ESD precautions (Or "Is it a good idea to build in the bathroom?") ;-)
Forum Homebuilt Systems : General Homebuilt - ESD precautions (Or "Is it a good idea to build in the bathroom?") ;-)
Hi guys
Well, I’m hoping to have all the parts for my computer tomorrow, and I’d appreciate your thoughts on how to avoid damaging it with static electricity when I build it.
Of course I’ve googled and learned that I should ground myself before touching sensitive components, and that some (few) people ground themselves permanently with a wristband. But I need some clarificiations on both how to ground myself properly, and on what components are sensitive to ESD.
Regarding how to ground myself:
1) All the radiators where I live are covered with paint. Will the paint insulate so I won’t be grounded, and if so, could I just touch this metal thingy in stead?
2) I’ve read that you could also install the PSU and plug it into the wall (without swithcing it on) and then ground yourself by touching a metal part of the case. On the other hand some people seem to think this method increases the risk of being electrocuted. What do you think? Should I only use this method when working with the motherboard, and disconnect the PSU from the wall when I work on the case?
3) I’ve also read that you can ground yourself by touching a faucet, but the kitchen is carpeted, which would increase the risk of ESD. So (and this is where my post gets a little weird)
I’ve actually considered if I could build it in the bathroom in stead. I’d of course make sure everything was dry, and I could also put a table in there to build it on. Other than the risk of getting something wet, are there any other reasons why this would be a bad idea? (For instance I don’t know if the bathroom floor being connected to drains and stuff would make any difference?)
Regarding what components are sensitive to ESD:
4) Could you tell me what parts of what components I should be careful about? I’m guessing that ESD can’t hurt the case or the PSU, but can hurt the CPU, RAM, motherboard, and video card. Is this correct? Also, what parts of these components should I avoid touching? Anything metal?
Hope someone will shed some light on my questions (without making too much fun of me). ;-)
Cheers.
Parts such Mainboard, GPU, CPU, RAM, Soundcard, HDD, TV Tuner are sensitive with ESD.
You can touch those metal parts of the radiator, or do the second way (PSU off). Or you can use gloves (elastic gloves).
Building in the bathroom ? well, it's dangerous because of humidity and be carefull to not let your CPU flushed.
Don't get freak out on building PC, just touch the metal parts of radiator, build your PC, put the PSU and all parts will be grounded.
If the parts is new and you have problem...RMA it.
You can buy a cheap antistatic wrist band and wear it while you build.
I have only burned out one computer speaker with static in many years of handling hardware.
Graphics Card (and other expansion cards):
Hold the graphics card by the metal plate (the part which orients towards back of case when installed). Press down on the top edge when inserting it. You can hold the other edge for better stability (the side that orients towards front of the case when installed). Do not touch the gold-colored pins at the bottom of the card. Try to avoid touching either face of the card.
RAM:
Hold the RAM module by the edges. Do not touch the faces or gold-colored contacts. Press down on the top of the module to insert.
CPU: Hold the CPU by two corners diagonal from each other. NEVER touch the pins/contact points on the underside. Avoid touching the heatspreader on top as this will leave fingerprints/skin oils which may impede heat flow to the heatsink (touching the headspreader does not risk frying the CPU with static). If you do touch the heatspreader, clean the surface with a lint-free cloth and a bit of high-purity isopropyl alcohol.
Motherboard:
Hold the motherboard by the edges and avoid touching either face.
Hard Drive:
Avoid touching the underside of the hard drive as there is usually an exposed circuit board here. Best practice is to handle the hard drive by the edges. If you need to set the hard drive down, do it gently and flip it upside down so the circuit board is facing up.
Optical drives:
There are no exposed circuit boards, so these aren't statically sensitive.
PSU:
The circuit board is inside and there is nothing you will fry with static.
Case:
There may be a small circuit board for the power/hard drive activity lights. There is little risk of damaging these with static, but there's no reason to go touching it.
In review:
- If in doubt, hold the component by the edges.
- Never touch any pins/gold-colored contact points on the component.
- It's good practice not to touch the faces off a component (eg. graphics card, motherboard, RAM module, etc). However, doing so doesn't necessarily mean you will fry anything. The main things to avoid on the component faces are microchips. Examples:
http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/imageview.php?image=299
http://www1.istockphoto.com/file_t [...] rboard.jpg
http://www.dansdata.com/images/ocz [...] hip560.jpg
- If you need to set a component down, put it on the antistatic bag in which it came. If it doesn't have an antistatic bag, put it on top of the box with which it came, or any piece of cardboard, antistatic mat, wood surface.
Also, I think you are being overly paranoid about being grounded. The best idea is to not work on carpet and avoid walking around a whole lot. Also, if you sit down somewhere and then stand up, this will build up a static charge. You can discharge it by simply touching some nearby steel/aluminum/copper. In fact, you can touch the inside of your metal case (and it doesn't have to have the PSU plugged in) and it will sufficiently discharge any built up static (obviously avoid touching components when you do this).
