Tom's Guide Forums
  Tom's Guide Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » I feel like I am taking crazy pills... RE: 4850/4870
 

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
 Page :   1  2
Next 
Author
 Thread : I feel like I am taking crazy pills... RE: 4850/4870
 
More Information

Last message on previous page:

bifford wrote :

Oh well, you guys got me for sure. I just had to test it out before shipping. Reinstalled Win XP Pro and SP3, installed Catalyst 8.7 beta. Did the fan fix, and set fan to 45%. I was getting idle temp of 60 degrees.

Installed crysis and updates. Ran Crysis, was really excited when it detected High for system. Was really bummed when it crashed before I could even make it to the beach. Screen went artifact on me, had to hit the reset button.

Then I tried LOTRO, seemed to play fine for about 15 minutes. Then I got a VPU error, which it recovered from. However, minutes later I started to see strange flashes of artifacts. Exited LOTRO and checked temp, but it was only 76.



Weirdness I have not ran into any major issues with the 8.7 beta driver, Played LOTRO, Crysis, Tabula Rasa, Supreme Commander, Mass Effect, COD4, Jade Empire, Never Winter Nights 2 (It does crash but thats the game not the card, it crashed on the 8800GT also), Sins of a Solar Empire, and Oblivion.

I am running a modified core of Vista x64 but I can't see a x64 Vista driver being more stable than a 32bit XP driver.

What is the temp inside your case when your running the games?, it might not be the card overheating but with all the heat that is being spit out into the case. It may be causing your ambient temps to rise, causing something else to overheat.

Also on my 4870, setting the fan at 45% my cards temps are fine at around 65' degrees, but with the smaller heatsink and fan on the 4850 I think you might want to up it a bit, maybe 60% or higher till the driver issues with the fan is resolved.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by CSA_Myth on 07-18-2008 at 07:09:34 PM
Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Speed Demon
More Information

bifford wrote :

How much does mine have? Maybe I don't know how to read it, but it looks like 4 x 20 on +12v = 80 amps. If you discount the CPU portion, 60 amps.



Yes and No. You got 20 in each different rail. The PSU will probably pass that amp no problem if you plug a GPU (for example) that consumes more than 20Amps under load. if not might be a problem there. But i don't think so.
I choose to have a nice 12v 60 amp rail, so the PSU distributes.

I got 720Watts on the 12v. ( All PSU, distributed also on the PCI-E)
You got 240 Watts on EACH 12v. But i think is enough. You might need a second opinion here. Cant be sure and already explained why.



---------------
Rock journalism is people who can't write interviewing people who can't talk for people who can't read - Frank Zappa
Speed Demon
More Information

@CSA, what is your PSU ? Just making a little math here.

 

Edit: CSA got a PSU like mine (Corsair TX750). Loads of power in the 12v Rail. I guess it might be it. if the drivers update fail to solve the problems, you got 2 situations.

 

A bad card (it happens), a PSU that cant handle (i doubt it). But hey anybody with a a 20amp 12v Rail and no problems ?


Message edited by radnor on 07-18-2008 at 07:22:54 PM

---------------
Rock journalism is people who can't write interviewing people who can't talk for people who can't read - Frank Zappa
More Information

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817703009

I run a PC Power & Cooling 750W

Single 12v rail 60A is more than enough for the 4870

Need to find someone with a 3 or 4 rail Power Supply to compare to.


Message edited by CSA_Myth on 07-18-2008 at 07:21:10 PM
More Information

CSA_Myth wrote :

Weirdness I have not ran into any major issues with the 8.7 beta driver, Played LOTRO, Crysis, Tabula Rasa, Supreme Commander, Mass Effect, COD4, Jade Empire, Never Winter Nights 2 (It does crash but thats the game not the card, it crashed on the 8800GT also), Sins of a Solar Empire, and Oblivion.

I am running a modified core of Vista x64 but I can't see a x64 Vista driver being more stable than a 32bit XP driver.

What is the temp inside your case when your running the games?, it might not be the card overheating but with all the heat that is being spit out into the case. It may be causing your ambient temps to rise, causing something else to overheat.

Also on my 4870, setting the fan at 45% my cards temps are fine at around 65' degrees, but with the smaller heatsink and fan on the 4850 I think you might want to up it a bit, maybe 60% or higher till the driver issues with the fan is resolved.



