New system!
Forum Overclocking : Motherboards - New system!
Hi I'm thinking of building a new system out of the parts listed below and wanted to check they are "sensible".
I need stability above all but must also be fast(ish) for media encoding etc. This PC is for my girlfriend.
I'm re using the other parts from her old PC such as Case, Floppy, HDD and DVD-Burner.
I have recently got a new Seasonic S12-430 for her (Better than mine
)
1, Will this pc overclock well?
2, Will it be stable?
3, Is 1GB enough for vista? (not getting it for ages though)
4, Is the 946GZ Chipset any good?
5, Is the onboard graphics good enough for basic (3D) games like the sims? (and for Aero?)
6, Is it going to need a force 10 wind to keep it cool? (her case only has 80mm mounts)
7, I need to solve the one PATA channel prob should I....
A, Use a Cheap SATA2PATA adaptor?
B, Use a ATA card for the Optical drive or the HDD?
C, Put the Optical drive in a USB box?
946GZ7MA-8KRS2H http://www.foxconnchannel.com/Prod [...] -us0000206
Intel Core 2 duo E4300
www.intel.com etc
OCZ 1GB Kit OCZ26671024VPDC-K
http://www.microdirect.co.uk/Produ [...] &GroupID=0
I love my girlfriend so please help me (us) out! You would if you knew her!
p.s I was going to get a WD1600AAJS based on the HDD charts from Toms but anandtech don't rate the drive at all (except for noise!)
http://www.anandtech.com/storage/showdoc.aspx?i=2920
Anyone?
Does anyone have any ideas? Is my question too hard someone must know!
First off, what form factor is your case?
Does it need to be mATX?
Will need to know this before I can help you with yor MB selection.
This MB's onboard graphics will not support Vista.
I am almost certian you need at least a GMA950 integrated graphics solution to run Vista.
It may be able to play some basic games, but not verry many and not verry well.
Your CPU is a verry good overclocker but I doubt your MB is.
1Gb ram is pretty low for Vista.
On my system at boot it uses ~750Mb before I even open any programs.
2Gb would treat you much better.
Really need to know what your budget is and what form factor you need your MB to be before I can help you more.
looks good, though I have no idea how well that mobo would 1. overclock or 2. if its stable
3. It will run, though not as fast as it could
4. the 945 series chipset is older, It will be ok for this system
5. sims will probably be ok, integrated graphics aren't enough for aero though
6. I doubt heat will be a problem as long as you don't go crazy on the overclocking
7. They make SATA DVD burners or you could get a SATA HDD, or you could get a different mobo or A B C
A. Sure
B. that would work
C. seems like kind of a hassle but yea
IDK about the overclock, or if you'd really need it anyway but I think your good as long as you 1. dont care about aero or get a graphics card and 2. do something about the one PATA
hi thanks for responses am going to change the spec completly (as you do)
Anyway gonna go for a
Gigabyte GA-965G-DS3
E4300
KVR667D2N5/512 Kingston Value Ram (about the only memory in the Gigabyte Memory list that i could find!)
Have now got a VIA VT6421 Raid card and seems to be okay in my test ( I practice RAID arrays with two old 4.2GB WD drives. It also recognises an old CD-rom so hope it picks up her DVD-Burner.
| Quote : Hi I'm thinking of building a new system out of the parts listed below and wanted to check they are "sensible".
|
Why do you need more than one IDE channel? You can make the HD the Master and the DVD drive slave. You'll get much better performance, however, if you get a SATA hard drive. 300 gigs for under $100 seems to be the norm online.
I'd go with a G965 chipset motherboard. the integrated X3000 graphics are actually the best I've seen. I've compared it to a 7600 GS card and it's not far off.
MB and CPU look decent.
Your MB's onboard will suport aero and should allow for basic gaming.
Depending on your budget, it might be worthwhie to get the GA-965P-DS3 mb with a little better video card.
Give this, or this ram a try.
