5 common mistakes to avoid when getting rid of mice

Mouse gnawing electric cable
(Image credit: Shutterstock)

If you find a mouse in your home or outbuildings, more will likely follow. These rodents are unwelcome guests, so it's only natural that your first instinct will be to banish them from your property. Before springing into action though, it's best to consider how to get rid of mice from your home and what the most effective method will be.

When inside your home, mice can damage appliances and furniture and, at the extreme, gnaw through wires and cause electrical fires. They can also carry disease, bring ticks, fleas, and mites into your home, and contaminate your food and water with their droppings, so it’s important to be informed before taking action. 

Here are 5 common mistakes to avoid when getting rid of mice.

1. Ignoring the warning signs 

Mouse droppings

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

Spotting mice early is key to getting rid of the problem, as mice breed quickly, making the problem harder to resolve. There are plenty of telltale signs that you have mice in your home, including hearing scratching noises, especially at night or finding droppings in corners of rooms or near possible entry sites. 

Diagno Pest Control also warns that you might find nesting material, such as shreds of paper and fabric. Gnaw marks on furniture and food packaging are another sign, as is spotting visible entry points, such as gaps in walls, and windows. 

At this point, if you don’t take action to seal entry points and prevent mice from entering your home, you could be faced with a much bigger problem. 

Multiplying mice
Mice are prolific breeders and can produce six to seven babies in a litter in as little as 21 days. So, if you don’t get on top of the problem quickly, you could face an ever-increasing infestation. 

2. Not cleaning down food preparation surfaces 

Crumbs on a counter

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

Mice love to find morsels of food, so although a few food crumbs might seem insignificant, it can seem like a feast to a mouse. And they have an exceptional sense of smell. According to scientists at Harvard Medical School, mice have about 1,200 odor receptors, compared to humans, who have around 350. So, even if you can’t smell food remains, mice certainly can.

Hygiene is always important, especially if you have mice in your home. To keep your home clean, wipe down dining tables and countertops promptly and vacuum floor surfaces. Also, avoid leaving food uncovered and regularly declutter your kitchen to make it a less attractive refuge for mice.

3. Using the wrong bait 

Peanut butter in jar surrounded by peanuts

(Image credit: Getty Images)

A common mistake is using too much bait or the wrong bait to attract mice. According to Burns Pest Elimination, overloading a trap with bait can cause it to malfunction. Moreover, mice only need a morsel of food and may be able to take a nibble of bait without setting off the trap. Adding a smaller amount of bait will be more effective.

What bait attracts mice?
Rapid Rodent Removal suggests peanut butter, as its strong nutty smell will entice mice into your trap. Sweet and fatty foods are the best way to attract mice out of hiding, and the benefit of using a substance like nut butter or sticky jam is that mice are more likely to spend longer on the trap, giving it time to be triggered. 

Apart from nut butter and jam, chocolate and marshmallows (if you can spare them) will attract sweet-toothed mice, while seeds, nuts, deli meat, pet food, and soft cheese will also work.

4. Using a mouse trap wrong 

Mouse sitting onto on top of a lump of cheese on a mousetrap

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

Understanding the type of mouse traps available and the best place to position them will help deter your pest problem. However, using traps incorrectly can increase the problem.

Burns Pest Elimination warns against placing a mouse trap in the middle of a room. Mice stick close to walls and corners for protection and will be unlikely to risk scurrying across the middle of a floor with nowhere to hide, open to being pounced on by household pets.

Positioning traps close to walls and behind furniture is a better strategy, although don’t forget to check them! Victor Pests advises angling the bait and the trigger end of the trap towards the wall, as this will encourage the mice to explore what’s on offer immediately without walking around the trap.

Also, don’t forget that if you find one mouse, you’ve probably got more. So, if you are setting traps, put out a few. 

Types of mouse traps
The most humane type of mouse trap is a live trap and is the method advised by the Humane Society of the United States, which involves trapping the mouse without killing it. The mouse can then be moved outside and will hopefully not return if you’ve sealed up all possible entry points into your home. 