According to the utility that shipped with my mobo, the cpu temp is 25 and mb temp is 35. I have 6 fans in my case, it is very cool.

Just my two frames' worth.
Profile: Graphic Gorilla
More Information

bifford wrote :

If you bought a new television and it wouldn't play some channels (one of which happened to be your favorite channel), would you still be this understanding? Really what this all boils down to, is that I don't get why you guys are soo willing to accept the amount of issues that tend to plague new video cards.



Dude this isn't a monitor it's a Card. Monitors have about 4 variables that can be changed in like 5 ways, same with a TV. A card is much more complex.

And guess what, yes, the first HD-DVD player I bought, wouldn't play many movies out of the box or after the first patch, same with the PS3 and my LG Combo player. Guess what happened with some VCDs on those early DVD players too.

Dude, your biggest problem, you're buying new generation hardware, when you shouldn't be an early adopter.

This is one drawback of the cheap prices of higher end cards, too many people buying it and complaining, when they really should be the mid-range or refresh buyers.

Quote :

Honestly, it makes me wonder how many of you are on-line gamers. I understand that if Crysis crashes, it is annoying, but really nbd. Simply reload last save and move on. On the other hand, if I crash in LOTRO while playing the main tank in a dungeon....



Let me guess world peace is in jeopardy. [:thegreatgrapeape:5]

Quote :

I bought a 7900 GTX at launch and have never had a single issue with it.



The GF7900GTX was a refresh of a mature line of NV4x design with 3 years of driver work behind it.
Hoever there's still major issues with the GF7 series, especially if you value image quality, that you haven't noticed it is similar to your comments about Crysis.

Quote :

I guess that means I should just STHU and keep it, right? Or only buy tech that is like a year old and almost completely obsolete, but proven.



Sounds about right, not everyone is fit to be an early adopter.

Quote :

As a consumer, you probably only have about a 6 month window to feel like you have a top shelf product. If it takes 2 months to get stable drivers, you have missed out on a third of time.



That's life, just like first generation cards. It took almost to the GF8800 Ultra (~ 7 months) refresh to get most of the GF8 drivers sorted. To the HD3870 and beyond for the HD2900. That's the way it is.
Comparing it to a TV, what ATi and nV do is essentially re-invent an etirely new product about every 18 months. Compare that to the TV segment and tell me how well your OLED TV is working for you right now, the one that's been in development since before the R300 or even Geforce 2 was made.

Quote :

At the end of the day, I just want to be able to play my games. Show me a stable/reliable card that doesn't need a lot of tinkering to make run correctly and that is the card I will pay my hard earned money for.



Last year's cards.
The GF8800GT and GF8800GTX are very cheap right now and have had alot of work done to make them stable, and they'd play a game like LOTRO fine.
If you don't have the passion to fix and tweak it yourselves others are just going to get frustrated trying to fix it by proxy, best you return the card and buy last year's hardware for half the price.


---------------
You need a license to buy a gun, but they'll sell anyone a stamp (or internet account) - RED GREEN. GA to SK
HD Freedom: 45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2

More Information

bifford wrote :

According to the utility that shipped with my mobo, the cpu temp is 25 and mb temp is 35. I have 6 fans in my case, it is very cool.



Then I would have to agree with Radnor that it might be a defective card or a power supply load issue. I could understand some problems with it, people have reported random crashes and artifacts with the beta drivers but it shouldn't be like that with everything you play.

My PC has in the past week had LOTRO running 8 hours non-stop with out a single crash or noticeable error, (dang kids and summer vacation). It is either a problem with the card or your setup, try running some benchmarks (3Dmark06 seems to work fine with the beta drivers) and see if the system hangs or crashes out. That would tell you that you either have a heat, power problem or a bad card.

Anyhow I wish computer parts were just like a TV, come home, plug it in, and go, but that would mean I would be looking for a new job too. :pt1cable:

More Information

Uninstalled the ATI drivers, did driverclean, threw back in my 7900 GTX and ran LOTRO for 3 hours with no issues.

Speed Demon
More Information

bifford wrote :

Uninstalled the ATI drivers, did driverclean, threw back in my 7900 GTX and ran LOTRO for 3 hours with no issues.



Trying to find TDP of your GTX, but from reviews ive read, they did it with a Enermax EG565P-VE. A 535W PSU.
Cant put my finger on it. If it is a PSU problem your GTX would work just fine.

Might still be PSU now giving enough power through the 12v PCI-E Rail.
Might be a bad card.

