OnePlus 6T vs. iPhone XR: Which Affordable Flagship Wins?

Flagship smartphones are getting more expensive every year, with Apple's $1,099 iPhone XS Max and Samsung's $999 Galaxy Note 9 leading the pack.

But you don't need to shell out $1,000 for flagship features. Apple's own iPhone XR offers best-in-class performance, lengthy battery life and a solid camera for $749, and the OnePlus 6T sports a stunning screen and cutting-edge in-display fingerprint sensor for $549. So which affordable flagship wins? It's a close race, but the XR takes the cake.

OnePlus 6T vs. iPhone XR: Specs Compared

  OnePlus 6TiPhone XR
Price$549$749
Display (Resolution)6.4-inch AMOLED (2340 x 1080)6.1-inch LCD (1792 x 828)
CPUSnapdragon 845A12 Bionic
RAM6GB, 8GBN/A
Storage128GB, 256GB64GB, 128GB, 256GB
Rear Camera16 MP (f/1.7), 20 MP (f/1.7)12 MP (f/1.8)
Front Camera16 MP (f/2.0)7 MP (f/2.2)
Battery Life10:2311:26
Size6.2 x 2.94 x 0.32 inches5.9 x 3.0 x 0.3 inches
Weight6.52 ounces6.8 ounces

Design

If you're tired of giant, shiny, nondescript black smartphones that are indistinguishable from one another, the OnePlus 6T isn't the device for you. The phone comes in two shades of black — a matte version and a shiny version —  and both are made entirely of glass. The 6T looks perfectly nice, but there's nothing particularly eye-catching about it.

The iPhone XR is also coated in glass but comes in six stunning shades: black, white, blue, yellow, coral and red. The lemony yellow is my personal favorite — it's as fun as the iPhone 5C's candy-coated colors were, but feels more high end. Each shade has a matching aluminum band around the frame, which is also a nice touch.

The XR is noticeably heavier than the 6T at 6.8 ounces to the 6T's 6.52 ounces, though the 6.2-inch-long 6T is taller than the 5.9-inch iPhone. Both phones are sleek and thin — 0.3 inches for the XR versus 0.32 inches for the 6T. But when it comes to style, the XR wins hands down.

Winner: iPhone XR

Display

Both the 6T and XR have nearly bezel-free displays with notches, but there's no mistaking the two.

The lowest-priced iPhone's screen is a sizable 6.1 inches, but Apple cut costs by providing an LCD panel instead of offering a pricier OLED display. The OnePlus 6T's 6.4-inch AMOLED panel is absolutely brilliant by comparison — its massive 2340 x 1080 slate is the clear winner when placed next to the iPhone's 1792 x 828 screen.

Then there's the notch. The iPhone XR has a shallow but wide cutout for its front-facing camera, while the 6T's dewdrop-shaped notch is so small as to be almost completely unobtrusive.

The XR wins points for brightness, as all LCD panels do. The panel reached 589 nits on our lab test, while the 6T's AMOLED reached 405 nits.

Overall, the 6T's richer, more vivid, larger display is the winner, especially at its price.

Winner: OnePlus 6T

Camera

The OnePlus 6T has a dual-lens camera with 20-MP and 16-MP shooters, but the iPhone XR's lone 12-MP lens still wins in our comparison tests.

OnePlus improved the 6T's low-light photos and portraits with software tweaks, so we compared both modes to the iPhone XR. The iPhone doesn't have a Nightscape mode that's comparable to the 6T's, and its Portrait Mode only works on humans. And yet, the XR still comes out ahead.

In a challenging low-light shot of a Halloween display, I turned on the 6T's Night mode to capture both the colorful display and the brownstone behind it. The 6T turned out a shot that was brighter overall than the iPhone XR's, but the OnePlus phone also struggled with the lamplight directly in front of the inflatable monster.

The XR retained the detail in the shot, even though it was darker than the 6T's, while turning the glow from the lamp into an artistic lens flare. The 6T's shot was overexposed, turning the glow from the lamp into the focal point of the photo.

In Portrait Mode, the OnePlus 6T set me farther back from the camera than the iPhone XR, despite being taken from the exact same spot. The XR also captured a warmer, more color-accurate photo. The hue of my hair was more true-to-life in the iPhone's portrait when compared to the 6T's.

The same was true of the colors in selfies, which were dark and muted in the 6T's image, while being more vibrant and true-to-life in the iPhone's.

Overall, the iPhone XR has a better camera, despite lacking a second lens.

Winner: iPhone XR

Performance

The OnePlus 6T sports a Snapdragon 845 processor and 6GB of RAM (or 8GB if you splurge on the $579 model), so it can easily compete against more expensive Android flagships. On the Geekbench 4 test of overall system performance, the 6T notched 8,972, sailing past the Google Pixel 3 XL with its score of 7,684, and even topping the Galaxy Note 9's 8,876 peak.

But the iPhone XR's A12 Bionic chip is an unbeatable beast. The XR scored 11,312 on Geekbench 4, just behind the XS (11,420) and XS Max (11,515). Apple's custom chips are unmatched.

Even in a real-world test, transcoding a 2-minute, 4K video file into 1080 in Adobe Premiere, the XR crushes the competition. Apple's newest iPhone completed the task in just 40 seconds, while the 6T finally finished at 3 minutes and 45 seconds.