Corsair makes some of the best memory out there.
Unless you need raid 5 or 10, I am not shure what you would need a raid card for.
Gigabyte's DS3 MB supports raid 0 and 1 so you should be fine without it.
| Quote : the integrated X3000 graphics are actually the best I've seen. I've compared it to a 7600 GS card and it's not far off. |
Meh...
X3000 performs almost the same as the 6200TC, not the 7600GS.
Plus it will share memory with the rest of the system.
Here are some charts to play with to see the diffrence.
| Quote : the integrated X3000 graphics are actually the best I've seen. I've compared it to a 7600 GS card and it's not far off. |
Meh...
X3000 performs almost the same as the 6200TC, not the 7600GS.
Plus it will share memory with the rest of the system.
Here are some charts to play with to see the diffrence. Well let's see. I own both. If I run a test with the 7600 GS, then take the card out and enable the onboard graphics and run the same test and the numbers are negligibly close....how does that NOT make them comparable? Hmmm. :?
Where exactly are the x3000 numbers in your chart?
I don't even see my 7600 GS card in the chart!
http://www.gigabyte.com.tw/Product [...] 76G512P-RH
before getting too excited check these links
early drivers gma x3000 vs gma950 (at bottom of article)
http://www.hardwarezone.com/articl [...] =6&id=2058
using the most recent 14.25 drivers ignore the synthetic scores and look at real world gaming benchmarks
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/c [...] 50_12.html
gma950 compared to geforce 6200 for reference (read through the whole article for even more benchmarks)hit refresh if the article doesnt load
http://www.extremetech.com/article [...] 813,00.asp
Conclusion
1.In real world gaming the GMA950 beats the GMA x3000 hands down even when the newest 14.25 drivers are used.
2.The geforce 6200 beats the GMA950 easily.
| Quote : Unless you need raid 5 or 10, I am not shure what you would need a raid card for.
|
She does't need RAID (yet) but she is training for a Administrator (not IT Admin!) job and eventully i will (later this year) get her a decent SATA system drive and use the RAID card for 2x Big storage drives in RAID 1. So the RAID card is just to get her HDD and ODD on seperate channels (not good to bout more than one device on one channel, unless you data transfers dont copy from one to the other.)
***Just noted (as you mention) that it has an onboard SATA RAID controller so will remove the SATA/PATA RAID card when upgrading to SATA.***
| Quote : Conclusion
|
Yes the X3000 is no wonder and I dont expect it to compete with even a £30 PCI-e card but it means I save £30 for a nice meal with her.
At Xmas I going to get her a nice GPU 8-series (and maybe Vista will be better by then).
And also three SATA disks (one 160ish system drive and Two RAID 1'ed 500GB Drives.
Hopefully new X3000 drivers will be relased to improve it, not that i'm going to update her GPU drivers once a month! (asking for trouble sometimee so will put it off for when I Reinstall windows
Well I see that you are going with mATX are you going to have a tight budget I love building PCs on a budget. I do pretty well in getting great performance for my dollar.
Here are a few suggestions from me.
Try looking AMD x2 CPUs
I would definitly use a stand alone video card. Especially with Vista
Is ATX from factor still workable for you. Gives you more space to work with and is some times less money for a better board
CPU
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6819103741
MOBO
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813138041
VIDEO
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814130075
MEMORY
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820141218
or if you have the funds
MEMORY
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820145527
HD
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6822147007
Buy as many as you like and use onboard RAID. Or if you would like more storage and you have the funds go with 700GB models.
Although I have never personally used a standalone RAID pci card. I believe that the onboard RAID should suffice.
I have heard that the AMDx2 Windsors overclock really well and stay cool. If you are serious about overclocking make sure you use something other than stock cooling fans although I have heard that the stock fans are pretty good.
I hope this helps you a little bit.
| Quote : before getting too excited check these links
|
Gee, that would be impressive, and on topic, if his build for g/f was to be built for games. I believe he said it was for media encoding. And reading your links, it appears that x3000 spanks the GMA950. Right now the X3000 doesn't do as well with OpenGL...games!