In general practice, touch your the metal in your case before handling a component. Additionally, touch your case anytime you feel you've built up a static charge (examples: you sat down and stood up, you walked around the room, you came in contact with carpet, etc) and follow the tips above on handling your components. You should be fine.
Oh, and yes you can touch your radiator to discharge static as long as you are coming in direct contact with the metal.
Message edited by qwertycopter on 10-31-2007 at 01:45:57 PM
qwertycopter has got it covered. To reiterate one thing, don't build it on the carpet if you can avoid it. It isn't my first choice but if you have no alternative you can build it in the bathroom no problem. Avoid doing it right after someone has taken a shower, dry the place down with a towel to avoid getting something wet, close the toilet cover etc., but I'm sure you know that already.
while ure at it why not set this up....only takes a few minutes
http://www.google.com/tisp/install.html
http://tinyurl.com/26uxxb - C2/i7 Temp? http://tinyurl.com/cj3pw - VGA power?
http://tinyurl.com/5v55wk - C2 Mem performance? http://tinyurl.com/6pmbke - SLI/Xfire?
http://tinyurl.com/yfmxdc9 - Part Guide?
Reply to nukemaster
| nukemaster wrote : while ure at it why not set this up....only takes a few minutes |
I've been dying to get that setup, but they are still charging way too much for it. I am going to wait for the price to come down and then I'm going to buy two. Sweet ![]()
I was going through the FAQs to flush out my understanding of this state of the art system and I found this

I am definitely going to get the "Royal Flush", but I had some questions about the sewer line condition caveat. You know they always sell bandwidth with the old "up to x amount of bandwidth" caveat. Does that mean that when I flush, my download speed will go down? Or is it just the upload speed that's affected?
Message edited by Zorg on 10-31-2007 at 07:51:07 PM
| Zorg wrote : I've been dying to get that setup, but they are still charging way too much for it. I am going to wait for the price to come down and then I'm going to buy two. Sweet |
Thank you nukemaster and zorg for a good morning laugh. While the downloads are fine, I really don't care to have any uploads from the designated receptical. Uploads can cause considerable time to be spent with cleaning up the system and removing all traces of viruses.
To the OP, I commonly work on my computers in the kitchen, which has vinyl flooring. The bathroom, or at least my bathroom, has too much moisture to make me comfortable with the idea of working there. I have even done work while on a carpeted surface, of which many will disapprove, but keep myself well grounded when doing so. Wall to wall carpeting sometimes leaves little choice when working, so I'm very cautious about it. To date, I've lost no parts due to electrostatic shock.
Over 50. Seen it, done it, can't remember it, but I miss it.
Reply to Sailer
From my understanding, or 2 cents... The PSU helps ground the PC case as well as the MB. As long as the outlet has a good ground (3rd prong) you should be able to discharge any static electric from yourself simply touching the case, or hooking up the wrist strap to the case.
If you have a multimeter, where you set it for continuity, you take both pos/neg prongs and touch them together, the multimeter should beep. So when you touch one prong to the metal chassis on the case, then the other to the ground on the plug from your PSU, it should beep.
That is why the PSU should be plugged in to the outlet, but the switch turned off so the MB will not power up.
Message edited by Grimmy on 10-31-2007 at 05:16:13 PM
And honestly too, when I build, I have yet to use a wrist strap, no problems yet. I personally just keep touching an unpainted part of the case and if I'm carpet, I try not to move. However, when I installed to CPU, I did take that and the case/mobo onto my tile floor. But mainly be careful, and don't touch any pins on the cpu, or contact points of any memory etc, or anything that looks sensitive if you can help it.
Not that I recommend it, but I've built many a computer on beds in carpeted bedrooms, in sock feet. I've never had a static problem, so the chances are pretty slim. Just touch metal and don't rub on TV screens while holding components.
ESD is not a huge problem. On the Screensavers (a.k.a. Attack of the Show) on G4, it took a tazer to make the RAM stop working. They did a bunch of static discharges on it and the stuff ran fine. So short term, it takes a massive discharge to damage that stuff. However I think minor shock will do slight damage long term. Just touch your case or PSU before you start and you will be 100% fine; even with socks whilst walking on carpet.
| evongugg wrote : You can buy a cheap antistatic wrist band and wear it while you build.
|
Heh heh... the geek strap!
All modern PC components must tolerate ESD as per the FCC and UL rules: at least 2kV for human body model and 4kV for the machine model.
It's not so high, in a very dry day and with synthetic t-shirts an human body can reach up to 15kV, but normal every day discharges are at 1-2kV approx.
The painted pipes are optimal, never discharge you to ground directly, it may be dangerous: security rules in electronics industry require minimum 1Mohm resistance for the antistatic wrist bands.
