Ads
Tom's Guide > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New Build > Which is the best way to build a computer?

Which is the best way to build a computer?

Forum Homebuilt Systems : New Build Which is the best way to build a computer?

Word :    Username :           
 

just a quick question, if i have 200 dollars and want to buy parts for a computer, would it be better to build a higher end CPU/MB, and use onboard graphics till you can afford somthing else, or buy a lowerend computer and have all CPU/GPU/MB?

for instance would it be better to build a
Athlon x4, with lower end MB with 4gb of ram, and a like HD 4780 (or somthing just thowing things out there)

or a

Phenom ii x4, with 8gb of ram, with mid range board, and currently using Onboard HD 3000 Graphics? (which is the way i went)

was i right to chose this path? or should i have just built quick ( i would also like to note i RARELY get money for things, so it might take me FOREVER to get the money :(.

so was i smart?

thnx for the feedback

Reply to TechnicEclipse
Register or log in to remove.

How can you have an AMD CPU, and Intel integrated graphics? I hope you didn't order incompatible parts.

Reply to LtDan

LtDan wrote :

How can you have an AMD CPU, and Intel integrated graphics? I hope you didn't order incompatible parts.

its AMD Radeon HD 3000 (im preaty sure) also i have it already built, it runs fine.

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

its AMD Radeon HD 3000 (im preaty sure) also i have it already built, it runs fine.


Ahh, I thought you meant the Intel HD 3000 integrated graphics that come with some i5s and i7s. Anyway, how does it fare in the games you play/things you do.

Reply to LtDan

I would get a good motherboard processor and the largest single stick of ram you can afford and use the onboard graphics. This means you'll only be able to play older games or less intensive ones. Then spend your money saved on buying new games on a good graphics card and the mate to that ram stick.

Reply to Maxor1

Trust me, you absolutely did the right thing. It's better to get the cpu and mobo you want then figure the rest out later than to cut back on them so you can just get an ok gpu. Having to replace the mobo later would be a pain IMO.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

well im running this so far, honestly i could have went better with the MB, but i saw good reviews on it. (plus i can upgrade to a FX 6100, because its a AM3+ Board)

AMD Phenom ii x4 960T (stock)
M5A78L-M LX
8gb DDR3 PNY Optima 1333mhz ram
AMD Radeon HD 3000 (integrated)(also threw in a XFX Radeon HD 4550 that i had laying around)
500gb WD HD
Logysis 480watt Psu (got a little money, so i have a Antec 430watt Earthwatts psu on shipment)
was this a decent setup, i mostly atm use if for Minecraft, TF2, and light video editing

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

well im running this so far, honestly i could have went better with the MB, but i saw good reviews on it. (plus i can upgrade to a FX 6100, because its a AM3+ Board)

AMD Phenom ii x4 960T (stock)
M5A78L-M LX
8gb DDR3 PNY Optima 1333mhz ram
AMD Radeon HD 3000 (integrated)(also threw in a XFX Radeon HD 4550 that i had laying around)
500gb WD HD
Logysis 480watt Psu (got a little money, so i have a Antec 430watt Earthwatts psu on shipment)
was this a decent setup, i mostly atm use if for Minecraft, TF2, and light video editing



Don't "upgrade" to bulldozer, it's more of a sidegrade and in most games gives worse performance than phenom ii, even on the best FX 8150 chip.
You may be able to unlock cores on that board since the 960T has two locked cores.
They also OC very well up to 4-4.2ghz.
The PSU could be better, the new one you are having shipped will be able to handle at max these gpu's 5770/6770/7770. They ask for 500watt minimum but that antec should do fine even though it's one of antec's lesser quality psu's.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

omega21xx wrote :

Don't "upgrade" to bulldozer, it's more of a sidegrade and in most games gives worse performance than phenom ii, even on the best FX 8150 chip.
You may be able to unlock cores on that board since the 960T has two locked cores.
They also OC very well up to 4-4.2ghz.
The PSU could be better, the new one you are having shipped will be able to handle at max these gpu's 5770/6770/7770. They ask for 500watt minimum but that antec should do fine even though it's one of antec's lesser quality psu's.


i have already unlocked them (not long) just to make sure that the CPU would unlock to all 6 cores, and well it did. ran it for about a hour, then locked the cores back up (mostly because this MB max TDP is 95watt, and well for some reason without the cores unlocked it runs at 107TDP?, and at 168TDP with it unlocked. but do you guys know why its running at 107TDP?

