Tom's Guide Forums
  Tom's Guide Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » 4850 versus 4870 in Crysis (other games too)
 




Word :   Username :  
 
 Page : 1 2
Previous
Author
 Thread : 4850 versus 4870 in Crysis (other games too)
 
More Information

Anybody with ATI Radeon video card experience, please help.

I've seen numerous benchmarks, and they vary significantly. I've seen tests with it at 35fps and at 45fps in Crysis at 1280x1024

Is the Radeon HD 4870 really worth the extra hundred?
http://www.legitreviews.com/images [...] crysis.jpg

In all other games I see that the 4870 does have significant FPS improvements, but in all other games the 4850 already runs at 60+ fps. I do want to keep my computer very fast for at least the next 10 years, so I do always have an option of just getting a second card for CrossFire.

With my motherboard, how does the CrossfireX work? Will I be able to eventually add two 4870s to my one 4850? The TigerDirect video review seems to indicate yes. If this is possible then I think the best choice is to go with a single 4850 for now, and later just add some better cards in as needed? Link to mobo: http://www.tigerdirect.com/applica [...] CatId=1572

My computer specs:
Core2Duo 3.0GHz
2GB DDR3 RAM
X48 Motherboard

Resolution: 1280 x 1024


Message edited by infinitywraith on 07-24-2008 at 04:01:00 AM
Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

More Information

omg of course 4870 is better

More Information

But is is worth the 100 bucks extra? Can someone seriously tell me if it's worh it.

More Information

No one out of the four hundred who viewed this thread will help???

cjl
Rocket Scientist
More Information

At 1280x1024, it won't be enough of a difference in all likelihood. At higher resolutions, the GDDR5 would help out quite a bit, but for you, I would just recommend the 4850.

More Information

I will help ;)

Well personally I would try to shoot for the 4870, if your funds allow you to.

But then again, your gaming at a lower res, so a 4850 would work really good also.

And to answer you question of Crossfire X, yes you can simply add another 4850 or 4870 later if you so choose. But at your resolution, Crossfire would be a waste.

Any more questions?


---------------
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L*Intel E2180 OC 3.00Ghz Lapped*PowerColor ATI 3850 256MB*Patriot 2x1GB DDR2 800*Cooler Master CM690*Western Digital 250 GB*Silverstone Strider 600 Watt Modular PSU*Samsung Lightscribe Drive*CoolerMaster Geminni II Lapped Mirror Finish
More Information

The reason I want crossfire is so that my computer is future-proof, because games will get better, and even at a lower resolution i'll still need to step up performance over time.

 

What settings do you think I could run Crysis on with a 4850? Most benchmarks say 35fps on max settings (high DX9). So i could just lower to 1024x728 and get good fPS?

 

I'd like to keep my native resolution (1280x1024) if possible. Postprocessing and shaders are something I want to keep nice and high, but shadows at low still look very nice.

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by infinitywraith on 07-22-2008 at 09:41:19 PM
cjl
Rocket Scientist
More Information

At 1280x1024, I would guess it would be pretty smooth on fully cranked settings, with no to low AA. Very high everything, 2xAA maybe? Of course, the 4xxx series are good with AA, so you might be able to do 4x. That's a fairly low resolution though, so I wouldn't be too surprised if you could pull it basically fully cranked on very high and maintain >25fps at almost all times.

 

Keep in mind that crysis has motion blur implemented quite well, which allows an occasional dip down to 20fps to still feel smooth.


Message edited by cjl on 07-22-2008 at 09:45:34 PM
More Information

"I do want to keep my computer very fast for at least the next 10 years"

- i think the 4870 will devour crysis7 and in 2018.


---------------
AMD Opteron 180 (s939) @2.7 | Biostar geforce 6100-m9 matx
OCZ gold 2x1gig DDR500 (@ DDR450)
evga 8800gt 512mb on 22" Gateway LCD
Enermax Liberty 400w psu | Silverstone sg01b matx case
More Information

Alright, so I think $100 is not worth the +3fps in Crysis?

In the future I think my motherboard will let me add more video cards and stuff so i'm keeping my comp open for upgrades.

More Information

I'm thinking about saving the $100 by getting an 4850 instead of 4870 for a better case, is it worth it?

More Information

MayDay94 wrote :

"I do want to keep my computer very fast for at least the next 10 years"

- i think the 4870 will devour crysis7 and in 2018.



I meant more like 5 years I guess, and I am going to upgrade in the next 5 years, just keep it upgradeable for at least 5 years.

More Information

If you're looking to keep it that long, I'd spend the extra dough on the 4870.

More Information

5 years is a bit much... if i was you id just wait for the 4870x2 than...
and i wudnt be surprised if you were insanely outdated by 2010-2011, ray tracing is just on the horizon

More Information

I cant believe no one has burst this guy's bubble. To upgrade a rig in 5 years and hope its lasts for 5 more, is impossible. If by upgrade you mean everything but the case(??) then i guess it will work.

You are going to come to the point of needing to upgrade everything (read new build) before ten years if you want to do more than type and surf the net.

Reformulated with 20 percent less ahole !
More Information
n°1846186
07-23-2008 at 05:04:59 AM
Hide