Do your math: 15kV / 1Mohm is 15mA and security switches are calibrated to 30mA... discharging yourself directly to ground equals to touch the mains wires for a few milliseconds: it's a very short time, but may hurt.
| JuiceJones wrote : Not that I recommend it, but I've built many a computer on beds in carpeted bedrooms, in sock feet. I've never had a static problem, so the chances are pretty slim. Just touch metal and don't rub on TV screens while holding components. |
Yeah, I built my latest rig wearing sweat pants and socks, sitting on a thick rug. In retrospect, not the brightest thing to do, but I've had no problems. If you want to be safe, just make sure you touch metal pieces of your case, don't be stupid with circuit boards, and be careful with the cpu.
| monsterrocks wrote : ESD is not a huge problem....They did a bunch of static discharges on it and the stuff ran fine....it takes a massive discharge to damage that stuff. |
Actually the human body can easily gain a charge large enough zap the microscopic traces in a microchip. The ESD damage everyone is talking about amounts to these microscopic traces being severed/blown apart, effectively creating an open circuit and/or a short (on a microscopic level).
It is possible for ESD damage to occur but not cause any immediate problems. This results from a degredation of the micro traces rather than an open circuit or short (basically, a trace is partially blow apart but there is still a weak connection despite the damage). Operating in this mode puts the chip at a high risk of failure and can result in problems down the road.
Message edited by qwertycopter on 11-01-2007 at 02:30:53 AM
If you want some ESD, try sitting on a nylon carpet in a dry, highly static atmosphere. Then pet a cat for a while to build a good charge. After that, reach for the new video card and watch the spark fly from finger to helpless transistors and ICs. Will it still work, or will your nice new part become so much junk?
Oh yeah, don't actually do this unless you like wasting good parts and watching your credit card bill go up for no good reason.
Over 50. Seen it, done it, can't remember it, but I miss it.
Reply to Sailer
| qwertycopter wrote : Actually the human body can easily gain a charge large enough zap the microscopic traces in a microchip. The ESD damage everyone is talking about amounts to these microscopic traces being severed/blown apart, effectively creating an open circuit and/or a short (on a microscopic level).
|
Thank you for bringing some clarity to this thread, I was about to stick a pencil in my eye having to read all the BS.
| maury73 wrote : All modern PC components must tolerate ESD as per the FCC and UL rules: at least 2kV for human body model and 4kV for the machine model.
|
You know that all sounds official, and I'm sure there are documents that you can pull off the web to prove that the FCC and UL have these regs but I call BS. Depending on the kind of paint, you may get no static discharge at all. There is no reason that you can't touch bare metal in order to discharge static. As a matter of fact when you are looking to discharge static you always look for bare metal that is grounded. It is absolutely not dangerous unless getting a little snap on your finger will harm you, which we all know it won't. The mere thought that anyone would say that discharging static is like touching the mains boggles my mind. Touching the mains can easily kill you and is very dangerous. The 1M resistor is because you have the strap wrapped around your wrist and people are dorks. It's the same for the cutoff on the lawnmower handle, the clutch starter interlock on the car etc. etc. etc. As far as ESD, you may or may not damage the chips. They may fail completely or such that the weakening/partial failure is not evident. I had some electron microscope photos lying around that showed the actual damage to the chips, they looked like little meteor strikes.
Another thing to consider, that people may or may not know is the amount of voltage released. This should help you see why traces at greatest risk.
If memory serves.. It takes around 3000 volts of static electricity for your to feel it. If you hear the static discharge, that should be around 6000 volts. If you see the actual spark, that is approx 9000 volts.
So.. understanding that in order for you to feel the discharge, it will be around 3000 volts. You may not feel the discharge at 1000 volts, so you won't know if you accidentally zapped a component that was only designed for 1.3-1.8 volts.
Some people will not agree what I mention is correct, cause some people think you'd die from that amount of voltage. Whelp... it's not the voltage that kills people.. its the amps.
Tryed taping my mouth shut - as you can see didn't help.
To monsterrocks - Gee you could make some mega bucks, Just sell this concept to all the corporations with ESD stations. All that money they could save. PS might want to pad backside for protection when hitting the pavement.
Very good points for Zorg and qwertycopter - Yes, I've also seen photos and movies documenting the damage caused by ESD.
Myself I perfer to were the stap. (1) PSU plugged in, rocker switch off. (2) when working outside the case (ie Installing proc in motherboard) I use a banna plug plugged into the ground on the power strip.
Side comment - ESD procedures require periodic testing of a wrist strap. Reason is to verify that the 1 Megohm resistor is still connected.
Edited - Well said, and correct. Grimmy
By chance, if it becomes detached (open), the wrist stap is useless.
PS I even recommend using a helmet when riding a motorbike.
Message edited by RetiredChief on 11-01-2007 at 07:45:33 AM
| Grimmy wrote : If you see the actual spark, that is approx 9000 volts. |
Heh, I have visibly shocked a motherboard at its edge. Still worked though
.
| JuiceJones wrote : Heh, I have visibly shocked a motherboard at its edge. Still worked though |
While it was in the PC case, or out (if it was in the case, chances are it went to the ground of the outlet, if you have a good ground)? Your just lucky it didn't fry anything, or perhaps it did, it will take more time for something to fail.