(just a side note) im using a Old AM2 Heatsink, which cools better then the one the 960T came with, which is really sad
i was hopeing to get one of the good stock heatsinks that had the Heatpipes, but i was mistaken. :(

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

i have already unlocked them (not long) just to make sure that the CPU would unlock to all 6 cores, and well it did. ran it for about a hour, then locked the cores back up (mostly because this MB max TDP is 95watt, and well for some reason without the cores unlocked it runs at 107TDP?, and at 168TDP with it unlocked. but do you guys know why its running at 107TDP?

(just a side note) im using a Old AM2 Heatsink, which cools better then the one the 960T came with, which is really sad
i was hopeing to get one of the good stock heatsinks that had the Heatpipes, but i was mistaken. :(



You could always buy a CM 212+ for like 20 bucks and be good for a long time. The TDP might be showing high depending on your voltage, what's it at? do you have it overclocked at all? CPUz showed my phenom ii at 125 when i had it unlocked, and when overclocked it didn't change even though i pumped alot of voltage through it. Might just be an error.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

Its not overlocked, but heres a CPU-Z pic, showing it running at 107TDP.
http://i934.photobucket.com/albums/ad186/jamminjr1993/Untitled.png

Reply to TechnicEclipse

It's just a calculation max/average when running under full load and such
http://www.techpowerup.com/forums/ [...] 56466.html
personally i wouldn't worry about it. I've run chips well over the TDP or watt the boards supported and have had them run for years until the point where i couldn't see keeping them any more :)

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by omega21xx on 02-16-2012 at 01:47:03 AM
------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

omega21xx wrote :

It's just a calculation round up when running under full load and such
http://www.techpowerup.com/forums/ [...] 56466.html
personally i wouldn't worry about it. I've run chips well over the TDP or watt the boards supported and have had them run for years until the point where i couldn't see keeping them any more :)

alright kewl, but... is it safe to run it with 6 cores unlocked? at 168TDP????

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

just a quick question, if i have 200 dollars and want to buy parts for a computer, would it be better to build a higher end CPU/MB, and use onboard graphics till you can afford somthing else, or buy a lowerend computer and have all CPU/GPU/MB?

for instance would it be better to build a
Athlon x4, with lower end MB with 4gb of ram, and a like HD 4780 (or somthing just thowing things out there)

or a

Phenom ii x4, with 8gb of ram, with mid range board, and currently using Onboard HD 3000 Graphics? (which is the way i went)

was i right to chose this path? or should i have just built quick ( i would also like to note i RARELY get money for things, so it might take me FOREVER to get the money :(.

so was i smart?

thnx for the feedback




Which do you prefer, AMD or Intel flatform? I don't know if the $200.00 is enough for MOBO and CPU.

Reply to aqe040466

aqe040466 wrote :

Which do you prefer, AMD or Intel flatform? I don't know if the $200.00 is enough for MOBO and CPU.



OP already has their rig, they were mainly asking if they made the right choice.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

TechnicEclipse wrote :

alright kewl, but... is it safe to run it with 6 cores unlocked? at 168TDP????



