Would it be bad (amd)
Forum CPU & Components : CPUs - Would it be bad (amd)
hello folks
next month my pc is 3 years old. time to get a change.
what i need is/are:
-CPU, mobo, ram, hdd, OS, gpu.
what i'm planning to recycle:
-case, psu( xilence 600W)
so some questions for you all: would i go for socket 775? or the PII from amd?
can somebody tell me a good asus mobo for those PII's? (<150euro's)
ram: no problem to pick them. but wich mhz? ddr2?
hdd: 500 WD
gpu: 9800GTX+ or 4850
total cost: 750-800 euro's, i know it's tight, but i need a new system, and i'm not a hardcore gamer enymore. (asking myself if i was... my gaming years are over
)
so if you count if, i'm really stuck on the cpu!!
help please
or should i go for DELL I7 system: 750gb, 3gb ddr3, I7 920 and 4850 for less then 1000 euro's
If you are competent in building pc's then dont get the dell.
I think you are right on the fence between getting a phenom 2 940 or a Q9550 and an i7 920. Since you already have some parts to reuse and you dont need a powerful videocard you might be able to get an i7 system. IMO if you go with i7 then you should be getting at least 6GB or DDR3.
If you are looking for an asus mobo for the phenom 2 then get one with either a 790gx or 790fx northbridge and southbridge 750.
My suggestion is to try to make it work with i7, if you cant then go with the phenom 2.
nsimo86 thanks,
i ham using a new screen 22inch, so i need a gpu that is strong enough to handle 1600x1200 resolution
can you advise me one?
about I7: 920 costs 296 euros vs pII 940 that cost 280
Message edited by vochtige on 01-19-2009 at 07:17:53 PM
even though the cpu costs are similar, i7 requires a more expensive mobo and DDR3 RAM.
I would see how much all the components excluding a gpu would cost you and then see how much money is left for the gpu. If you go i7 you'll probably be limited to a 4850 or 9800gtx. If you go phenom 2 you could go for a better card.
I am from the US so i dont really know where to buy stuff in europe and the price differences.
its not the price of the processor ..its the price of mobo and especially the price of RAM that makes all the difference .. A good PH2 or C2D board can be had for good 100 euro while the I7 board its hard to find for less then 200Euro ...and RAM ... 8 Gb of decent DDR2 can be had for as low as 80 euro while 8Gb of DDR3 cant be had for less than 200 euro ... I personally need all the RAM i can get... therefor i'd still go for the ddr2 ...my prediction is, that at least through 2009 there wont be significant acceptance of the ddr3 ... and ddr2 will live for another 3 years ....
If you decide to go for the Phenom 2 I would go for the 790fx chipset. Reason being is it has all the kinks worked out of it. Most 790fx chipsets support the new P2s as well. Price is also a factor. The 790fx MBs should be on sale in alot of places. Your ram would be 1066 ddr2 btw. It should be no problem running your new rig on old ddr2 800 as well. You are going to want Vista 64 with 4+++ gigs of ram as well.
Intel options atm are not that great imo. Only reason for me to say that is price vs performance. DDR3 and MB prices are just to high for me personaly. The i7 while its a wonderfull cpu its only decent price vs performance is when you use it specificly for the applications it is very good at. For gaming and the average user is not worth the investment atm imo. It all comes down to your price range.
I highly recomend when asking for hardware advice you list your monitor size, type(lcd ect), and native resolution as it is super important if anyone is going to give you advice on your GPU. For your average 22 inch lcd at 1680x1050 and below I highly recomend a 4850-1gb for graphics when on a budget. This would put your gpu in its sweet spot performance wise. I highly recomend the 4870-1gb models for that resolution and display size and above IF you plan on upgrading your display in the near future. I would steer far clear of Nvidia as the 8800s and 200 cards do not support most of the features we will be seeing next year and they do not natively support dx10.1. Basicly you are paying for a gpu with very old features that inside of a year will perform like bottom level gpus because of the lack of feature support.