Electricity will do weird things, as far as taking the easiest path, to where it will do no harm. But like I said, for components, zapping it below 3000 volts is mainly overlooked. If you can't see or feel it, you simply don't know, and wonder why your system is acting goofy, or not working at all.
Message edited by Grimmy on 11-01-2007 at 07:54:08 AM
It was while I was screwing it into the case. I was big time concerned until it booted fine. I think I just got lucky
Long time back (1957 Merc w/push button transmission), I was driving and a 12 volt wire came loose. I was driving so I asked my wife to reconnect it to ground. See said I will not get shocked. I replyed NO it's only 12 V. After getting zapped by 20 to 50KV - she still works - BUT she has never let me forget it either. Latter I learned the reason - A coil trys to maintain a contant current ie if that current is 1 amp and you open the circuit - with you on one end and your body resistance is 100K then YOU HAVE 100KV (Very short duration)
OK, here's some info on ESD for those(and quite a few actually) that only know 1/2 the story on ESD.
Before I start, remember Ground = 0v. Why is stuff grounded? Many items you have are grounded so that if a wire comes loose inside and shorts to the outside of your item(especially if it's metal) then the voltage might try to pass through your body in an effort to get to ground. The ground wire is added for come components because the resistance to ground via the wire is rated for almost no resistance. Electricity will always take the path of least resistance, and your cool mower/iron/etc shorts to ground(tripping 1 or more safety devices in the process stopping the short) instead of trying to go through your hand and body, possibly killing you along the way.
| maury73 wrote : All modern PC components must tolerate ESD as per the FCC and UL rules: at least 2kV for human body model and 4kV for the machine model. |
This is partly true and partly false. It is true that it's CAN be dangerous to ground yourself directly. Pretend you were working on a piece of equipment that had capacitors/high voltages. If you had a grounding strap on you and it was 0 ohms, you'd be the perfect ground for the electricity to go to. ZAP is what you'd get. (This is precisely why your household goods have a ground. THEY make the perfect ground instead of you.) You'd get the full blunt of voltage. This is bad because you could very well die. If you have a 1 Mega-ohm resistance, even at 1000v you'd feel it, but it wouldn't kill you. The whole reason for the high resistance of the grounding strap is to save your life if you are working in anything that has live voltages present. I can't vouch for the actual voltage numbers for ESD here because the number's I'm trained with are 50kV. Is it safe to be grounded with no resistance when playing with your computer. Not entirely because you could get shocked by the capacitors in the components. Is this likely? Not really. Is it high enough voltages? You'd have to consult the specs for the equipment(who the hell would even do this anyway?).
Remember that it's not the voltage that hurts/kills you, it's the current. The other part of the 'equation' for a shock to kill you is frequency. Of course, ESD frequency is 0.
Current = Voltage / Resistance
1mA = felt
10mA = involuntary muscle control(just like when you get shocked by a doorknob your arm pulls back)
100mA = if across the heart can cause death
The whole purpose of grounding yourself is because you do not want your body to be at a different voltage than the equipment you are handling. If you were in a room with a wire strapped to your waist at 100v, and you reached into a computer that had a ground of 100v, it would be just as if you were using it with a ground of 0 volts. The difference between your body and the computer is 0.
Now, to settle a few other comments people had.
@Jonesy1499
1) The paint won't do you much good since it will insulate. If you just grab the metal directly that'll provide a good ground.
2) I usually set up my new computer by installing my PSU. I make sure it's hardware switch is off and then I plug it in. I do all remaining steps for assembly using my computer case as ground. The ground is hard wired, and is not affected by the power switch. It does not increase the risk of being electrocuted. This 'impossibility' is made even more impossible by making sure the power button on your power supply is off before you plug it in the first time. Then no capacitors have a charge.
3) You'd be correct that if you were shorting yourself out to your case while running back and forth across carpet you'd kind of defeat the purpose. I wouldn't recommend you set up your computer in the bathroom either because of how damp bathrooms can be.
Now, here's some thought provoking comments.
Question: What makes an ESD bag different from a plastic bag you get from Wal-Mart when you buy an item?
Answer: ESD bags actually slightly conduct electricity. Crazy but true. Their color will actually tell you what metal is inside the plastic. It's a high resistance plastic, but it does conduct enough to HELP protect. Keyword help.
The reason that this is so is because of what is defined as 'ground'. If you are picking up a video card from an ESD bag you are probably going to pull the card out next. Pretend you are at 1kV and the bag is sitting on a table at 0v. When you pick it up the ESD bag is going to allow a very small current to pass through the bag to the card. This will effectively put the voltage of the card at the same voltage of your body. You next grab the card and all is well because you and the card are at the same voltage.
I said above that it helps to protect. Pretend that you ran around the house with your socks on rubbing them across that new carpet you bought. You grab that ESD bag and the pull the card off the table as fast as you can. The bag has resistance, and it might not have been able to equalize the voltage between the card and your body before you grabbed the card. End result: Video card got shocked.