Once those cores are unlocked it will give you weird readings like that for TDP and core temps possibly too, it's fine.
If you plan to unlock and overclock make sure to test before an unlock what the core temps are and add an estimate of like 5C when unlocked to give you an estimate incase you can't read the temps when unlocked.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

omega21xx wrote :

Once those cores are unlocked it will give you weird readings like that for TDP and core temps possibly too, it's fine.
If you plan to unlock and overclock make sure to test before an unlock what the core temps are and add an estimate of like 5C when unlocked to give you an estimate incase you can't read the temps when unlocked.

well like i said i have already had them unlocked, and then locked them back up because of stock cooler, and the MAX TDP, when i unlocked them, it didnt really run that much hotter at about 40-45c, but that was just idle, when i get around 38-43c with them locked (i lucked out i guess and got a good chip.) (these Temps were also Recorded with PC Probe II)

Also when i unlocked them, CPU-Z recognized the CPU, and everything. so it was a very succesful Unlock.. just my worries are since my Board says it has a 95watt MAX, if it could harm my board running it at (i guess 125watt). or is it safe to run it still?

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

well like i said i have already had them unlocked, and then locked them back up because of stock cooler, and the MAX TDP, when i unlocked them, it didnt really run that much hotter at about 40-45c, but that was just idle, when i get around 38-43c with them locked (i lucked out i guess and got a good chip.) (these Temps were also Recorded with PC Probe II)

Also when i unlocked them, CPU-Z recognized the CPU, and everything. so it was a very succesful Unlock.. just my worries are since my Board says it has a 95watt MAX, if it could harm my board running it at (i guess 125watt). or is it safe to run it still?



I wouldn't worry about TDP too much, as voltage is the killer of boards 99% of the time. There shouldn't be any danger, but i'm not going to lie, doing anything but stock could cause problems or damage. As long as you don't push voltage too high and don't have temps reaching 60 or higher under full load you are fine and should have nothing to worry about.
When i unlocked my phenom ii 720, my temps were still readable as was the 960T i unlocked and overclocked for a friend.


Message edited by omega21xx on 02-16-2012 at 02:32:01 AM
------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

Here is what it says with the Cores Unlocked. and the Temperature

http://i934.photobucket.com/albums/ad186/jamminjr1993/AMD.png


good or bad??

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

Also its actually running at 41C average



Everything looks good, but you will want to stress the cpu with prime under small fft's to see if the cores are completely stable and see what your max temp is. If you reach into the 60C's you'll want to stop and get a better cooler or reseat the cooler you have as you should idle at 25-35C and 50-55 full load depending on the cooler and ambient temps.


Message edited by omega21xx on 02-16-2012 at 03:29:49 AM
------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

ok, how long should i run it? and im guessing i use 64bit, for 64bit os?

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

ok, how long should i run it? and im guessing i use 64bit, for 64bit os?



If you run the 64 bit windows yes, and you should see your max temps in about 15-30 mins and if the temps are in check and not over 60, you should stress for at least 6 hours, I always stress for 24 hours to insure my rig is 100% stable for 24/7 use. You get a general idea of how stable it is in about 30 mins to an hour. If it passes an hour it should be generally stable to play on, just make sure to do a full 12-24 hour test when you sleep and go to work the next day.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx

ya, it gets at 60c in like 4-10mins, soooo, should i reset my Heatsink?, or should i set it back to a quad, until i get a better cooler?

Reply to TechnicEclipse

TechnicEclipse wrote :

ya, it gets at 60c in like 4-10mins, soooo, should i reset my Heatsink?, or should i set it back to a quad, until i get a better cooler?



If you have some fresh cpu paste try reseating the heat sink. You can run at 60-65C for a long time, heat is a very slow cpu killer so if you watch a graph/chart rise on something like speedfan, if you don't see it start leveling out before it reaches 60C then you may need a new cooler.

------------------------------ Sentey Optimus Extreme | OCZ ZX 850 | ASRock 970 Extreme 4 ASRock z68 Extreme 3 Gen 3 | PII b20 x4 @3.5ghz i5 2500k @4.5ghz | A70 | 8GB G.Skill | Solid III | 6870 |
H61m | Celeron G530 | 4GB GSkill | Antec 520w | 6790 |
Reply to omega21xx
TomsGuide.com: Over 800,000 questions and answers to address all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Tom's Guide > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New Build > Which is the best way to build a computer?
Go to:

There are 44 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Tom's Guide around the World