Tom's Guide > Forum > Overclocking > Cooler and Heatsinks > What is your preferred CPU cooling solution?

What is your preferred CPU cooling solution?

Forum Overclocking : Cooler and Heatsinks - What is your preferred CPU cooling solution?

TomsGuide.com: Over 800,000 questions and answers to address all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
What is your preferred CPU cooling solution?




Warning, if you click on "see results", you won't be able to vote
Page:    Previous 1 2 Next Bottom Search this thread
Word :    Username :           
 

I thought I would keep this simple for collection of data toward total percentage

You don’t need to reply if you dont want too .
just click and leave donations :mrgreen:

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

Thats odd 8O
there only seems to be 6 users with coolers on there cpus so far

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

Air is teh bombz0rz. It is effective on my cpu, but not super-effective on my wallet.

Reply to xyzunit
- 0 +

who needs a wallet when we have credit cards :lol:

Reply to kwalker

Quote :

I thought I would keep this simple for collection of data toward total percentage



Different applications require different solutions, so please add:

"All of the above as needed."

Reply to clue69less

Quote :

I thought I would keep this simple for collection of data toward total percentage



Different applications require different solutions, so please add:

"All of the above as needed."

Good point. I went for extreme because thats just how I roll. I don't like doing things the *normal* way. I like the challenge of extreme cooling.

I know it isn't cost effective, and frankly I don't care. What I do like is the challenge of eeeeeking every last MHz out of the FSB just to see how ridiculous ridiculous can get.

Plus, I learn alot when doing extreme things. :D

Reply to SuperFly03
- 0 +

I did toy with Idea of "all of the above"
but was more interested in actual user experience over desire.
the in depth aproach would require me to think :wink:

Reply to kwalker

Quote :

I did toy with Idea of "all of the above"
but was more interested in actual user experience over desire.
the in depth aproach would require me to think :wink:



Yeah it is too late for serious thinking....

Reply to SuperFly03
- 0 +

Im Running A 300Watt Peltier With A Oversized Custom Copper Nickel Coat Plate/Core Aluminum Heatsink And A Duct Pulling Air In From A 120mm 3500RPM, 96CFM Fan

Reply to Hella-D
- 0 +

I'd be interested in your temps.
So would a few others here

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

Well Due To The 90nm And High OC (Stock For This CPU Is 2.0GHz) I Get Around 80F Idle And Load Temps In The 120 - 130F Range

Reply to Hella-D

Thats not too bad, mid 50's. It is on the high side, but 3.2GHz dual core 939 @1.55v.... not too bad. My damn 939 maxed at 2.75 single core.... how stupid is that bs. I prob hit 40-41 on load, so 50's isn't bad at all. :D

Reply to SuperFly03
- 0 +

Well The Peltier Was Simply To Allow A Cool OC Without Too Much Hassle As Long As The Temps Are Not Above Spec It Dont Matter Much To Me And If I Can Play A Game For 4 Hours Striaght With The Room Temperate Being Almost 100F And Not Have A Crash Im Doing Good And Trust Me Ive Tried

Reply to Hella-D
- 0 +

Quote :

http://www.supremelaw.org/systems/ [...] arning.htm


Sincerely yours,
/s/ Paul Andrew Mitchell
Webmaster, Supreme Law Library
http://www.supremelaw.org/
All Rights Reserved without Prejudice



:?:
Thanks for the link.
but what or who was it intended for and why ???

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

never liked the idea of liquid & electronics so close. cyro cooling is cool but way to pricey, air it is for me (@ least for now)

Reply to cdonato

Quote :

Well The Peltier Was Simply To Allow A Cool OC Without Too Much Hassle As Long As The Temps Are Not Above Spec It Dont Matter Much To Me And If I Can Play A Game For 4 Hours Striaght With The Room Temperate Being Almost 100F And Not Have A Crash Im Doing Good And Trust Me Ive Tried



Not sure what kind of peltier setup you have, but I am going to combine it with water so I can run a 245w peltier on the CPU and 188w on the GPU. It won't heat up the room that much at all since the heat is transferred to the water block and then to the water. :D

Reply to SuperFly03

Quote :

Not sure what kind of peltier setup you have, but I am going to combine it with water so I can run a 245w peltier on the CPU and 188w on the GPU. It won't heat up the room that much at all since the heat is transferred to the water block and then to the water. :D



The heat has to go somewhere. It will heat the room unless you carry it elsewhere. And remember that Peltiers are notoriously inefficient. Depending on which unit you choose, a 100 watt TEC can put out 400 to 1000 watts. So if you have a 245 plus a 188, the total could be in the 2KW range or higher. That is enough heat to make a large bathroom nice and toasty on a winter morning. I once bought a ~200 watt TEC that was claimed to be 35% efficient. It measured about 15%.