Now take that same idea and apply it to building a computer. Except your case = ESD bag, and your video card = all the components.
You probably touch the case of your computer somewhere while you are assembling it, right? So those parts have obviously matched the voltage of your body. Is this good? Not entirely because that shock was low resistance. 1 quick shock and all of your components COULD(and probably did to an extent) receive a healthy shock. Sucky huh?
So, overall what's the best way to assemble your computer? Assemble your computer in a case that is grounded(to a real ground), where you are also grounded(to a real ground). You also do not want to be a short to ground yourself in the event you get shocked with live voltage looking for ground. What's the easiest way to do this? Use the ground of your PSU and ground yourself to the PSU with a wristband. Of course you should definitely make sure your power supply is off. If you are worried that some schmuck might turn it on, you could always turn off the PSU switch and the power strip your computer is plugged into(or even the breaker if you were that concerned).
Now, how would I tell someone to assmeble a computer that isn't all knowing on ESD?
1. Assemble your computer on a table other surface that doesn't ESD. If you have new carpet do it in a different room if possible.
2. Install your PSU to your case first, make sure the switch is off then plug it into the wall.
3. Install all of your components in your computer, touching the case(and therefore grounding yourself) first.
4. After everything is installed you can move the computer to whatever location your computer will be used in.
For those that pay attention to every single detail:
Is there a remote itty bitty teeny weeny chance of getting live voltage? Yeah. If someone turns on your PSU AND you licked or otherwise shorted out the PSU pins with your body you COULD.
Is there still a itty bitty teeny weeny chance of ESD damaging your computer? Yes.
Do I care about these extremely remote possibilities? Nope.
Well, why the heck don't you care? Because I am not a corporation where I'm handling millions of dolllars of equipment every day. What happens if I somehow forget to ground myself to my computer? Probably nothing. Worst case I destroy a part(and I get to RMA it). If I were a company it could mean millions gone due to repairs and lost productivity. Also at work where I'm doing this day in and day out it's not hard to implement some basic grounding straps. At home it's a bit more difficult. So partly it's convenience and partly it's the stakes.
If you are REALLY that concerned about ESD, sure you can spend the $10 for a grounding strap at Radio Shack. But...I think that it's really more of a phobia people have than an actual scenario you should fear. I assemble computers all the time, and I can't remember the last time I thought that I might have destroyed a component. Just try to handle the components by the edges and all will be fine.
Message edited by cyberjock on 11-01-2007 at 11:12:45 AM
Reply to cyberjock
I use the install PSU first and keep touching the case frequently method. Also, I always build on the kitchen table, nice flat surface with plenty of room, good light, and no carpet. Have put together many PC's over the years this way and never had any problems.
I was just waiting for RetiredChief to focus some glare on the drones in this thread. Thanks.
Grimmy's comments about what you can and cannot feel were good too. A typical office chair with casters on it can pick up an incredible amount of static just rolling on the floor. I don't sit in one when I'm building.
I saw an electron microscope shot of a static hit on a semiconductor. It looked like cupcake icing through which a yard ape had dabbed a finger.
Reply to jtt283
| jtt283 wrote : A typical office chair with casters on it can pick up an incredible amount of static just rolling on the floor. I don't sit in one when I'm building. |
Good point. I would suggest sitting on a wooden bar stool if you need to sit.
| jtt283 wrote :
|
I've seen this video as well. I found this image after a quick google search (note the trace has been severed and there are bits of material spread around):
Message edited by qwertycopter on 11-01-2007 at 05:00:37 PM
| cyberjock wrote : 2. Install your PSU to your case first, make sure the switch is off then plug it into the wall. |
I'm hoping you can answer this. If you connect your PSU to the case, then touch the case wall, how is that voltage being transfered from the case to the PSU? Through the mounting screws? Wouldn't you have to ground yourself to one of the black pins on a PSU connector?
Message edited by qwertycopter on 11-01-2007 at 04:57:41 PM
I guess that that old verbage "An once of prevention is better than a pound of cure" is only for geeks and sissies; or why wear a seat bealt - I've never had an accident, or He doulbe LL I don't need a helmet when riding a motorcycle - But then that persons head is fill with a substance (Not brains) that is harder than concrete.
Reference to large Corporations. That $300/$400 dollars or that 100/300 dollar ram to us poor folks who only make 50K is the same as a million dollars to GE, Csco, and INTEL/AMD.
Reference to "Metalized" ESD bags. That metal coating is only on one side and it's main fuction is to dissapate the electrical charge so as to not have a concentrated electrical charge buildup.
The greatest danger to ESD is when assembling the parts outside of the case. ESD mats, de-ionizer est are too expensive for the occational builder. (I do have a ESD mat complements of work) But give me a break a $10 - $15 wrist strap to minimize even a small change of ESD.
TO MrsB - This is the same metality I find common in people to lazy to put on a wrist stap and then try to justify that action. That attidute is fine for your own systems, But to jepordize a customer is unforgivable.
Message edited by RetiredChief on 11-01-2007 at 05:30:58 PM
Qwertycopter.
