How 3D Printing Will Transform Chinese Manufacturing (Op-Ed)

Melba Kurman, author, and Hod Lipson, Cornell University associate professor in mechanical and aerospace engineering, contributed this article to LiveScience's Expert Voices: Op-Ed & Insights.

Compared to the United States and Europe, China has gotten off to a slow start as a 3D-printing powerhouse. But that's going to change rapidly.

On a recent book tour in China, we witnessed first-hand how 3D printing (pronounced like "san D da eeng" in Chinese) is igniting people's imaginations. Recently, Chinese astronauts sat in 3D-printed seats on their historic space flight. Each printed seat was tailored specially for that particular astronaut’s unique size and shape. On the industrial front, China is now home to seven 3D printer manufacturers, including a consumer-level model called the UP!. And, United States-based Stratasys (the largest 3D printer company in the world) employs about 150 employees in its Hong Kong office and plans to open an office in Beijing. 

Not everyone in China has embraced the potential of 3D-printing technologies. Terry Gou, the high-profile chairman of Foxconn, has been an outspoken skeptic of the notion that 3D printing will trigger a new industrial revolution. Gou created a media buzz recently when he told reporters that "3D printing is a gimmick. If it really is that good, then I'll write my surname 'Gou' backwards."  In Chinese culture, offering to re-arrange the spelling of your family name is a bold statement.

The UP! 3D printer, billed as the \

The UP! 3D printer, billed as the "Micro Factory for Anyone Anywhere Anytime." The UP! is sold by PP3DP, a subsidiary of Delta Micro Factory Corporation, and costs about $1,500.

Gou makes a valid point. China's 3D-printing industry won't replace factories and mass production. In fact, if anyone doubts that mass manufacturing is here to stay, they need only to watch an industrial robot in action. 

In Beijing, we wandered into a manufacturing trade show right next door to a 3D printing conference. Gou would have enjoyed the demos of state-of-the-art, robotic, high-speed mass-manufacturing machines. A few yards away from a meeting of experts speaking about the next industrial revolution and 3D printing, on the trade show floor we watched industrial robots pick, place and assemble parts so quickly that in comparison, a human worker would seem sluggish — not to mention an even slower-moving 3D printer.

In the short term, 3D printing won't make a dent in China's mass production empire. In China, as in the United States, mass-produced commodity goods — where yours is the same as everyone else's and that's ok — will always be made using traditional factory machines. Instead, 3D-printing technology will serve as a catalyst to ease China's evolution into providing high-tech manufacturing and related services.

The process of creating 3D solid objects from a digital computer model.

The process of creating 3D solid objects from a digital computer model.

3D-printed products will continue to creep into the medical, dental and aerospace industries where customers are willing to pay a premium for custom products. In industries that aren't built on "markets of one," 3D printing will help product designers accelerate the design process. In fact, the consumer electronics industry has been, and will continue to be, one of heaviest users of 3D printing to test out and refine product design concepts. And that's no gimmick, Mr. Gou.

MORE: 10 Amazing 3D-Printing Startups

Moving toward higher-tech manufacturing

To understand the excitement about 3D printing in China, it helps to look at the nation's 12th (and current) Five-Year Plan. The Chinese economy is centrally steered by the government, which sets broad goals for the nation every five years. Over the next five years, China intends to evolve from being "the factory for the world" into a knowledge-driven economy based on innovative products and processes.

Here are some of the key goals from the Five-Year Plan that relate to 3D printing:

  • Maintain a strong mass-manufacturing base, but move up the value chain to high-margin, skilled-labor products in biotech, new materials, IT and specialized, high-end manufacturing;
  • Grow the research and development (R&D) base and invest in universities;
  • Develop the biotechnology and medical-device industries and expand high-end equipment manufacturing, in particular for aerospace and telecommunications equipment; and
  • Reduce growing income disparities between low-wage, unskilled workers and China's growing middle- and upper-classes. 

The advantages of a large domestic population

Looking into the future, China's massive population will accelerate the adoption of 3D-printed manufacturing. China's huge domestic market of consumers is becoming more sophisticated in its tastes. This increasingly affluent consumer base will demand novel and custom products that require advanced engineering and manufacturing capabilities. 

MORE: Dos and Don'ts for Doing Business in China

The Chinese government is investing in higher education in anticipation of a shift to a higher-skilled manufacturing economy. China will soon face the same labor challenges the United States is already grappling with. By educating more of its population, the Chinese government hopes to mitigate the potentially devastating double impact of factory automation and jobs lost to even cheaper labor markets. The result is that China's skilled workforce is growing rapidly. The number of students entering and graduating from Chinese universities has skyrocketed — from 1.6 million new students in 1999 to 7.5 million in 2012 — according to the China National Bureau of Statistics.

University research-project teams at Chinese universities are equally well-resourced. A single research project in an engineering department at one of China's top universities might have 50 graduate students working on different nuances of the same problem. China boasts millions of new university graduates, a large consumer population and well-funded academic research. The result will be a tremendous amount of intellectual horsepower that will rapidly enrich the nation's scientific and industrial knowledge-base.