Message edited by jerseygamer on 01-19-2009 at 08:12:44 PM
samsung syncmaster T220 paired with my 17 inch 740BF. both great screens. currently i'm using both. i'm planning to game my old games, and i'm willing to play gta IV! i'm not an encoding guy or something. and the I7 gaming performance at the moment aren't so wonderfull. that's why i don't want to spend so much money.
about the gpu: the 9800GTX+ and 4850 are at the same price. i'm using nvidia for many years, don't know what ati has to bring me.
i know myself, and i'm a person who buys a new gpu after 1.5 years. so spending more money for a 4870 isn't my thing.
can someone give me some numbers about asus motherboards? like m3n ... because intel is known for me, but amd is an unknown path for me.
about the cpu. i hear here and there rumors about Phenom II to be only an upgrade cpu. but what about the people who don't want to spend so much on mobo and ram? i payed for my old pc 1005 euro's (let's say it's the same in dollars at that same time). i got a p4 630 3.0 ghz, 6600gt xxx 256mb xfx gpu, 2x80 gb maxtor sata 1 and a cheap nec dvd burner that doesn't work enymore. in those 3 years i changed the gpu to a 8600 (what dubbled my performance in fps, but didn't do what a 8600gt suposed to do... all known subject
p)
so now i can get for 800 euro's the best amd processor, a X8XX model card and more ram...
are there reasons to go for intel again?
If you buy a 790fx/gx mobo it should have support for future AM3 phenom 2 cpu's so there will be some upgradability. You wont be able to use DDR3 but it is shown to have less than a 10% performance increase over DDR2.
The asus model is the M3N79-T deluxe. However on newegg it is priced much higher than its MSI, DFI and Foxconn counterparts. I dont know if it will be the same for you in Europe though.
I would go for the radeon 4850 or 4870 as both prices have come down a long way and can be crossfired in the future.
The reason to go intel is if you are a true enthusiast and need the best of the best. Anything lower than that comes down to loyalty as the Core2Quads and Phenom 2s perform similarly, although I'd lean towards AMD for the AM3 upgradability.
thanks!! that's the info i needed most.
one more question: the OS:
is vista basic 64bit enough? or do i have to go for premium?
an other new question: 2.8 or 3.0ghz amd pII? is 200mhz worth the extra money?
Message edited by vochtige on 01-20-2009 at 05:04:09 PM
As far as i can tell Premium comes with a bunch of crap that i never use, eg mail and dvd makers and such.
Heres the MS link, they tried to pad out Premium but most of it is crap.
http://www.microsoft.com/windows/w [...] fault.aspx
Easier networking wtf? Better protecting data loss?!
1. Eve Online
2. MW2
3. Uhm...Eve Online alt
Reply to pr2thej
I think windows media center only comes with premium and higher in case you ever intend on using a remote or tv playback.
oke, maybe i'll get basic, i don't know yet (it's the last step after the build)
1 x OCZ 4GB 1066-555 Reaper
1 x XFX GF9800GTX+ 765M
1 x Microsoft Windows Vista Home Basic 64 bit (System Builder, Nederlands, SP1)
1 x Asus DRW-20B1LT (Bulk, Zilver/Zwart, 12x DVD-RAM schrijven, Lightscribe)
1 x Western Digital WD5000ABPS (RE2-GP)
1 x AMD Phenom II X4 920
1 x Asus M3N78 PRO (Retail, Sound, HDMI, Gb-LAN, FW, SATAII-RAID)
756,28EUR
what you guys think for the money? the mobo suports PII (says asus on the website)
if the amd pricecut for the 920 is coming to europe, maybe i can spend more at the mobo... or the other 940 cpu
Message edited by vochtige on 01-20-2009 at 06:08:40 PM
=> i don't plan to use a remote
and media center i don't even use on my xp media center edition
basic enough?
Just to warn you if you're going to go Phenom II, that you may run into a whole lot of problems getting your board to post. I bought the Phenom 920 with an Asus M3A78-T which supports the CPU by flashing the BIOS. However, you can't get the board to post so you can't flash the BIOS. I had to take my board to a buddy's house and pull out his Athlon 64 X2 and put it in my board to flash it. If you're board comes with the original BIOS which it mostly likely will, then good luck getting it flashed.
| vochtige wrote : => i don't plan to use a remote |
yeh and their is alot of freeware give u all the extra options for free .
just search on Download.com of softpedia and u will find what u want .
http://valid.canardpc.com/show_oc.php?id=548517
Reply to salem80
Well watch some of the info offered here if you get an AM2+ board your not going to be able to upgrade to AM3 socket. Pretty darn sure it will be totally different socket on those.
