help on a decision please.. upgrade-replace - CPU & Components
  Tom's Guide Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » help on a decision please.. upgrade-replace
 




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : help on a decision please.. upgrade-replace
 
More Information

my system
XP Pro
AMD Athlon (2800+ CPU)
(Soltek MB)
2Gb DDR
500Gb IDE


just gave up..

I have put the memory into a friend's 'pass me down' Fujistu Scaleo 600 box ..it's a P4 HT system

2.4Ghz (I think)
ATI 9600
Gigabyte GA-8ISXT-FS
P4 Titan Motherboard
CPU �� Socket 478 for Intel® Micro FC-PGA2 Pentium® 4 processor
�� Support Intel® Pentium® 4 (Northwood, 0.13 m) processor
�� Support Intel® Pentium® 4 Processor with HT Technology
�� Intel Pentium®4 533/800MHz FSB
�� 2nd cache depends on CPU
Chipset �� Chipset Intel SPRINGDALE-PE HOST/AGP/Controller
�� ICH5 I/O Controller Hub
Memory �� 4 184-pin DDR DIMM sockets
�� Supports Dual Channel DDR333/400 DIMM
�� Supports up to 2GB DRAM (Max)
�� Supports only 2.5V DDR DIMM

It also has two SATA connectors


I don't have a lot of money and am thinking of initially getting just a Samsung 500Gb SATA as the old HD (IDE 160Gb is original)

Then you start thinking... will it take a beter CPU P4 3Ghz???(can you still get one?) Am I wasting money..

I really need someone elses view on this. I'd save a little and and get a bundle of MB/CPU/Memory..(still neeed a new HD anyway) but which bundle to get.. I presume entry level is not going ot be more powerful than the existing set-up or am I wrong and things have moved on a lot?

New is nice but cheap is too!

Help please!!!

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

More Information

If the P4 2.4 is a B model (533 bus) it's slower than your AXP2800+. If it's a C model (800 bus) it is about equal. You could probably OC his 2.4 to near 3.0 GHz.

Honestly, if you are gaming on this machine, any CPU you can put on either motherboard is quite low for the newest games. I think it's a waste to buy a CPU for either system. You would be much better off with a budget socket AM2 or 775 dual core setup instead. You will need a mobo, cpu, DDR2 memory, and a PCI-e video card. Also possibly a new power supply depending what your currently available ones are and the video card you choose.

Anyway, sorry to bare bad news. There are plenty of old games you should be able to play. But If you hope to play the latest and future games, you should aim toward a dual core system within budget. I was trying to play the new Race Driver: Grid demo yesterday on an A64 3700+ (once mighty single core) and it struggled under 30 fps most of the time on low details even at 640x480 resolution.


Edit: I assume you have an Athlon XP 2800+ and not an Athlon 64 2800+. The A64 2800+ is much faster than the Athlon XP or the P4. Still single core though.


Message edited by pauldh on 07-05-2008 at 02:27:23 PM

---------------
MSI P6N SLI Platinum, Q6600, 2GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer PC8000,
SLI BFG 8800GT OC 512MB, SB X-Fi Fatality, Antec TruePower Trio 550W, Windows XP pro
More Information

Paul... that was one quick reply!

I don't pay games`at all.. however i do do some video editing but ainly photo editing in PhotoShop. I use Nikon NX which is slowish.. so maybe a new system is a better way forward.

You say get a Dual Core CPU.. this will have to be Intel based as my Video editor sw prefers intel although it did run acceptably on my AMD system. What DualCore CPU do you think is equal in performance to what I have, so I can decide on what I can afford that will be better? Thanks!

More Information

Alot depends on your budget and whether you have to use your old memory. There are plenty older model cpus, but few motherboards left for socket 478 and 939 (using ddr). Check starmicro for any oem cpus you're interested in, and computer geeks for older motherboards. For a cheap upgrade using your old ddr, 3btech has an asrock dual vsta socket 775 board for $33 shipped with no accessories (you can get a backplate from asrock america for $5). For the cpu, the 2xxx series core2 duo is priced right, and I use the "pin mod" technique to overclock.


Message edited by o1die on 07-05-2008 at 02:50:29 PM
More Information

o1die...

this is great information!... do you see the 2xxx serias as comparable to the P4 24Ghz I have..respecting performance that is.

I just need something to compare to, before shopping.

I think video card and memory are on the cards as my AGP and DDR are too old tech for anything today.

So, it's a bundle, I think..

More Information

advice again please... this would appear to provide a 'slight increase in power (presume the AMD 64 is better) and have the SATA HD connectors I would prefer.. and use my 2Gb of DDR memory..

is the board any good enough though..chipset won't be Intel obviously.

I'm trying to find the Elite Group website a we speak..

Many thanks for all your help and suggestions.

More Information

give us a rough amount you are willing to spend and we can put together some stuff for you as suggestions

More Information

apologies.. I meant to put a link in my post..this was it:

http://www.misco.co.uk/application [...] Sku=138120

It's only £42.00 inc 64 3000+ processor.
Not sure if my video card, an ATI 9600 256 AGP, is AGP Pro fit for this MB though?

however if i had to put a limit on spend at present it would be £150.00 UK pounds..but that would mean a PCI express Video card I presume?

again, i thank everyone for their information


  Tom's Guide Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » help on a decision please.. upgrade-replace

Go to:
 

Google ads