Google Street View Controversy: Next Up Germany
Source: Tom's Guide US | Keywords: google, maps, street, view, germany | Themes: The Internet
It seems like there’s no end to the trouble Google is seeing because of its Street View endeavors.
The New York Times today reports that Germany is getting in line behind the UK and Japan when it comes to countries who have a problem with the search company’s plan to photograph the streets of the world and put them online for the world to see. According to the Times, Johannes Caspar, the data protection regulator for the German city-state of Hamburg (the location of Google’s German headquarters) yesterday threatened Google with “unspecified sanctions” if the company did not agree to make a certain changes to the service.
German privacy law prevents anyone from taking photos of someone else or their property without their consent and Mr. Casper told the NYT that a total of 300 people in Germany have complained to local officials about Google taking photographs for Street View.
Google has yet to set a date for the launch of Street View Germany, however Casper told the New York Times that if Google does not provide written guarantees on 12 points by 10 a.m. (local time) today, they will have no other alternative than to investigate possibility of sanctions.
Related links:
-
Previous News Article
Craigslist Sues South Carolina... -
Next News Article
GPS Navigation May Fail Next Year








Ahhahhaahahhaha!!!
Poor Google, so many people around the world are terrified of having their houses' pictures taken. I could drive down the street and look at the house, even stare at it, even draw myself a picture of it, but my the Lord help me if I try to take a picture of it.
Would Google give me a cut of that money they make for advertisement on Google Maps if I provide a picture of my house?
I wonder how Google Streetview Iraq will go?
Wanted: one suicidal man to drive an armored car.
lol wounder how many are up to no good and it will be posted. Have nothing to hide; nothing to fear
I drove by the Street View car in Pickering (a suburb of Toronto). I might be in a picture.
^That was just 20 minutes ago BTW^
I hope they take a picture of my place. It would be much easier to give people directions if they could actually SEE my house.
poor Google but, i have to agree that they should not be taking picture of people homes, for a few reasons. one is they have windows you never know what they might get a picture of. also if some one trying to sell there home and there house was in bad shape and some on looked at Google street to see it may turn off potential buyers. it also makes a thief's life easier he can learn what are better neighborhoods to steel from.
What the hell is wrong with these "privacy" freaks? The ACLU and their kind are just out of control, even in other countries. What the deuce does anyone get from a streetview picture? They're entirely trying to stop humanity's progress.
For instance, cell phones that have built in GPS that show where your friends are (think Marauder's map from the Harry Potter books), will tectonically change society as we know it - we'll be able to hang out more with friends and family who we may have just passed by on the street without even knowing they were there. And they will be able to send an immediate SOS to authorities if you're ever kidnapped or in trouble. This is progress and these privacy jerks are out to stop it.
Google should team up with NGA and teach those sissy short wearing European a thing or two about privacy.
or your carrier or the government.
Progress is a subjective term.
Believe it or not I don't have some weird shelter in my basement and I don't subscribe to consipracy theories, but I'm not a fan of being tracked. I like my privacy.
The cell tracking thing is opt in, so its a non-issue (and whether you like it or not, the carrier and the gov't can already track your cell signal anyways). Google taking photos of your house doesn't give anyone any more information than they could already easily obtain.
These people don't realize they are just creating their own Streisand Effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect).
If they just didn't make a fuss, who would even bother to look up the street view and notice their house? There are terabytes/petabytes(exabytes?) of data available from Google, how is someone going to accidently come across a picture of your house, and then use that maliciously? Trust me, if someone already has the intent of being maliscious towards you, they don't need google streetview telling them where you live or what your house looks like.
I don't get the fuss with people complaining about Street View, but if that's the law in Germany than Google shouldnt do street view in Germany. Fuck 'em. At least we still have Google Earth to make sure the German's aren't building any new camps.
oh no! someone saw your house! on a public street of all places!
get over it
I'm tired of Google going around thinking they are God like we are in their snow globe, that they get to peer in and shake things up like this. Who gives them the right?
I'm tired of Google going around thinking they are God like we are in their snow globe, that they get to peer in and shake things up like this. Who gives them the right?
In Germany when photographing someone's property? Nothing - they are in the wrong (apparently).
In the USA when photographing someone's property? Their right to travel in a public place and let their eyes (and maybe cameras) look about.
I like how my wife defines privacy: Its what you have inside your house when you make an effort to secure it. This means if you want to walk around naked, then you need to shut your curtains. If you want to watch pr0n without anyone knowing, then freaking don't set your TV volume to max. However, you don't have the right to tell someone they can't look at your house from a PUBLIC space, like a road or from an airplane.
what kind of sanctions are we talking about here?
No becks beer. They won't stop sending BMW's over.... they need the money.
I think they're more worried cos of stories like this:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uk [...] roofs.html
Big Brother is watching you.
I have no idea what the problem is. People are nuts.