Tom's Guide > Forum > General Networking > Network General Discussions > Cable vs DSL

Cable vs DSL

Forum General Networking : Network General Discussions - Cable vs DSL

TomsGuide.com: Over 800,000 questions and answers to address all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Ask the community Add a reply
Word :    Username :           
 
junglicious   12-09-2007 at 11:20:42 PM

I wanted to know what you users prefer. I know that cable is shared and can vary from neighbor usage and that DSL is direct but depends on how far you are from the central office? I wanted to know, in general which one do you prefer and have you tried both?

Thanks

Add a reply
Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
Grumpy9117   12-09-2007 at 11:45:10 PM
- 0 +

And you don't think DSL isn't shared once it leaves the CO. I'd go with whatever is cheaper.

Grumpy

Reply to Grumpy9117
g-paw   12-11-2007 at 01:43:57 AM
- 0 +

My experience is Cable is faster, I have Cable and 2 of my kids have DSL although I don't know what level they have. At least where I'm at, there is virtually no difference in price is the DSL has speeds close to cable.

Reply to g-paw
rattman169   12-11-2007 at 04:21:02 AM
- 0 +

Well that all depends. Now there are several companies that use DSL and the new ADSL2+ setup, which means the connection goes from the CO to the phone junction box near your premise,at the juction box is the new ADSL2+ "ERX" and can have speed of 24Mbs. I work with DSL and have worked with cable,depending on the service you get, you can get 6Mb DSL and have more bandwidth then cable (most cable companies have a 20Gb download/10Gb upload usage a month VS DSL and 60 GB a month downloads) and with comparable speed as cable and more stability then cable (constant 6Mb connection VS Cable variable rates due to many connection on same line). So you should check what the ISP's offer for the value and go with the better choice?

Reply to rattman169
Riser   12-11-2007 at 05:03:24 PM
- 0 +

Cable is throttled these days. DSL is guarenteed.

Pick whatever is cheaper. I personally don't like signing contacts so I avoid DSL.

------------------------------ "Alcoholism is a disease, but it's the only one you can get yelled at for having. Goddammit Otto, you are an alcoholic. Goddammit Otto, you have Lupus... one of those two doesn't sound right." M. H.
 Reply to Riser
junglicious   12-14-2007 at 06:13:46 AM
- 0 +

Thanks for all the input. What I might have to do is have both of them at the same time for a month. The thing is I cancel my land line a week ago so If I get DSL I would have to get a land line again. ATT top package is $35 at 6mb, so $35 + $16 for a land line would cost around $51. I have comcast now and pay around $50 (6mb) a month.

Reply to junglicious
davelakecity   01-02-2008 at 09:19:59 PM
- 0 +

I would find people in your area that have each (DSL or CABLE) and test each one using speedtest (or similiar).
For me cable has been great... downtown Syracuse now, standard road runner = 1200KBs down, 120+KBs up = best I've ever had. (road runner $30/month first 12 months)

------------------------------ P5N32-E-SLI, e4300@3.2, 4x1gig tracers 1:1 , 8800gts-320 OC ?/?, antec 850w psu, antec 900 case
Vista64 Ultimate
 Reply to davelakecity
rgeist554   01-03-2008 at 09:31:16 PM
- 0 +

DSL signals are going to degrade and become much slower the further you are from the NOC. I guess the same thing can be said for cable, but to a lesser extent...

Anyways, I think this is one of the best suggestions so far. :p

Quote :

I would find people in your area that have each (DSL or CABLE) and test each one using speedtest (or similiar).


Reply to rgeist554
stabgotham   01-09-2008 at 09:11:50 AM
- 0 +

DSL is going to be better in the future. A professor in Australia recently developed an algorithm that will increase DSL speeds up to 100mb/s, which is considerably faster then cable. Granted, he just did this, and the article I read stated that we probably wouldn't see it available to home users for another year to two years.

------------------------------ Lian Li PC61 | MSI K9A2 Platinum 790FX | AMD Athlon 64 X2 5000+ Black Edition | Xigmatek S1283 Rifle CPU Cooler | 4GB OCZ SLI-Edition DDR2 800 | Visiontek HD4850 | WD Caviar 250GB | X-Fi XtremeMusic | Samsung 17" 740n
 Reply to stabgotham
michaelahess   01-12-2008 at 03:22:18 AM
- 0 +

Cable is usually faster, and has a higher capactiy:

Docsis 3.0:
Down : 171.52Mb
Up: 122.88Mb

Plus the fact that most hybrid cable networks would be able to upgrade to fiber at some point if they needed to.

Bandwidth out of the ISP is very important. A DSL provider with 5Mb package and limited external bandwidth could be slower than a 2Mb cable package with adaquate bandwidth.

I've worked at both types of ISP's and cable is nice since the infastructure is actually owned by the same company, DSL still has to go through local telcos, and they don't always get along real well. Unless you get it straight from the telco.

Best advice is to check both though.

Reply to michaelahess
timby   01-14-2008 at 04:12:32 PM
- 0 +

While Cable internet looks to be faster than DSL in a lot of cases it isn't. Just because an ISP states they provide 5 Meg-bit down and over 700 K-bit up doesn't mean you'll have all the available bandwidth to use. You are on a shared pipe with cable and not DSL.

I canceled Time-Warner (Road Runner) because of bandwidth problems. Even though they were giving me 5 Mb down and over 700Kb up I wasn't getting any where near the specified speeds because my node was to congested. So I was getting better throughput on my old DSL. I switched to FIOS and am very please with my experience.

Just my 2 cents ....

Reply to timby
calyn   01-14-2008 at 06:33:18 PM
- 0 +

Cable and DSL both overbook, and generally to the same extent although this may differ per provider. The DOCSIS spec does indeed prmise a lot of bandwitdh, but this is shared and, if the provider is smart, uses balancing algorithms to mask this. DSL overbooking can gto up as far as 1:50 which is a nightmare at peak hours.

Which is the best? Neither one, as it's very dependent on the provider.

------------------------------ Humans become confused when presented with too many choices, and will limit themselves only to an inefficient subset of the available choices or none at all.
Reply to calyn
Ask the community Add a reply
Tom's Guide > Forum > General Networking > Network General Discussions > Cable vs DSL
Go to:

There are 9 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Forum map
Bestofmedia Forum ©
2000-2009 Bestofmedia Group
Page generated in 0.449 seconds
Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Google ads