Source: Tom's Guide | Keywords: sony, toshiba, 12-inch | Themes: Business Notebooks, Laptops and Notebooks, Business
- 1. 12" Power Notebooks
- 2. HP Compaq 2510p: Design, Weight, Quality
- 3. HP Compaq 2510p: Hardware, Software, Usability
- 4. HP Compaq 2510p: Features, Heat, Noise
- 5. Samsung P200-Pro: Design, Weight, Quality
- 6. Samsung P200-Pro: Hardware, Software, Usability
- 7. Samsung P200-Pro: Features, Heat, Noise
- 8. Sony VAIO VGN-G21XP: Design, Weight, Quality
- 9. Sony VAIO VGN-G21XP: Hardware, Software, Usability
- 10. Sony VAIO VGN-G21XP: Features, Heat, Noise
- 11. Toshiba Portégé R500: Design, Weight, Quality
- 12. Toshiba Portégé R500: Hardware, Software, Usability
- 13. Toshiba Portégé R500: Features, Noise, Heat
- 14. Benchmark Testing
- 15. Application Testing, Battery Testing, Noise Level
- 16. Conclusion: Underdog, Sprinter, Endurance Racer and Flyweight
- 17. Spec Sheet
- 18. More on this topic
10. Sony VAIO VGN-G21XP: Features, Heat, Noise
Features
The keys of the trackpad are only 1.5 x 1.5 cm wide. If you’re used to a desktop keyboard you’ll feel at home, because all the keys are right where you would expect them; the only exceptions are the Up/Down, Home/End, Roll, Pause and Break keys, which can all be reached using the Fn-menu. The common Fn shortcuts like brightness, volume and so forth are also provided; the right Windows key is missing, though.
The key stoppers are very soft and don’t have a well-defined pressure point; you’ll miss the feedback during typing, especially in the spacebar. The keyboard bends down at the sides, but this is more of an optical issue than it is bothersome while writing. Sometimes single keys tend to make a cracking noise, but other than that, everything works as it should.
The trackpad is hardly noteworthy, but this is meant in a very positive way — it is fast, precise and does not over-respond. The same is true for its buttons. However, we would appreciate more resistance and a more clearly-defined pressure point.
Display
The LED back light of the 12" display makes it very bright, reaching up to 302 cd/m². Even the darkest spot still emits 239 cd/m², and on average we measured 296 cd/m². The black level is a very high 1.63 cd/m²; the bright illumination makes the contrast result in 165:1. Black and dark colors are okay, but we wouldn’t mind if they were a little bit stronger. Red, yellow and skin color tones are a little dull. With 1024x768 pixels the display has the lowest resolution of all the candidates.
The light distribution is even on the right half of the display, but it increases from the middle towards the left side. At the bottom edge of the display you can see three darker spots; depending on the perspective, the difference in brightness there is more or less noticeable. If the display is dark, this effect is inverted, and the areas between those shades turn into stretched bright stripes.
The cover lid opens easily, but it also moves either forward or backward when jerked quickly. The horizontal viewing angle is sufficiently wide. When looking from the bottom text stays readable but colors invert quickly; when viewed from the top, even text is barely legible and colors get weaker, but due to the wide opening angle of the lid, you should always be able to find a position that works for you.
Temperature
Even when idle, the right underbody with its cooling air exit gets noticeably warm, but if you don’t block the airflow causing the heat to accumulate, the VAIO will stay cool enough to put it on your lap.
Under full load the Sony fan is really challenged by the processor’s heat and the exhaust air gets uncomfortably hot. You don’t want to direct it onto exposed skin like arms or legs, and the underbody gets even warmer. If you want to rest it on your lap make sure to put some cloth between your skin and the notebook.
Noise Level
The fan on the VAIO spins even when idle. In spite of the fan’s high speed, noise stays comfortably quiet at 32 dB(A). Similar to the other notebooks, you will be reminded of a small fan trying to keep the processor cool under full load, which results in a noise level of 40 dB(A).
- Previous page Sony VAIO VGN-G21XP: Hardware,...
- Next page Toshiba Portégé R500: Design, Weight,...








Why only these four?
The Acer Travelmate 6293 (or older 6292 model) competes well with these models. The review would have been much more useful if you had included the Acer.
What about x300, x61, d430 etc.... the review is grate, just pour choice of Notebook's if you ask me.
Nice article, especialy useful in times when mini-notebooks, or netbooks come to be more and more popular. I am owner of HP 2510p almost 6 months and I love this notebook. It was extremly cheap for me - just 450USD from ebay. Small, well featured, ultra-light /1.6kg/ and 6-7h on 6-cell battery. Btw I think that overlaping battery is quite useful - just try it - as IT admin I use it every day - one can hold this notebook easily in one hand while doing many common service work, and type with other hand. I got my HP with Windows XP Pro, so its much faster than with Vista. I installed tripple boot on it, XP Pro, Ubuntu and Mac OSX 10.5.4 - just used external USB WiFi for Mac OSX, all other HW is working in all OSs.
I never understand while to bother with popular trends like Asus Eee - no DVD, limited HDD options, extremly LOW battery time /I expected much better performances with Atom and SSDs/, small size-display like from Gullivers fairy-tale. Thers only one good point - price. And its fun that if you want all these features on new EEE-like notebooks, you have to pay 500-700USD. So why not to pay more and have all fetures together like in HP 2510p or Toshiba R500. Or try ebay like me, and its even cheaper than new EEEs with Atom.
But maybe I am wrong and EEE targets different audience.
I cant believe you have done a review user "power" and "12.1" in the same sentence and failed to include uber powerful Asus U6V. My god this thing would blow your choices out of the water for under $1700 anywhere in north america!
HP recently introduced the 2530p with substantially faster ULV processors (up to the SL9400, 1.86GHz, 6MB L2 Cache, 1066MHz FSB) and with 2 DIMM slots for up to 8GB of 800MHz DDR SDRAM. It weighs a little more with a starting weight of 3.16lbs, but with some additonal durability features built-in, it meets the Mil-Std-810F standards for vibration, dust, humidity, altitude and high temperature. The spec's can be found at this URL:
http://h18000.www1.hp.com/products [...] 01_na.HTML
The 2510p will be going away shortly so the 2530p is the one to look at if one is considering HP.
HP also introduced the 2230s with a 12.1" screeen, and although it weighs a little more than the 2530p, it boasts a regular mobile processor such as an Intel® Core™2 Duo Processor P8400 (2.26 GHz, 1066 MHz FSB, 3 MB L2 cache). This is a new form factor for HP as this model did not replace any existing models, but rather it is a new addition to HP's notebook lineup.
Marcus
The Top Floor