From everything I've read, the AM3 will be compatible with an AM2+ socket.
Thanks guys for the income!!
i think i'll wait what the next month will bring. the pc is still working now, and i start Thursday for my look after a new pc! thanks for the income!!!
i'll post my new setup if it runs.
| wingmaster wrote : Well watch some of the info offered here if you get an AM2+ board your not going to be able to upgrade to AM3 socket. Pretty darn sure it will be totally different socket on those. |
AM3 CPUs will have both a DDR2 and DDR3 memory controller and therefore can be used on either an AM2+ or AM3 motherboards. AM2+ Phenom 2s have only a DDR2 controller and therefore will not work on a AM3 motherboard.
little update: the price for phenom 940 is come down as the price of the 920. but the question is: is the 940 worth the extra 34 euro's? i'm not an overclocker! so the system would be like this:
1 x OCZ 4GB 1066-555 Reaper
1 x XFX GF9800GTX+ 765M
1 x Microsoft Windows Vista Home Basic 64 bit (System Builder, Nederlands, SP1)
1 x Asus DRW-20B1LT (Bulk, Zilver/Zwart, 12x DVD-RAM schrijven, Lightscribe)
1 x Western Digital Caviar SE16 (Bulk, WD5000AAKS)
1 x Asus M3N78 PRO (Retail, Sound, HDMI, Gb-LAN, FW, SATAII-RAID)
1 x AMD Phenom II X4 940
733,66EUR
I would go for premium, just for aero... Vista basic looks like crap. Unless you want to go for windows classic and forgo live preview or whatever it is... IMO one of the best, most useful features of Vista. It's only like a $50 difference for the non-upgrade, non-OEM version anyway...
| vochtige wrote : samsung syncmaster T220 paired with my 17 inch 740BF. both great screens. currently i'm using both. i'm planning to game my old games, and i'm willing to play gta IV! i'm not an encoding guy or something. and the I7 gaming performance at the moment aren't so wonderfull. that's why i don't want to spend so much money.
|
Keep in mind that you will not get the new features on an AM2 socket. It has to be AM2+ for the new AMD rigs. Most of the new performance is lost unless you are on the new socket.
Avoid any and all Asus MBs at all costs imo. They recently went 100% Chinese production. Asus has put there hands in everything from MBs, GPUs, Laptops ect. It shows and especially in the MB section. They use poor caps and have pretty bad bios, driver and utility support these days. Even there graphics cards are slipping with support a bit more then usual. I put Asus MBs at the bottom of the list with Foxcon and EVGA(all EVGA products). I recomend Gigabyte for ease of use, great tech support(factory advanced support) and they are built like a brick. The Bios is also very easy to use and has both the simple version and an advanced verison with the flick of a key. Gigabyte has some pretty decent desktop apps for OCing, bios updates, and fully featured control over your MB.
When it comes to your GPU its really up to you. Again I advise against any and all current Nvidia products as they are still on last years features. It sounds like you are fit for a 4850 512-1gb. You should get better color and have no problems running that gpu for 3 years on your display. I recomend again the 1gb model as more and more engines are eating more and more vram with every passing year. Inside of 2 years I firmly believe 1gb will be standard. There is just no point in buying last years GPU when this years models are that much better. If you are going to run 2 displays I recomend you do so on the 4870 as it yeilds better returns. Oh and that 8600 is pretty much good for propping up your desk at this point.
The new P2s are very viable gaming builds. If you decide to cut out xfire/sli options you can save alot of money on the MB. DDR2 1066 is plenty for any gaming rig as benchmarks on DDR3 make it a non factor for a must have atm. Chances are you will never see the difference. Socket is a non factor. Its about price vs performance. It doesnt matter if you build AM2+ or an Intel system. The next time you are ready to upgrade your CPU you will need to buy a new MB and Ram anyways.
