camcorder question

Forum Other Consumer Electronics : Other Consumer Electronics - camcorder question

TomsGuide.com: Over 800,000 questions and answers to address all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

i'm looking for my first digital camcorder. in the 300 to 400 price range..
i'm looking for one that i can download it to my PC. so i can burn it to a CD.
i have notice some of them still come with a tape, like the minidv.
an are the ones that uses the Mini-DVD any good?
i have a VHS-C camcorder. that's a few years old. do they make a cable to transfer it to the PC. i don't want to use a program like Digital Video Creator. I've tried it an couldn't get it to work rite. thank you for any help

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

If you are buying a new vidcam, be sure it (and your computer) has a Firewire or IEEE 1394a port on it - Sony calls their version an iLink port. These are by far the best way to transfer digital video files with sound between computer and camera.
As for miniDV using tape versus DVD camera, I have experience only with a Sony unit that does digital video on tape, but can also play back older analog video tapes such as the Hi8 system. Works well, but I'm pretty sure the more modern trend is away from tape towards DVD or HDD systems.
Regarding your older VHS-C system, here's how I would do it. I fully expect the new camera will have a cable that allows you to input to it a composite video signal and stereo sound from outside, so that the camera can record it just like a VCR can. And I'm assuming your old VHS-C system has a similar output connection. So in the simple case you copy tapes from the VHS-C collection onto the new camera. Then you transfer the stuff from new camera into the computer.
But even better, you should be able to skip a step. Some of the new cameras (my Sony does this) will take an input composite signal and instantly put it out on the Firewire port as a digital signal into the computer. (You connect up the stereo sound inputs to the new camera, too, of course.) So you don't even need to record the old material onto the new camera as an intermediate step. Just playing it back from old VHS-C camera through the new camera into the computer via Firewire could do it all in one step.

When shopping for the new vidcam, ask carefully about how you could do the old-tape-to-computer thing. In one step or two, as outlined above. I will warn you that many mass-market retail stores' staff will not know the answer, and they may try to give you a load of BS. But someone should know. In fact, ask them to demo it all working, just to prove it!

Reply to Paperdoc
- 0 +

Your best bet is a Panasonic 3ccd MiniDV camcorder. With 3 seperate CCD chips (one for each color: RED, GREEN, BLUE) just like component video cables, it offers the best picture in that price class.

And believe it or not, MiniDV has higher bit rates and better editing options as it records in a (fairly) uncompressed format, to where the DVD camcorders record in MPEG2 (which is outdated and in-effecient).

Reply to Noya

I have a TRV-140 if you want any feedback about it. I might even be willing to sell it :o

Reply to scarslilpyro

I have a Sony miniDV that I love! The video quality is amazing with s-video. I do not know about the options today, but if my 4 y/o camera is amazing I can only imagine what the ones today are like.

I personally would not do DVD as I like to transfer the videos to the computer and re-use the tapes. I can edit and burn DVD videos for viewing after the transfer, or just plug the camera in the TV for immediate viewing.

If I were buying a new one today I would look at the ones with a built-in hard drive as opposed to tape, but that is just me and I don't know what their prices are.

Unless you are totally sure what you want go to Best Buy or Circuit City and after 2-3 weeks if you don't like it you can return it. If you are sure of what you want I'd buy it on-line. Of course you can return on-line, but it is not as easy as going to a store.

Reply to mickeddie
- 0 +

Quote :

Unless you are totally sure what you want go to Best Buy or Circuit City and after 2-3 weeks if you don't like it you can return it. If you are sure of what you want I'd buy it on-line. Of course you can return on-line, but it is not as easy as going to a store.



Unfortunately, Best Buy now charges a hefty 15% re-stocking fee.

Reply to Noya

Quote :

Unless you are totally sure what you want go to Best Buy or Circuit City and after 2-3 weeks if you don't like it you can return it. If you are sure of what you want I'd buy it on-line. Of course you can return on-line, but it is not as easy as going to a store.



Unfortunately, Best Buy now charges a hefty 15% re-stocking fee.

On every item?

Compusa recently only charges 15% for wireless products

Reply to scarslilpyro
- 0 +

Quote :

Unless you are totally sure what you want go to Best Buy or Circuit City and after 2-3 weeks if you don't like it you can return it. If you are sure of what you want I'd buy it on-line. Of course you can return on-line, but it is not as easy as going to a store.



Unfortunately, Best Buy now charges a hefty 15% re-stocking fee.

On every item?

Compusa recently only charges 15% for wireless products

On every camera and camcorder. I just purchased a Canon S3 last week and it and all the others had a sticker across the box opening stating that if it was opened and returned a 15% restocking fee would be deducted. That is sorry, e-shopping is looking better everday.

Reply to Noya
Tom's Guide > Forum > Other Consumer Electronics > Other Consumer Electronics > camcorder question
Go to:

There are 9 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Google ads