Humane Mouse Trap, 4 pack: $19 @ Amazon

Humane Mouse Trap, 4 pack: $19 @ Amazon
Catch mice in your home with this 4-pack of humane 'catch and release' traps. Designed to catch mice without harming them for them to be released back into the wild. These pet-friendly traps are easy to clean, contain a removable bait case and are reusable.

5. Using dangerous substances

A pile of poisoned wheat for rodent bait

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

Although you’ll be keen to banish mice from your home, it is possible without harmful chemicals. And while chemicals can be detrimental to pests, they can also put your household at risk.

Apart from being inhumane, poisons can also endanger your pets, as curious cats and dogs will be interested in any tempting bait. So, unless you’re calling a professional pest control company to help, we recommend avoiding the use of any dangerous substances.

If your attempts and controlling mice don't work, and you've called in a professional pest control company, it should be able to treat the affected area with the right proportion of products that do not harm your shared environment.

More from Tom's Guide

Camilla Sharman
Staff Writer, Homes

Camilla Sharman has worked in publishing and marketing for over 30 years and has covered a wide range of sectors within the business and consumer industries both as a feature, content, and freelance writer.  

As a business journalist, Camilla has researched articles for many different sectors from the jewellery industry to finance and tech, charities, and the arts. Whatever she’s covered, she enjoys delving deep and learning the ins and out of different topics, then conveying her research within engaging content that informs the reader. In her spare time, when she’s not in her kitchen experimenting with a new recipe, you’ll find her keeping fit at the gym. In the pool, stretching at a yoga class, or on a spin bike, exercise is her escape time. She also loves the great outdoors and if she’s not pottering about in her garden, she’ll be jumping on her bike for a gentle cycle ride.  

Read more
Mouse hiding in a Santa hat with Christmas gifts
Don’t let rodents ruin your holidays — 3 easy tips to keep them out of your home
Man sneezing into tissue
5 common cleaning mistakes that could make you sick — stop these now
Tineco Floor One S7 with iLoop Smart Sensor technology.
5 mistakes you’re making when cleaning floors — and expert tips to avoid them
A mosquito resting on a plant
3 pests to watch out for this spring — and expert tips to prevent them
Image shows a person in blue disposable gloves pointing to bed bugs on a mattress
You might be creating the perfect conditions for bed bugs to thrive in your mattress — here's why
A woman's hand holding a magnifying glass magnifying bed bugs on a mattress
3 home remedies that can actually get rid of bed bugs
Latest in Home
the baratza encore esp coffee grinder with a 200g capacity hopper, steel burr, with plastic black exterior
I just tested one of the most famous budget coffee grinders — and it lives up to its hype
the comandante c40 mk4 hand coffee grinder with a glass catch chamber and high nitrogen steel burrs
I tested this famous $300 hand-crank coffee grinder — and it's worth every penny
Cumulus Coffee Machine
I tried this high-tech coffee maker that makes nitro cold brew in seconds, and I'll never order an espresso martini at a bar again
Le Creuset Pokémon limited edition collection
You can now buy Le Creuset's Pokémon collection in the U.S. and I gotta catch 'em all
Cleaning with a mop in yellow bucket
Your cleaning tools are spreading dirt — here’s how to disinfect them properly
HomePod with display concept render
Apple HomePod with display now rumored for late 2025 launch
Latest in Features
A comparison photo showing a Helix mattress directly next to a Helix mattress topper
You need a new mattress but don't have the budget — is a new topper worth buying this World Sleep Day instead?
The iPhone 16 Pro Max (L) and Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra rear cameras
I took 200 macro photos with Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra vs. iPhone 16 Pro — here's the winner
Woman sleeping on a new mattress in a brightly lit room
Keep waking up at night? Your mattress might be stopping you from sleeping through — here's why
Pro-ject colorful Audio system
I gave up my $3,000 speakers for this stunning stereo system — and the results blew me away
Man performing a push-up on yellow exercise mat at home during workout
I just tried the ‘Chelsea’ CrossFit workout — and it strengthens your entire body with just 3 bodyweight exercises
Woman doing a yoga pose in bed against a green background
Sleep expert reveals her secret weapon for falling asleep fast — and you can do it in 15 minutes