Reply to clue69less

Interesting. They will be on 2 separate loops and my apt is a loft with 40 ft ceilings (idk, have I measure it? lol). We shall see what happens. Keep ya posted :D

Reply to SuperFly03

Quote :

Interesting. They will be on 2 separate loops and my apt is a loft with 40 ft ceilings (idk, have I measure it? lol). We shall see what happens. Keep ya posted :D



Yikes, that's huge! You will enjoy that heat source in the winter.

Reply to clue69less

Phase isnt extreme... you can run it 24/7!
I voted for water as its the overclockers favorite $/performance.

Reply to rwaritsdario

Alright, so far the only one to go extreme.... It's fun to be a little bit crazy.

Reply to SuperFly03

So far im in the watered TEC field, gimme a few months to settle down on it and ill start to make my own phase hehe

Reply to rwaritsdario

OH your own phase.... sounds like a cool project to me :D

Reply to SuperFly03
- 0 +

i like air but may be going to water as my cpu runs hotter
than i like.

not sure if water will cool it down enough for the price.

Reply to sirheck
- 0 +

Nah My System Dosent Heat The Room To 100F Although It Does Warm The Room Witch Is Good Considering That I Heat My House With The Oven And A Small Underpowered Space Heater

Reply to Hella-D
- 0 +

Quote :

Phase isnt extreme... you can run it 24/7!
I voted for water as its the overclockers favorite $/performance.



Close enough to extreme
its just on the edge and for more of a sustained higher oc.
anyway ...So far there is not enough votes to tally a fair percentage .
Thanks for your vote .

Reply to kwalker

Depends, I like air cooling but I can push my cpu with liquid and I can't afford extreme cooling.

Reply to chuckshissle
- 0 +

I know what you mean.
Air is just fine but liquid keeps the temps in line when you push your rig hard.
I Kind of like the extra security myself
extreme cooling is for fun any way :)

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

Just bumping
I would like to see a few more votes for a fair overall percentage

Reply to kwalker

Quote :

OH your own phase.... sounds like a cool project to me :D

Definetly, but I dont think ill be getting into it until after water isnt enough. And by the efficiency im going for with water it might take a while...[/b]

Reply to rwaritsdario
- 0 +

speaking of efficiency would you believe that by turning the potentiometer down 50% on my mcp655 swiftech pump my temps droped 2C.
I was dumping too much back into the system for the dual 120 rad.
seems that revised pump needs more radiator for that setting.

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

I use the Coolit Freezone cpu cooler(TEC). Overclocked q6700 system at 3.2 gives me 34-35C at idle 45-50C under heavy load.

Reply to pmt411

The D5 dumps about ~22W of heat into the water, and since youre using the Apogee I cant say im surprised...

Reply to rwaritsdario

Quote :

I use the Coolit Freezone cpu cooler(TEC). Overclocked q6700 system at 3.2 gives me 34-35C at idle 45-50C under heavy load.

So would a $150 water loop...

Reply to rwaritsdario

Liquid cooling using inert fluorocarbon would be my choice (money no object). You have the choice of using it in a closed loop system or immersing the whole thing in it (does make it a bit messy when you want to upgrade things though....)

Reply to Ford_Prefect
- 0 +

Quote :

The D5 dumps about ~22W of heat into the water, and since youre using the Apogee I cant say im surprised...



I'm more surprised that the apogee performs almost the same as my storm -1C. :?
That might change with a 3X120 rad and increased flow through the loop.
I’ve been hearing that this is the case and had to find out for myself.

Reply to kwalker

Quote :

I'm more surprised that the apogee performs almost the same as my storm -1C

Again the pumps faults. The Strom is the second most restrictive block in the market and the D5 is all about flow and no head.
If you still have the Strom laying around then sell the Apogee and the D5 and get a DDC-2 with a modded top from Petra or Alphacool if youre good at modding, it will definitely yield better results than the triple rad on its own.

