Tom's Guide > Forum > Motherboard & Memory > Memory > Laptop DDR/DDRII compatibility

Laptop DDR/DDRII compatibility

Forum Motherboard & Memory : Memory - Laptop DDR/DDRII compatibility

TomsGuide.com: Over 800,000 questions and answers to address all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Hello,

I have an Asus A3E 5015P laptop (specs). As you can see it runs on Intel's Centrino platform, on the Intel 915GM Express chipset (specs). As you might know, Intel says this chipset is compatible with up to 2GB of DDRII-533.

The laptop currently has 512 MB of DDR ram, which I would like to extend to 2GB of DDRII RAM.

I've opened my laptop already, and I see that DDR and DDRII SO-DIMMs seem to have the little crop in the middle of the rows of pins placed differently, making a DDR slot incompatible with a DDRII stick. But I could chop off the little plastic discriminator on the slot (I don't care about voiding the waranty, it's over already anyway...).

My question is the following: If I chop off the discriminator so that DDRII SO-DIMMs fit inside the slot, will I be able to plug DDRII memory in my laptop since the Intel chipset supporta both DDR and DDRII memory , or are there any other components that will cause problems (if so, I'd be curious to know which)?

Thanks for your help :)

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.
- 0 +

I don't see it working. If you chop off the notch and force it in, the some pins would end up where the notch used to be and there's no electrical contact there. Other than that there'd be different operating voltages between DDR and DDR2 modules, different pinouts, BIOS compatibility...

Reply to BigRat

u cant do that. dont be a fool.

DDR is compleatly different to DDR2. in the same way u cant expect to chop one of the 940 socket CPU's pins to make it a 939. what do u NEED ddr2 anyhow??

Reply to dougie_boy

I was just wondering :)

Seems that it's not possible then. And I'm not a fool unless I try that before asking, am I? ;)

Reply to LordOfThePigs

Quote :

I was just wondering :)

Seems that it's not possible then. And I'm not a fool unless I try that before asking, am I? ;)



You could still get a 1GB DDR2 SODIM and install that :) unless you can find a 2GB stick (I havent seen them but I havent searched that hard either lol)

Reply to JonathanDeane

As I said, it wouldn't fit into the slot (because of the plastic notch in it) and it seems it doesn't run the same voltage than regular DDR.

Just out of curiosity, here is an additional question: if it isn't the chipset that forces the use of DDR, what forces it then?

Reply to LordOfThePigs

Quote :

But I could chop off the little plastic discriminator on the slot (I don't care about voiding the waranty, it's over already anyway...).



Bad idea; don't do it. You'll probably end up frying your laptop. Just upgrade using DDR RAM; there's little or no performance benefit from DDR2.

Reply to angry_ducky

Quote :

Hello,

I have an Asus A3E 5015P laptop (specs). As you can see it runs on Intel's Centrino platform, on the Intel 915GM Express chipset (specs). As you might know, Intel says this chipset is compatible with up to 2GB of DDRII-533.

The laptop currently has 512 MB of DDR ram, which I would like to extend to 2GB of DDRII RAM.

I've opened my laptop already, and I see that DDR and DDRII SO-DIMMs seem to have the little crop in the middle of the rows of pins placed differently, making a DDR slot incompatible with a DDRII stick. But I could chop off the little plastic discriminator on the slot (I don't care about voiding the waranty, it's over already anyway...).

My question is the following: If I chop off the discriminator so that DDRII SO-DIMMs fit inside the slot, will I be able to plug DDRII memory in my laptop since the Intel chipset supporta both DDR and DDRII memory , or are there any other components that will cause problems (if so, I'd be curious to know which)?

Thanks for your help :)



Just get 2 good 1Gb DDR or you will fry you memory and/or memory socket and/or notebook chipset

DDR2 may even make your notebook SLOWER if you somehow manage
to make it work

Reply to vladtepes

Quote :

...
Just out of curiosity, here is an additional question: if it isn't the chipset that forces the use of DDR, what forces it then?


The design of the notebok. It would be silly (because of the extra cost) to design two duplicate memory systems, one for DDR and one for DDR2.

Reply to Mondoman
Tom's Guide > Forum > Motherboard & Memory > Memory > Laptop DDR/DDRII compatibility
Go to:

There are 8 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Google ads