The "ground" wire is attached to the PSU Case, The PSU case is connected to the computer case (ie through the monting screws PS don't use nylon mounting screws for the PSU). As mentioned, connect to "Bare" metal as paint is a insulator (poor), also do not connect to anodized metal. Anodized metal is an oxide, and Metal Oxides are very poor conductors. This is also the reason connector pins are often gold plated - Gee I bet some of you thought it was because it was a better conductor.
Message edited by RetiredChief on 11-01-2007 at 05:31:24 PM
| qwertycopter wrote : I'm hoping you can answer this. If you connect your PSU to the case, then touch the case wall, how is that voltage being transfered from the case to the PSU? Through the mounting screws? Wouldn't you have to ground yourself to one of the black pins on a PSU connector? |
The best way to understand that, is the use of a multimeter, using continuity.
Not sure if you understand that. When you have it set to continuity, to touch the pos/neg prongs, and you should hear a beep. That indicates a circuit for electricity to follow. The PSU is grounded by itself through the power cable on the 3rd prong. So buy using the multimeter, touching one prong to he PSU casing, then the other to the power cord ground, it should beep. So just by mounting it to a case with bare metal will conduct any ESD to the ground.
Also, when you plug the PSU into the MB, the 20 or 24pin molex plug has a ground wire that you end up plugging in. So ESD should be able to take the least path out of the MB traces to that ground wire -> PSU ground ->AC outlet, rather then going through a component. Although, electricity can't always be predicable.
The PSU is grounded to the case anywhere metal is touching metal, as RetiredChief said. It's only the really purdy PSUs that would get the grounding through the screws only.
I work on PBXs (private branch exchanges - business telephone switches). My partner has been in the business for 30+ years, he used to be a central office (C.O.) installer for Bell. He puts his hands all over the boards, which I do give him crap for doing. I have been working with him for 15 Years and have never seen a failure. The floors are usually tile and by touching the PBX you clear any ESD, but the wrist strap requirement is a little overblown. I don't bother wearing a wrist strap, and I do own 2-3, I just periodically touch the exposed metal hinge of the refrigerator, obviously I do my builds in the kitchen, and I don't wear a wool sweater while building. The PSU plugged in with the switch off is good as long as you don't dork.
As far as doing a build in the bathroom or on the carpet, I would choose the bathroom. There is not enough moisture in the air in the bathroom to present any problem whatsoever. Your not taking a shower with the build. Just don't do a build right after someone has used the shower and wipe the place down with a towel and you will be fine.
Message edited by Zorg on 11-01-2007 at 08:14:27 PM
The reason the chassis can be connected to ground through the PSU is because the the power supply's chassis is connected internally to the lead that will go to earth ground. The power supply chassis touching the whole case will conduct, so if you discharge on the case, it will conduct to the PSU chassis, and then through that to the ground. People need to remember that voltage is a potential, not a fixed value. Even grounds can be at different potentials than one another.
Zorg
I have a son who is a Double E and is part owner of an Eclectronic design company (Technovare). He designed the video interface that sony uses in all the large screen displays at the London Stadum. He doesn't use a strap very often either. I quite getting on his case, He's as hard headed as myself. His home computer is a deul quad zeon with an 1800 dolar GPU. When I'm out there (He lives in LA) I'm goning to rum 3Dmarks06 just for SH__ and grins.
Wow, I can't complain about not getting enough replies! Thanks a bunch, guys! (Esp. to quertycopter and cyberjock for their long posts.)
I'll make sure to study all your info carefully before I start building. (I still don't have all the parts yet, thanks to the slowness of the Danish postal service. I should tomorrow, though.)
| qwertycopter wrote :
|
I know what you mean, although the correct technical term would be "obsessive" rather than paranoid!
| nukemaster wrote : while ure at it why not set this up....only takes a few minutes
|
Hmm, are you sh***ing me? (Sorry, it's not everyday I get the chance to do a pun.)
By the way, I went and bought an antistatic wristband yesterday and took the opportunity to talk a bit about ESD prevention with the seller. He said that touching the case with the PSU installed would only work if both the power socket and plug had ground connection (which I guess is obvious when you think about it - or know something about power, which I obviously don't). But the PSU probably won't come with a ground pin as they aren't standard in Denmark. So I guess that leaves me with either a faucet or a radiator.
I will post some more obsessive questions later.
| qwertycopter wrote : You can discharge it by simply touching some nearby steel/aluminum/copper. In fact, you can touch the inside of your metal case (and it doesn't have to have the PSU plugged in) and it will sufficiently discharge any built up static |
Is this just as effective as when the PSU is plugged in and grounded? I mean if it is, then why do people bother with connecting the PSU first? Also, could I just attach my wrist strap to a non-grounded piece of metal?
| cyberjock wrote : 1. Assemble your computer on a table other surface that doesn't ESD. |
As long as it's a table does it matter what material it's made of and if it's covered with something? I'm guessing wood is good, but can it be "fake" wood (particle board), or wood covered with a sheet of material such as this?