I can not recomend any single x16 MBs as I only build xfire rigs. I can recomend you do some reading on what 790fx MBs are out there if you decide to go that route.
hey jerseygamer
thanks for the big comment!! so i should go looking for gigabyte! i didn't pick that brand because of the strange colors they use to paint the mobo's and components.
i'm only looking to buy next month, and things change really fast these days!! maybe i'll pick up amd3 socket.
about the old nvidia: maybe you're right about the old tech that nvidia is using. that's why i'm very interesting what ATI has to offer.
i'm not planning to use xfire or sli, because i don't need to use 2 gpu's. if i need a new gpu, i'll get a better one than i already have...
thanks alot, you all made me doubt more about getting a system now
, intel prices went up, amd prices went down!
I wouldnt hold out for the am3 mobos. Supposedly the am3 phenom 2's are delayed because amd hasnt worked out all the bugs with the DDR3 memory controller.
| nsimo86 wrote : I wouldnt hold out for the am3 mobos. Supposedly the am3 phenom 2's are delayed because amd hasnt worked out all the bugs with the DDR3 memory controller. |
That's a BS rumor that was started by Fudzilla.
http://www.pcper.com/news.php?page=2
| Quote : Going straight to the source, I got a pretty enlightening answer. It seems that when the first batches of 45 nm processors were coming off the line, to get them validated they focused on DDR-2 and only ran the northbridge portion of the chip at 1800 GHz instead of the full 2 GHz that many were expecting (remember, the "uncore" parts of the 45 nm Phenom II run at 1.8 GHz while the processor cores run at 2.8 and 3.0 GHz). This allowed AMD to get these AM2+ parts out in relatively short order, and once those products were in the pipeline AMD concentrated on getting the DDR-3 parts out at full spec. So, the DDR-3 portion of the memory controller is still being officially validated, but from all indications it is working perfectly fine.
|
The AM3's have already been tested by Gigabyte (check their website) so they have at least a few made in retail (C2) stepping.
One word of caution, I have the Gigabyte board and it still has a few minor BIOS glitches. I can tell you them if you'd like. From what I've heard, the Asus 790GX is a little more stable, but accounts vary. I'd suggest sticking with the 790GX since it is very good for the price.
Also, if you are worried about the shipped BIOS being incompatible, just buy a cheap $20 Sempron for that first boot. On top of it, at the time I bought mine my board was $10 off so the extra CPU cost only $10. Not a bad deal if you ask me.
Athlon II X2 250 3.0GHz > GA-MA770T-UD3P > Sapphire ATI 4650 512MB DDR3 > 4GB OCZ Platinum 1600MHz@1066MHz > XP/Win7 Enter 64
Reply to EXT64
Hey guys, i started my search. i don't know if you guys know Medion. it's realiable they say, so i found this 2 systems: the links are in dutch, but i'll give you a little translation.
https://www.medionshop.be/nlshop/ca [...] reItems.do
the black one has: phenom 9550 2,2ghz, ati 4850, 4gb ram (667mhz), 1000gb (WD), tv tuner card with wireless controller price 799euro's
the white one has: Q6600 (intel), nv 9600GT, 3gb (800mhz), 1000gb... but no TV- tuner card or controller... price 749euro's
so guys, the black one with the tv-tuner card and the better graphics card is it worth the extra 50 euro's? is 4850 a big diffrence against 9600GT? would the amd phenom hurt me? just guys tell me what you think?
| EXT64 wrote : The AM3's have already been tested by Gigabyte (check their website) so they have at least a few made in retail (C2) stepping.
|
But don't forget that ASUS BIOS UPDATE Through USB FLASH Disk with
""ASUS CrashFree BIOS3"" and "ASUS EZ Flash2 " offer u update Bios Like this MOBO
http://www.asus.com/products.aspx? [...] odelmenu=1
but i don't know if it work with new cpu
| vochtige wrote : Hey guys, i started my search. i don't know if you guys know Medion. it's realiable they say, so i found this 2 systems: the links are in dutch, but i'll give you a little translation.