Reply to rwaritsdario
- 0 +

Quote :

I know what you mean.
Air is just fine but liquid keeps the temps in line when you push your rig hard.
I Kind of like the extra security myself
extreme cooling is for fun any way :)



I've stuck to air so far, and even with a lowly 9500, my temps max about 50c and idle about 38c. Part of this I think is because the AMD chip doesn't overclock as high as an Intel to start with. Don't know for sure.

Reply to Sailer
- 0 +

[quote="rwaritsdario"]

Quote :

If you still have the Strom laying around then sell the Apogee and the D5 and get a DDC-2 with a modded top from Petra or Alphacool if youre good at modding, it will definitely yield better results than the triple rad on its own.



I'll try that on my next project and let you know the results.
I havent received everything yet so it will be a week or so.
Either way the 3X120 rad will be on the back of my P180 soon. :)
I'm kind of partial to my 655 pump
Since it replaced the older version of that unit I noticed quite a difference in quality.
The storm will go back on to compare results with the new rad and then find its way to the mystery rig I'm working on.

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

Very nice temps.
no need for water there :)

Reply to kwalker

What have you ordered?? I thought you had a D5, not a D4?

Reply to rwaritsdario

Has anyone tested the new water block from Dtek Fuzion? It is getting very good press on other forums. They are posting very low pressure drop with very high thermal performance, and they are claiming it is designed for dual and quad cores. If this is true it would be excellent for a two block system in the new AMD two chip dual core solution.

Can we get Toms to review against other blocks?

Reply to jerrydog
- 0 +

I'll let you know when everything is in place.
Time to have a little fun :wink:
I got my numbers crossed on the pump its mcp655 not a 650 :lol:
http://www.swiftnets.com/products/mcp655.asp
Looks like the d4 or the d5 from dd but swiftech branded.
I know you don’t think much of the unit but I think its one of the better pumps on the market.
I'll test your recommendation and give you a fair analysis.

Reply to kwalker
- 0 +

this one?
http://www.dtekcustoms.com/index.a [...] D=182&HS=1
maybe dario has heard more .
I havent seen much from this end on its real performance .
just a little chatter here and there

Reply to kwalker

The massive heat dump of the pump makes it unsuitable for some situations, as you have experienced when reducing the flow rate. So its a double sided blade.

Seems like D-Tek is aiming at multicore cooling with that design, but the water on the three corner without an outlet would have a hard time moving. Definitely wont be compared to the impregnent blocks in the market and for its high price it would have to outperform the pants of a Apogee or MP-01.

Reply to rwaritsdario
- 0 +

Quote :

The massive heat dump of the pump makes it unsuitable for some situations, as you have experienced when reducing the flow rate. So its a double sided blade.

Seems like D-Tek is aiming at multicore cooling with that design, but the water on the three corner without an outlet would have a hard time moving. Definitely wont be compared to the impregnent blocks in the market and for its high price it would have to outperform the pants of a Apogee or MP-01.



That’s something I didn’t take into consideration when I built the system.
I believe the mcp650 is more efficient than I gave it credit for and you may want to give it a better grade than you previously did for recommendations.
As for the D-Tec Time will tell but so far the apogee is better from what I have been seeing.
Not worth the purchase at this time.
Somewhere someone will claim it’s the best thing out there. :wink:

Reply to kwalker

I just read a review on Xtreme Systems forum on the Dtek Fuzion spanking both Apogee and Storm. I know this is not scientific yet, but they are all talking about the pin density and high flow capability....we should watch this block as it starts to get momentum .and additional testing..if you are looking for the best block I have no problem paying an extra $10 or $20, for the best!

Are any of you going to the shoot out next week in Vegas, that Swiftech is sponsering? Someone should bring the Fuzion block and we can see if it is worth it? :?: :?:

Reply to jerrydog
- 0 +

I've been following this also but like I said its too early to determine from a few reviews.
I do admit it looks promising and if it performs better than the storm over the next few months I definatly will have one. :)

Reply to kwalker

where does the Asetek Antarctica fit in with these?

Reply to ArchosSecutor
Previous
1 2
Tom's Guide > Forum > Overclocking > Cooler and Heatsinks > What is your preferred CPU cooling solution?
Go to:

There are 8 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Google ads