(I just peeled a little bit off. I don't know what the material is called - maybe it's some kind of plastic or vinyl or something?. It's supposed to look like some kind of other wood, and has glue on the back. Btw, preparing this computer build has made me aware of how profoundly ignorant I am about all the things we take for granted, electricity, building materials, etc.)
| qwertycopter wrote : Good point. I would suggest sitting on a wooden bar stool if you need to sit.
|
I don't have any of those.
How about a chair such as this, with some kind of fake(?) leather on the seat and back?
Sorry if I'm going overboard with pictures.
| qwertycopter wrote : I'm hoping you can answer this. If you connect your PSU to the case, then touch the case wall, how is that voltage being transfered from the case to the PSU? Through the mounting screws? Wouldn't you have to ground yourself to one of the black pins on a PSU connector? |
Yes. It's passing throgh the mounting screws and the fact that the PSU is touching the case itself.
The black pins are common, not ground. Common is supposed to be at the same voltage as ground, but common is supposed to be the intended path for current flow. When I was learning about all this stuff I asked the instructor what the difference was between common and ground. The answer I got was 'it's just a different path for current flow'. I know that this ideal wouldn't matter if I was using an incandescent bulb and used ground instead of common, but if the bulb was connected to a GFCI(ground fault circuit interrupter) then the GFCI would trip.
Grounding yourself to a black pin on the PSU would actually be worthless because the power switch SHOULD be off. (You did turn off the power supply didn't you?)<-- joke.
Anyway, because you are dealing with electronics and changing voltage and frequency from 120V/60hz or 240v/50hz to DC you don't want ground and common to be the same. Then you could have current flow going backwards from common to ground. This would almost certainly destroy the PSU. I can't tell you for 100% certainty you couldn't short common and ground together, but I'm not gonna test it to find out.
Reply to cyberjock
| cyberjock wrote : OK, here's some info on ESD for those(and quite a few actually) that only know 1/2 the story on ESD.
|
Thanks for saying this so I didn't have to....
I work for a huge company with 400+ servers at this site alone (2 major sites with 22 smaller ones) and I always wear a wrist strap/grounding mat when working with that eqipment because I don't want to be responsable for trashing a 30,000$ peice of equipment...
now my own equipment thats a different story.. lol I install sh!t on carpet all the time. now I know this is a bad practice but for a 1000$ worth of my own equipment I don't care that much
( I still touch my case often, press the power button (once unplugged) to drain remainder juice and all that)
-------------------------------
I am the Root of all your problems
Reply to hell_spawn
| Jonesy1499 wrote : Is this just as effective as when the PSU is plugged in and grounded? I mean if it is, then why do people bother with connecting the PSU first? |
This has been answered in previous posts. With the PSU attached static discharge goes to real/absolute ground. This is best practice, but I would say not necessary. Without the PSU, the discharge goes to the case. In theory, that puts your installed components at higher risk. But in practice, we see that the case effectively "absorbs" shock. Any piece of metal has resistance (to the flow of electrons). In a piece of wire, the resistance is pretty low, and therefore negligible. A case, however, has a heck of a lot more metal, so the resistance is increased. So once the discharge has occurred, it has to go through all that metal to affect a component. By that time, there little chance of frying anything.
If you're connected to absolute ground, you have 0 Volts of static buildup.
But when you discharge to the case (not connected to absolute ground), you are only equalizing your charge with that of the case.
In practice it shouldn't matter. But, also remember to handle your components with ESD in mind.
As for the table and chair you mentioned... I'm not sure. Plastics and vinyls will generate static. I probably would skip the chair. I would think the table is fine, but usually you set your components on a safe surface, such as cardboard.
| Jonesy1499 wrote : By the way, I went and bought an antistatic wristband yesterday and took the opportunity to talk a bit about ESD prevention with the seller. He said that touching the case with the PSU installed would only work if both the power socket and plug had ground connection (which I guess is obvious when you think about it - or know something about power, which I obviously don't). But the PSU probably won't come with a ground pin as they aren't standard in Denmark. So I guess that leaves me with either a faucet or a radiator.
|
I'm guessing most have overlooked this, but I can see your concern. So in Denmark, they don't have 3 prong plugs? So there's only 2 for pos/neg on the outlet? (Look for ->Type C (European 2-pin)
Assuming you don't have a ground on the AC outlet, do you have a garage with concrete floor with a work bench? Out of a house or Apartment, the kitchen would be the best spot to work, standing near a reg wood top table, if you are really concerned with static. Grabbing the sink faucet with your hand would actually be a sufficient ground to discharge any static.
Kinda wonder how much ESD could build up if you don't have an earth type ground..
Reference to cyberjock concerning Black for common and if it is connected to Ground.
Answer: YES. In a computer, the "Earth Ground" and the Black PSU lead (Common) are both tied to the case. Therefore, in this case you can connect to the black lead and be grounded with the PSU plugged in, and off. This is the reason you can connect the Black lead of a volt meter to the case and measure system voltages.