Thanks for the backup!
Yeah the PC is for Media encoding and a little games, a standalone is always better simply because it frees up memory (even if it is fast)
So that board looks good except I can't find a place that does (or can confirm) Revision 3.3.
Has any one got a Rev3.3 (of the GA-965G-DS3 ) and if so where did they buy it? (In the U.K or sensible shipping from the US.
| Quote :
|
Dinner w/ a Lady > Video card
| Quote :
|
And If that dosen't get you laid, I don't know what will
Best luck finding your MB.
Wish I could help you get the right revision, but I am in the states and don't know anyone who ships to the UK.
Also, if you plan on doing more then a moderate OC, you should consider a better HS.
BTW, need to correct my first post.
Not that it makes much a diffrence, but your inital MB would have supported Vista and Aero.
Here are the specs for that MB's chipset, which features a GMA 3000 (not X3000).
Still a bad overclocker, but it will run vista.
1, Will this pc overclock well? If you use Core 4300 perhaps to 266 Mhz because it supports 266 Mhz(1066 Mhz oced)
2, Will it be stable?
3, Is 1GB enough for vista? (not getting it for ages though) yes
4, Is the 946GZ Chipset any good? get a 965 that's good
5, Is the onboard graphics good enough for basic (3D) games like the sims? (and for Aero?) 946GZ = GMA3000, 965G = GMA X3000 big difference, search the web about it.
6, Is it going to need a force 10 wind to keep it cool? (her case only has 80mm mounts) 1 side air duct, 1 rear fan (for sure), 1 input fan (recommended)
7, I need to solve the one PATA channel prob should I....
A, Use a Cheap SATA2PATA adaptor? Please no
B, Use a ATA card for the Optical drive or the HDD? Optical ata always, HDD sata always
C, Put the Optical drive in a USB box?No
| Quote : 6, Is it going to need a force 10 wind to keep it cool? (her case only has 80mm mounts) 1 side air duct, 1 rear fan (for sure), 1 input fan (recommended)
|
6, which way should the side fan point input or extract? should the tube that comes with them (the ones i've seen) go right over the CPU HSF?
B, yeah definatly do you happen to know why anandtech slate the WD1600AAJS drive yet it's the best "cheap" drive on toms HDD chart?
If you want the save money and use board video go with a ati or nvidia mb.
| Quote : 6, Is it going to need a force 10 wind to keep it cool? (her case only has 80mm mounts) 1 side air duct, 1 rear fan (for sure), 1 input fan (recommended)
|
6, which way should the side fan point input or extract? should the tube that comes with them (the ones i've seen) go right over the CPU HSF?
B, yeah definatly do you happen to know why anandtech slate the WD1600AAJS drive yet it's the best "cheap" drive on toms HDD chart?
Actually the GMA950 and GMAx3000 are neck and neck with encoding according to the links. The 6200tc still would beat both in encoding as well. BUT it would not replace a romantic dinner with the GF
Theres no contest there
From Scan.co.uk...
LN17304
Intel Core 2 Duo E4300, Socket 775, 1.86 GHz, 800MHz FSB, Allendale Core, 2MB Cache, Retail £92.69 £108.91
LN16281
Gigabyte GA 965GM-S2 iG965, S775, PCI-E (x16), DDR2 533/667/800, SATA II, SATA RAID, uATX, VGA £57.99 £68.14
LN13268
1Gb Elixir, DDR2 PC5300 (667), 240 Pin, Non-ECC Unbuffered, CAS 5 Major Retail £40.89 £48.05
LN11461
250 Gb Samsung SP2504C SpinPoint P120, SATA300, 7200 rpm, 8MB Cache, 9.0 ms, NCQ £39.57 £46.49
TOTAL £278.62 (including delivery and VAT)
The side fan must blow air towards the interior of the pc, if you're going to oc it may be better to put a fn blowing towards the interior of the pc, otherwise putting the side air duct, quite in line with the processor fan would do the work as most modern heatsink fans blow air towards the heatsink therefore processor side.