|
Both systems have serious flaws. The AMD needs faster RAM and it would be nice to get at least a phenom 9850 or 9950 if not a phenom 2. The Intel system needs a better graphics card and 4gb of RAM. Are these systems customizable at all?
no they are not customizable. so it's not a good way to go for? it would be my last desktop system i think! i've got at least 1.5 years to use a pc like i do now. after that i'm not more on school, but working.
not a good idea?
its a toss up, you would need to replace the RAM on either machine. I think I would go with the AMD machine as you could always upgrade the cpu in the future. What motherboard chipset does the AMD use?
i mailed them for more technical information!
they don't give the mobo brand or even the types....
prebuild, you know what that means!! 667mhz ram, why it's not good enough?
Well, for reference what I use (and the Phenom max) is 1066, which is quite a bit faster than 667. It doesn't mean your computer can't work well (I ran DDR1 400MHz up until a couple weeks ago) but it will be limiting it, and who wants that in a new system (especially with DDR2 prices so low).
Athlon II X2 250 3.0GHz > GA-MA770T-UD3P > Sapphire ATI 4650 512MB DDR3 > 4GB OCZ Platinum 1600MHz@1066MHz > XP/Win7 Enter 64
Reply to EXT64
yeah, maybe you are right!! i'll pick up some 8 gb ram 1066mhz, but how can i know if the mobo suports 1066mhz? the latest mobo's all do, but i can't even find out the brand(manufacturor) of those motherboards!
You'll have to find out from them but I am guessing its either a nvidia board or a micro atx board since it only has 1 pci express x16 slot. Its not bad, you just will be limited in your upgrades. You can only have one video card and probably only be able to upgrade to a phenom 9850 (if you would even need to). Overall its not a bad system for mainstream uses and will play games fine. The 8 gig will be a good upgrade with vista and even if the board doesnt support 1066, it should support 800 which is still an upgrade.
Well, 8GB may be a little overkill, but it can't hurt. The 2x2GB 1066 kits are quite cheap right now (around $50). The only problem is that prebuilt systems sometimes have limited BIOSes, and to run 1066 you normally have to adjust some BIOS settings.
Athlon II X2 250 3.0GHz > GA-MA770T-UD3P > Sapphire ATI 4650 512MB DDR3 > 4GB OCZ Platinum 1600MHz@1066MHz > XP/Win7 Enter 64
Reply to EXT64
Oh yeah I was thinking it was vista 64 but its probably 32bit vista so 4gigs is enough
| nsimo86 wrote : Oh yeah I was thinking it was vista 64 but its probably 32bit vista so 4gigs is enough |
4 gigs works for both. Its perfect actually.
some people use applications that benefit from 8gigs
i'm still waiting on their mail.
i think i can choose between 32 or 64 bit. they offer both choices in the same box. i really don't know what they mean about that, maybe they have an upgrade dvd-rom with vista64?
eumh, how long will 4 GB be enough in the pc-world? i run xp with 2 gb for a long time now, how long will 4 gb last with vista?
and again, thanks for the advices and comments!!
i think they have msi motherboard. mmh, i use asus now, and only have bad experiences with msi because there usb2.0 ports always do ****
oke new update:
i've mailed my favorite pcshop with the question what he can get me for 750-800 euro's amd phenom II.
so i don't think i'm going for that medion prebuild thing that costs me 800euro's. good choice? i'll post what i'm getting...
i'm gonna change the motherboard to an GigaByte MA790FX-DS4
the site says it suports the upcoming am3 cpu's from amd. so will it fit the new phenomII am2+ also?
and amd phenom II 920 pr 940??? 30 euro's diffrence. what to get?
Message edited by vochtige on 01-26-2009 at 04:25:21 PM
the phenom 2 should work with any 790gx/fx motherboard.
Go with the 940 if you want to overclock, otherwise the 920 is ok.
| vochtige wrote : samsung syncmaster T220 paired with my 17 inch 740BF. both great screens. currently i'm using both. i'm planning to game my old games, and i'm willing to play gta IV! i'm not an encoding guy or something. and the I7 gaming performance at the moment aren't so wonderfull. that's why i don't want to spend so much money.
|
There are 9 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