Do it like this, RMA your card, if the next that comes doesnt work also, your PSU is not pushing it. It gives 240W through the 12v Rail. Dunno really, cant really put my finger on it.


---------------
Rock journalism is people who can't write interviewing people who can't talk for people who can't read - Frank Zappa
Meowwwww!
More Information

bifford wrote :

If you bought a new television and it wouldn't play some channels (one of which happened to be your favorite channel), would you still be this understanding? Really what this all boils down to, is that I don't get why you guys are soo willing to accept the amount of issues that tend to plague new video cards.

If I was able to play and enjoy my games, I wouldn't have an issue. If it was just a matter of performance being lower than advertised until optimized drivers came out, I could deal with that. However flakey and unstable, I can not deal with. Honestly, it makes me wonder how many of you are on-line gamers. I understand that if Crysis crashes, it is annoying, but really nbd. Simply reload last save and move on. On the other hand, if I crash in LOTRO while playing the main tank in a dungeon....

I WAS ingnorant to all the problems with the 8800 series of GPU. I haven't really needed a video card in a while. My comments on NVidia were based solely on my personal experiences with the 6xxx and 7xxx line of cards. I bought a 7900 GTX at launch and have never had a single issue with it. I guess that means I should just STHU and keep it, right? Or only buy tech that is like a year old and almost completely obsolete, but proven.

Kind of sad, right? By the time they get all of the kinks worked out with this generation, they will probably have already released the next generation. As a consumer, you probably only have about a 6 month window to feel like you have a top shelf product. If it takes 2 months to get stable drivers, you have missed out on a third of time.

At the end of the day, I just want to be able to play my games. Show me a stable/reliable card that doesn't need a lot of tinkering to make run correctly and that is the card I will pay my hard earned money for.



silly noob go cry to the BBB if it bothers u soo much...GPU;s are not liek tv's and tv's are not replaced nearly as fast as GPU's are son, so that analogy is just horrible, you need to do some research and youw ill understand why it's not perfect, do some research on GPU's the hardware element then tkae a lookat the software element, you will see where the problem lies, and so u have problems w/ it I bet if anything it might not even be the gpu's drivers, many ppl come on here complaining about a problem and b/c they are terrible at diagnosing they don't get it right, period, so stop complaining about what you don't understand, yet [and that is the key word, son]

I am not trying to flame you or anything but if I don't say something you might go on thinking everything is simple, when the truth is it not, in order to play keep up w/ the Joneses ati and nvidia hurt themselves by trying to get stable drivers up too fast instead of delaying the hardware until the drivers are perfect, which you have to understand doesn't happen, testing for bugs in drivers takes a long time, in order to stay competitive they usually mature the drivers alter on not too mention you obviously don;'t understand the whole orgy nvidia has w/ game developers or even how deep it goes, so seriously brah do some research,

Don't even take my word for it, look it up yourself...

More Information

FrozenGPU, you can say you are not trying to flame, but the reality is that your comments are the most hurtfull and insulting I have seen posted here. Let me be perfectly clear on this, I am not your son. You are an elitist jerk, plain and simple. You are not an educator. Instead you use your knowledge as a weapon and you bludgeon other people with it.

None of the other internet nazis really even pissed me off, but I can't stand people like you. You sit on your intellectual throne and rain down missles of hate with each keystroke. Instead you could be putting that knowledge to work helping others.

Meowwwww!
More Information

bifford wrote :

FrozenGPU, you can say you are not trying to flame, but the reality is that your comments are the most hurtfull and insulting I have seen posted here. Let me be perfectly clear on this, I am not your son. You are an elitist jerk, plain and simple. You are not an educator. Instead you use your knowledge as a weapon and you bludgeon other people with it.

None of the other internet nazis really even pissed me off, but I can't stand people like you. You sit on your intellectual throne and rain down missles of hate with each keystroke. Instead you could be putting that knowledge to work helping others.



gonna cry son?

:lol:

Anyways, b4 you start w/ the water works... I didn't feel it was worth my time to delete it after I wrote it, sorry if you feel that way, Really I am, I take back what i said, but if you eevn read it, I did apologize in that same post...

but maybe reading is for the literate, perhaps? :whistle:

 Page :   1  2
Next 
Top 

Go to:
Add a reply
  Tom's Guide Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » I feel like I am taking crazy pills... RE: 4850/4870
 

Google ads