Winner: iPhone XR

Battery Life

The iPhone XR isn't just a performance powerhouse — it also offers great battery life. The phone lasted 11 hours and 26 minutes on the Tom's Guide Battery Test of continuous web surfing over T-Mobile's LTE network. The smartphone average is 9:48, so the iPhone XR easily landed on our list of the longest-lasting smartphones.

The OnePlus 6T's battery life isn't too shabby, either, clocking in at 10:23. But the iPhone XR can last more than an hour longer, which is a big deal when you're on the go without a charger.

MORE: iPhone XR Battery Life: The Results Are In

The 6T has one advantage: Its Dash Charge technology enables you to juice up the phone over a USB Type-C cable from 0 to 60 percent in just 30 minutes. The iPhone XR doesn't offer USB-C fast charging out of the box — you'll have to shell out an additional $50 for a USB-C fast-charging brick and a USB-C-to-Lightning adapter to get from 0 to 50 percent in a half hour.

A negative for the OnePlus: The 6T doesn't support wireless charging, while the iPhone XR does.

Winner: iPhone XR

Software and Special Features

The iPhone XR has all the features iPhone users love and expect: The latest version of iOS 12, complete with support for dual SIM cards, Group FaceTime, new emojis and real-time depth-of-field editing in Portrait Mode.

But the OnePlus 6T's lightning fast in-display fingerprint sensor feels like magic, and it's the first of its kind in the U.S. The iPhone XR offers Face ID, but if you prefer a fingerprint sensor to face scanning, the 6T is the way to go.

OnePlus also offers OxygenOS, which is its own elegant take on Android Pie, with gesture-based navigation similar to the iPhone's and a Smart Boost app-launching feature that makes smartphone games load times speedy and seamless. (I tested this with PUBG Mobile and found it worked as promised, compared to an older OnePlus 6 without Smart Boost.)

MORE: Forget the iPhone XS: iPhone Rumors Are Already Here

If you're committed to Apple's ecosystem, the iPhone XR is a sensible pick. But the OnePlus 6 could woo iPhone users with its fingerprint sensor and sophisticated software.

Winner: OnePlus 6T

Value and Availability

You won't find a better Android phone for your money than the $549 OnePlus 6T, which costs $200 less than the iPhone XR and offers features Apple's $749 iPhone doesn't have, such as a dual-lens camera and an in-display fingerprint sensor (which some people prefer).

The 6T also benefits from OnePlus' partnership with T-Mobile, which gives buyers the chance to snag a OnePlus device in the store for once, and even offers a financing option that wasn't available for past OnePlus devices. You can also buy a 6T unlocked online to use on Verizon or AT&T.

The iPhone XR is more widely available, but also costs more, making the 6T a better deal.

Winner: OnePlus 6T

Overall Winner: iPhone XR

  OnePlus 6TiPhone XR
Design (10)79
Display (15)1412
Cameras (20)1517
Performance (10)810
Battery Life (20)1619
Software and Special Features (10)98
Value and Availability (15)1412
Overall (100)8387

The iPhone XR is Apple's most affordable new iPhone, and it's just as capable as Apple's pricier models in most areas. The OnePlus 6T undercuts the XR on price, but its camera isn't as good, its battery life isn't as lengthy and its processor isn't as powerful as what the XR offers.

If you don't want to spend $749, the 6T is a solid option, especially for buyers who prefer Android and want a fingerprint sensor. For everyone else, the iPhone XR ekes out the win.

Credit: Tom's Guide

Create a new thread in the iPhone forum about this subject
8 comments
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
  • prabhujay01
    You don't know how much RAM is in an iPhone XR or don't want to put it in your data for comparison?
  • webgtlnbrgrs
    I phone hands down .. So I'll tell you PRABHUJAYO1 4GB of RAM … iPhone XR still blows the doors off the One Plus … My Son has One Plus and my Wife iPhone XR ...
  • webgtlnbrgrs
    3 GB of RAM... Still blows the doors off the One Plus …
  • mdh2006
    Lol, Xr design is better? How? Because it comes in ugly colors that will be cover d up with a case anyway???
  • prabhujay01
    Anonymous said:
    3 GB of RAM... Still blows the doors off the One Plus …



    Once again, not my point. Why not just put the data in the data table? My original post didn't mention perofrmance. It was WHY they left the table incomplete. Does that make sense to you?
  • prabhujay01
    Anonymous said:
    I phone hands down .. So I'll tell you PRABHUJAYO1 4GB of RAM … iPhone XR still blows the doors off the One Plus … My Son has One Plus and my Wife iPhone XR ...



    All I'm asking is why they didn't complete the table that mentions how much RAM the XR contains. It says "N/A." I have owned both Apple and Android and I try to keep an objective perspective. Everyone knows how much RAM each of the phones in the article has but Tom's Guide for some reason chose not to mention that piece of information for the XR....why? I know Apple performs better but that's not my point. I want complete information. I may or may not own an iPhone XR but I want one of my favorite tech sites to REMAIN objective and so I question why they left the information off the data table. Do you understand now??? If you STILL don't understand what I'm talking about, look a the data table in the article and then reread my original post and try not to read between the lines again.
  • rgd1101
    Multiple posts deleted. Please read the forum rule.
  • cenon415
    Anonymous said:
    I phone hands down .. So I'll tell you PRABHUJAYO1 4GB of RAM … iPhone XR still blows the doors off the One Plus … My Son has One Plus and my Wife iPhone XR ...

    I'm not sure about the XR blowing the doors off, after watching this video. They're pretty much on par with each other in terms of performances.
    https://youtu.be/gg-u1FDqDXo