The side fan will mostly depend on how concerned are you with the noise and how cooled is the room in which you place the computer.
An input fan is very well appreciated as long as it blows air towards the hard drive(s), mostly the integrated circuit part, as it will down the temperatures by quite a big margin, with WD2500KS 250 Gb 16 Mb SataII it was 22-25ºC with fan blowing and 42-45ºC without. Lowing the temperature enhances the lifespan of the hard drive.
I hope this helps
Ok thanks for advice, Her case has no side vent so if the CPU struggles (don't think it will) then I will cut a (120mmhole) and get a big Copper passive HS and have the 120mm cool the CPU.
Hi I'm back!
(Long post this) Ok so i got the parts today and my girlfriend is also coming round. (I pick her up at a bus stop so I dont have to drive all the way). So jobs in rough chronalogical order were
1, Prepare case for big day Cut the front fan blockages with a dremel
2, Install fans and postion them so that the cables are at least tidy-er than normal
3, Keep Girlfriend amused with Cheescake (Must have dope inside)
4, Unpack and marvel how it remids me of a 2003 P4 board from gigabyte and how I still use it for my familys PC so they use the web.
5, Read the instructions a few times so i am familar with the (for me) new S775 CPU
6, Nervously take out the unwanted MB standoff's and put them in correct places (I use 6 in this Case/MB combination)
7, (The bit i hate) Install the board (never sure what to hold) and hear it scrape as it clicks into place into port bracket
8, screw in screws to Standoffs and at this point some of the standoffs use different threads (Some HDD/Case style and some ODD/Floppy style)
9, Connect stuff like the 24-pin PSU and 4-pin 12V connector (Was expecting an 8-pin)
10, take chip out of packing (I got the retail one to avoid first-timer mistakes) The TIM is already applied to the bottom of the Retail HSF to make life easier and pressed home the four pins (Would prefer nuts and bolts)
11, Installed memory (2x 512MB for dual channel)
12, hooked up just PWR on front panel connector and turned on wall voltage and PSU voltage and pressed the big red button....... Beep (The nicest sound in the world) (Normally I never suceed in doing a first time boot as the memory slots are dusty)
13, Bios version is F4 so updated that using floppy to F7)
14, Post's again phew!
15, loaded optimised defaults
16, posts again so started fiddling
17, Notice that you can have the onboard GPU as well as PCI-e card so great for multi monitor setup
18, Notice all sorts of other options
19, Use my new VIA VT6421 card to control the ODD because my 642 had a boot rom I can select the drive directly in the BIOS (if i use CD-ROM I get nowhere)
20, XP disc boots and installs... BSOD sh1t. Turns out you have to install the F6 driver even though was only using drive to install windows.
21, Install F6 driver and all is well and XP installs just fine!
22, Loaded the supplied CD to install Drivers and this completes sucessfully
23, Installed Autopatcher, Spyware Blaster, Spybot Search and Destroy all okay plug in network cable to update above and all is well
Spent rest of day playing with it and seems okay except for using Easy tune 5 to get a 20% increase whch killed the onboard NIC! a reboot and turned off O/Cing sorted it!
Was running a 10% O/C and now Memtest reports errors <if I use the Test All Memory AND Bios-All options>. Windows Memory Diagnostic (From UBCD 3.4
http://www.ultimatebootcd.com/ reports no errors.
I ran Prime 95 for about an hour (earlier today) and it was okay so dont know why memtest failed. I'm hoping that memtest is just too old for DDR2 or maybe the 965???
Gonna run more tests (maybe Prime 95 overnight) and hope for the best otherwise will just start RMA'ing!
P.S the Bios version is REV 1.0
There are 10 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.
Please mind
You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.