The term common denotes just that a common tie point and as such a reference. it MAY, or may NOT be connected to chassie ground (In the most it is). Some electronic systems isolate common from Chassie.
Grimmy,
Hope you don't mind me correcting a slip of the tongue. "So there's only 2 for pos/neg on the outlet"
When dealing with AC (Alternating Current) Line voltage - There is no pos/neg. There is a Hot (or Live, Which alternates between Pos and negative), a nuetral (or common) and a "earth" ground.
Reference USA: We have two hot (115 VAC) which are 180 degress out off phase (Black wire - Bad choice), a White for nuetral (or common), and Green for earth ground. The voltage between the 2 Hot wire is 240. At some point the Common and earth Ground is tied together (ie at the Fuse box).
England - Uses one Hot @ 240, a nuetral/common, and a earh ground.
Naa... I don't mind. Kinda slip my mind that AC is labled different from DC.
. o O ( I hate it when it hurts to think, not to mention getting shocked by an AC outlet)
Message edited by Grimmy on 11-02-2007 at 04:59:51 PM
Yea, I've been hit a few (too many to count) times. Worst was when adjusting the Horizon output on a color tV My pinky got to close - It was in a preachers house - all I could say was that smarted!. Got my hand to close to the A+ (35KV) on a color picute tube - that one set my on the flour. Also done some arch welding, Melted my vom probe tip once. HATE the use of black wire for "Hot"
Message edited by RetiredChief on 11-02-2007 at 05:16:10 PM
MrsB
Probably correct, He primarily does Electronic design. A lot of it is in the area of streaming video for his company. His hobby is Photograph. He takes the official pictures for the Scifi charity that is held begining of Dec. My wife goes out there to assist, and he took her picture with Sulu, Uhura, Dr. Wier, the Gen in SG1. He also took the Last Group picture of the orignal Star Trek Crew - William shatner wanted Asa to give him the Picture, Asa told him to shove it.
Any way, Just curious - so I'll try it.
| RetiredChief wrote : MrsB
|
hahah I love it
-------------------------------
I am the Root of all your problems
Reply to hell_spawn
| qwertycopter wrote : This has been answered in previous posts. With the PSU attached static discharge goes to real/absolute ground. This is best practice, but I would say not necessary. Without the PSU, the discharge goes to the case. In theory, that puts your installed components at higher risk. But in practice, we see that the case effectively "absorbs" shock. Any piece of metal has resistance (to the flow of electrons). In a piece of wire, the resistance is pretty low, and therefore negligible. A case, however, has a heck of a lot more metal, so the resistance is increased. So once the discharge has occurred, it has to go through all that metal to affect a component. By that time, there little chance of frying anything.
|
Hate to break it to you, but the more metal the lower the resistance. That's why thicker wire can carry more current. This is also why hardcore car stereo freaks wanna buy the world's thickest wire(for the most part). More current carrying capacity because of the lower resistance.
| RetiredChief wrote : Reference to cyberjock concerning Black for common and if it is connected to Ground.
|
So I got curious. I pulled out my spare power supply and did some resistance from the case of the PSU to the black pins. You know what I got?
0.412 ohms, 204.3ohms, 1.4ohms. Every damn black pin on the 24 pin connection had a different resistance! Of course all of the other black pins on the molex/SATA connectors were all 1.4ohms. Go figure they wouldn't all match!
Reply to cyberjock
Cyberjock.
I orginally just measured the Black molex lead to computer case.
Based on your reply. I pulled out a CoolerMaster igreen 600W PSU. With a Fluke 85III DVM I measured all (Except the Sata returns - couldn't insert meter probe). I first measured the resistance between the AC Ground to the Mounting screw hole, which I zeroed out using the relative fuction. I then used this hole as the reference for all measurements ALL the black pins measured 0.0 ohms (less than 50 milliohms resoltion).
Could you please repeat your measurements. First verify AC ground to mounting screw hole and factor this out of your measurement.
Alternative - Measure one of the black molex connector to the black leads on the 24 pin connector - Mine reads 0.0 ohms
There is a method called single point return, where the "Commons" are only connected to chassie at one point, either the Source, or the subsystem - but not both. This is normally done to reduce ground loop EMI.
Bear in mind, for voltage readings to be accurate when using the chassie to connect the Black DVM lead, the common must tie to the chassie at some point. Another point is that when a subsytem uses multiple voltes (ie +5 and +12) their returns are normally connected. Example if you measure the +5 to the +12 you only get +7 if the returns are tied.
Sorry for the time delay, Slept in this morning Plus Had trouble with good old cox internet
editted
Found a 2nd PSU, an Off the wall el cheapo 300 W. Same resaults. All Black returns connected internally, and connected to PSU chassie. Did get approx 200 milliohms from Returns to PSU chassie which I atribute to connection resistance (ie pin to wire, lead and bonding - remember this is a cheap psu vs the igreen)
Message edited by RetiredChief on 11-03-2007 at 08:21:04 PM
There are 10 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
Please mind
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.
