Which processor is better for laptop. - CPU & Components
  Tom's Guide Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » Which processor is better for laptop.
 




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Which processor is better for laptop.
 
More Information

Is the x9000 at 2.8 better for laptop or q9450 or something around that quad core area. The laptop will be majorly used for gaming.

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

More Information

Although some might disagree I think that for gaming the fastest dual core you can find would be your best option for a laptop. It will consume less power than a quad and there are only a couple games that utilize more than 2 cores anyway.


---------------
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z311/AUsch30/badge_wtp_02_3001.jpg
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
-Aristotle
More Information

btw, the q9450 is a desktop processor.

Some call me ... Tim?
More Information

Yeah, if you find a laptop that runs the Q9450, it probably isn't too portable :P

Don't Feed the Trolls!
More Information

ausch30 wrote :

Although some might disagree I think that for gaming the fastest dual core you can find would be your best option for a laptop. It will consume less power than a quad and there are only a couple games that utilize more than 2 cores anyway.




^Good thinking.



OP:
Are you going to be using this on battery a lot?


---------------
- TC
More Information

hello enmaalvb,

Notebooks currently do have what you seek. The link below to pioneercomputers(rebadged clevo i think?) is a good example, enjoy.

http://www.pioneercomputers.com.au [...] 15&id=2218

Boju

More Information

Thanks for the comments.

I'm not really looking for portability, but desktop replacement laptop. And yes I know its a desktop processor but there are current places where a could buy laptops with those.

And, which processor would anyone recommend me for a gaming laptop.

No i wont be using the battery alot.

Thanks in advance.

More Information

What kind of gaming are you talking about?

Gaming on laptops are getting better with dedicated GPU modules, but are still behind desktop gaming rigs in overall quality/performance.

I would look at what kind of gaming you intend you play, and see if a gaming laptop is the best for your needs. Check out reviews of Dell XPS or Alienware gaming lappies for a good comparasion.

Here is a link that might help you out a bit:
http://computershopper.com/top-pro [...] ng_laptops

But do some research on your own to find the laptop that fits your gaming needs.


---------------
1:http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/350600.png
2:http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/431686.png
More Information

I might buy the xps m1730 with 4 or 2 gb, sli 8700 and x9000....but I am a little undecided because I have found other places that offer me desktops processors and one 8800 gtx on the laptop...so I dont know if to stay with the trusty and nice looks of dell or go to, more affordable and desktop processor and one gtx of sager or ibuypower or cyberpowerpc, wich I still dont really trust.

More Information
cjl
Rocket Scientist
More Information

You'd get a LOT more performance in an XPS 1730 if you put your money towards SLI 8800M GTX's and dropped the CPU a bit (to something like a T9500 @ 2.6 or even lower)

 

The X9000 is great of course, and if you can afford it, the best would be an X9000 and a pair of 8800m GTX's, but if you have to sacrifice one, you'll lose far less performance by dropping the CPU than the GPU.


Message edited by cjl on 07-07-2008 at 07:39:34 AM
More Information

If you want unbeatable performance, go with Sager and don't look anywhere else.

An X9000 and two 8800m GTX's will rock your world.
The Sager NP9262 is for you.


You better have a big bank roll, though.


But, for gaming, a faster clocked dual core will always beat a lower clocked quad core.

At least, for now.

Other Forum Pr!ck
More Information

I would wait because a mobile version of the 4850 will surely arrive soon and that will blow away any NVidia offering for a laptop.

Also the recent stories about NVidia mobile graphics processors which are failing due to defects in the packaging for the die are a bit of a worry. Looks like that is mainly to do with 6 and 7 series Chips though.

cjl's advice is good ... he is a rocket scientist ... I am merely a professor.


---------------
Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds.

More Information

Well, this is just another reason asking before buying is always good. Thanks for the comments everyone, now I will plan better what to buy.

More Information

enmaalvb wrote :

Thanks for the comments.

I'm not really looking for portability, but desktop replacement laptop. And yes I know its a desktop processor but there are current places where a could buy laptops with those.

And, which processor would anyone recommend me for a gaming laptop.

No i wont be using the battery alot.

Thanks in advance.



Could you possibly use a small-form-factor desktop with a micro-ATX case instead? In my experience, laptops are pretty much only the right choice if they intend to carry it around and run it off the battery frequently. Otherwise, a smaller desktop system offers more power for less money and doesn't take up much more space than a huge laptop. Both big laptops and desktops pretty much stay parked on the desk and never leave, defeating the only advantage of a laptop in the first place. About the only type of situation where a huge notebook would make sense is if you have to move the unit frequently or put it away but do not have to carry the unit with you or get away from a power outlet. OTR trucking would be an example of that as they can pull the notebook out when they are not driving and plug it in but stow it away when they are driving, something that's harder to do with a desktop.

That's just something to think about. If you would perhaps give us your usage situation that might help as well.


---------------
UNIX is user-friendly- it's just picky who its friends are.

DRM is slowly killing personal computing, one Sony rootkit and TPM chip at a time.
More Information

Thanks for the idea but don't use the battery but would plug in anywhere I can and I don't mind the bulky 17 inch laptop. But thanks anyway.

I want a desktop replacement laptop, could be 15 or 17 inch, I want it to play wherever theres a plug, or when I need to go the another city or a vacation and being able to still play or browse internet from any wifi connection I find from a neighbour (Because here in Dominican Republic there arent lots of malls or locals with wifi)

Now that I have rethinked what I'll buy Im stuck between these three choices.
*the sager 17in with the e8400 dual core at 3.0 sli 8800gtx and 2gb ram 1680 res in about $3200

*the dell 17 in 1920 resolution t9300 2.5 gh sli 8800 gtx and 4gb ram and the very nice looks, $3400

*Alienware 15 in 1680 res and t9300 2.5 one 8800 gtx and 2gb ram around $2800

The Sager seems to output alot of power, same as the dell, but the dell has a very nice looks and I trust more dell, I dont really know sager, first time I hear about it (If anyone has bought please info me) and the alienware is just for a budget and as a emergency option.

I got the money and would really like to get a laptop and I am a expirienced desktop user so dont flame about the money issue please.

Thanks in advance would like to hear your opinions.