MORE: 3D Printing: From Doodads To Prosthetic Hands | Video

At a height of about two stories high, this may be the world's largest metal 3D printer. At Northwestern Polytechnical University (NPU) in Xi'an, professor Huang Weidong (second from left) has successfully printed precisely shaped titanium airplane parts

At a height of about two stories high, this may be the world's largest metal 3D printer. At Northwestern Polytechnical University (NPU) in Xi'an, professor Huang Weidong (second from left) has successfully printed precisely shaped titanium airplane parts

The challenges

Yet, China also faces unique challenges. Chinese R&D and 3D-printer manufacturers still lag Western companies in the development of novel materials for 3D printing.  

Another challenge will be open communication. The Internet is a key component of the quick innovation that characterizes digital manufacturing. Yet, the Chinese government still censors the Internet with a filtering system sometimes called the Great Firewall. 

As the ingenuity of Chinese Internet users continues to grow, along with their determination to speak openly, the Chinese government has responded by increasing its efforts to crack down on Web-based dissent. Governmental censors stifle the rapid spread of new ideas that come from the collective buzz of Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, Google News and Web searches.

Another challenge that's perhaps not unique to China is the fact that mass manufacturing supply chains won't be suitable for 3D-printed manufacturing. Mass manufacturers use centrally controlled, or what some describe as "monolithic supply chains," to produce commodity products. Such a centrally managed approach won't work well as highly specialized 3D-printed parts begin to play an increasing role in mass-produced products. 

In the future, as manufacturing companies begin attempting to introduce small of batches of custom-made 3D-printed parts into their traditional supply chains, precise, responsive inventory management will become critical. An operational strategy that's suitable for making millions of simple and identical toasters won't be able to keep track of 3D-printed components for complex end-products

Finally, to deeply integrate 3D-printing technology into its design and manufacturing processes, China will need to aggressively re-think its intellectual-property laws. Change may be afoot, however. In anticipation of China's evolution from a mostly factory-based economy to one built on high-end manufacturing and knowledge work, the Chinese government is starting to tighten its intellectual-property laws. Global management consulting firm McKinsey & Co. reports that in 2012, "The Chinese government ministry charged with prosecuting intellectual-property violations recently announced that it handled 2,347 cases in 2012, up almost 40 percent from 2011, and over those two years, resolved $2 billion in violations."

China's national agenda has its eyes firmly fixed on building a knowledge-based economy where 3D-printing technologies will play a vital role. Chinese culture values self-discipline, hard work and respect for authority, beliefs that have enabled China to rapidly transform into the world's largest economy. It will be interesting to see China's factory for the world put 3D-printing technologies to work.  

This story was provided by LiveScience, a sister site to Tom's Guide, from its Expert Voices: Op-Ed & Insights section. Kuman and Lipson's most recent Op-Ed was How 3D Printing Will Transform Chinese Manufacturing.  Co-authors of "Fabricated: The New World of 3D Printing" (John Wiley & Sons, 2013), Lipson and Kurman are leading voices in the field of 3D printing. Follow Kurman @melbakurman. This article is part of their new LiveScience series highlighting issues and developments in 3D-printing technology. The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher. This article was originally published on

  • digiex
    Injection molding is still the king in mass production, while 3D printing is very good in prototyping. The advantage of 3D printing to manufacturers is that it will reduce the time to market considerably.
  • f-14
    3D printing with downloadable or media transferable blue prints for untraceable guns in china?
    that's just not going to happen in china if the chinese government has it's way.

    the potential for assassinations of communist party members and leaders and revolution is just to great.
    3D Printing is quite primitive as it is implemented now, and anyone can do it. The current technology and process is nothing more than an automated software driven version of the manufacturing used over the last 50 years.

    However, when a certain expertise is achieved with wielding the 3D printing process, you can then add advanced technology into the mix. China DOES NOT have the capability to form shapes out of carbon nano tube fibers... the US will be there a decade before anyone else, and that is all it will take for manufacturing dominance.
  • gm0n3y
    "Chinese culture values self-discipline, hard work and respect for authority"...

    I don't think that Chinese culture values a "respect" for authority. Fear would be a better term. Its hard to say that one of the most corrupt cultures/countries on Earth is respectful of authority. I guess time will tell if they are able to crack down on intellectual property infringement.
  • none12345
    At this point in time, 3D printers will have almost no impact on mass manufacturing.

    The injection molding process produces almost no waste, and its extremely fast compared to a 3d printer. Also uses far less energy. No matter how good 3d printers get, it probalby will never replace injection molding for simple items.

    For prototyping, 3d printers rule. Even tho they have been used for this purpose for about 25 years now, the price coming down will make them much more prolific for this purpose.

    For customization, 3d printers will rule. But this is a niche industry, not mass market.

    3d printers hold a lot of promise, but they are still a long way off for being a game changer for the common person.
  • atminside
    this could put a lot of Chinese manufacturing labors out of work
  • lordjakian
    "China DOES NOT have the capability to form shapes out of carbon nano tube fibers... "

    Oh ye of little faith. Believe a little more in globalization and the sharing of ideas.----->corporate espionage.