YouTube's Super Chat Is Bad for the Internet

All speech is not equal, especially if it's on YouTube. CEO Susan Wojcicki said at Google I/O that the site is different from traditional media because it serves as a “two-way conversation,” allowing people to interact with those they watch.

Then, product manager Barbara Macdonald stepped on stage and proved that’s not true anymore. She showed off Super Chat, a tool for viewers to have their message highlighted during a livestream and pinned to the top of the stream for up to five hours. It’s not a brand new tool (it launched in January), but the company wanted to show off new APIs to make videos interactive to those who pay.

YouTube says that this makes sure that your chat “stands out from the crowd to get even more of your favorite creator’s attention,” but it won’t be because it’s in bright green; it’s because you paid them.

Now, don’t get me wrong here. Professional YouTubers work hard, and they deserve to earn a living. But this form of payment goes against the spirit of the Internet: that all speech is equal.

Not everyone can afford to give $5 (or more! On stage, Macdonald gave $500 to the Slow Mo Guys), but everyone with internet access can watch YouTube. Are the voices of people who have less disposable income less important?

That’s not to say YouTubers are aiming to leave anyone out, but it’s far easier to notice and respond to a message when they’re huge and colorful, and it’s hard to ignore them when there’s money attached. You can only respond to so many comments, after all. The voices of those with money are the voices that get heard.

MORE: The 10 Best YouTube Videos You Missed This Week

This also fetishizes YouTubers to a degree that can be uncomfortable. As TechCrunch suggested back in January, it’s somewhat similar to chat systems that live porn cam websites have used for a long time. You’re paying for attention, for a connection that’s not there when the camera shuts off.

YouTube isn’t the only site with a system like this. Twitch, a streaming service aimed at people playing video games, has a system called cheering in which audience members pay for emoticons that draw attention to their messages. It’s kind of gross, but the intent is slightly different — to celebrate during awesome moments (think like a tip jar for headshots in Call of Duty or goals in Rocket League). YouTube’s is purely for attention from the people you admire who make videos.

Earlier this month, Kotaku’s Cecilia D’Anastasio wrote an article about people who fall in love with Twitch streamers, and those who took that love further than is appropriate. Surely, there are people who believe they have connections with YouTubers, too, and they’ll be willing to pay to further those feelings.

The whole idea, paying for an e-celebrity's attention, is bad for the internet and its users. It’s a slow step in making sure the rich’s speech have more influence, and it can help further unhealthy obsessions with celebrity. If this is how YouTube is going to foster “two-way” conversation, it will leave a whole lot of people sitting on the sidelines.

TOPICS
Andrew E. Freedman

Andrew E. Freedman is an editor at Tom's Hardware focusing on laptops, desktops and gaming as well as keeping up with the latest news. He holds a M.S. in Journalism (Digital Media) from Columbia University. A lover of all things gaming and tech, his previous work has shown up in Kotaku, PCMag, Complex, Tom's Guide and Laptop Mag among others.

Latest in Internet
23andME box
23andMe has declared bankruptcy — here's how to delete your data now
Russian flag with padlock smashing through glass
47 VPNs could be axed from Google Play Store following Russian demands
A magnifying glass on top of the Steam logo in a web browser
Valve just pulled a malicious game demo spreading info-stealing malware from Steam
Obscura VPN website landing page
Obscura VPN wants to be the "best darn VPN out there" – can it?
A man filing his taxes electronically on a laptop
AI-powered tax scams are here - how to stay safe from deepfakes, phishing and more this tax season
MacBook Pro 2023
New Mac attack is tricking users into thinking their computer is locked — how to stay safe
Latest in Opinion
The Amazfit T-Rex 3 shown close-up on a user's wrist with the snorkeling and surfing workout tracking modes displayed; colorful flowers are out of focus in the background
7 reasons why this budget-friendly smartwatch is my new go-to for surfing and swimming
Apple maps logo on iPhone screen
I avoided Apple Maps for trip planning — but these iOS 18 features are changing my mind
Adam Scott in "Severance," now streaming on Apple TV Plus.
'Severance' season 3 officially greenlit — but I may not watch after that season 2 finale
Woman has taped her mouth shut with a blue I shaped mouth tape
I tried I-shaped mouth tape to fall asleep faster but now I'm more tired than ever — here's why
An angled view of the distraction-free desk setup I built around the Oakywood Standing Desk Pro
I built a completely distraction-free desk setup with these 10 gadgets — and now I’m truly locked in
A Samsung DU7200 LED TV on a side table
I'm a TV reviewer — here's the one type of TV I wouldn't buy
  • turkey3_scratch
    Youtube should be rid of all conversations because the comment sections are always the most pure trash filth on the Internet.
    Reply