Tom's Guide Forums »
Homebuilt Systems
»
New System Build »
Build AMD/ATI OR Intel/nVIDIA thats the question
| Bottom | |
|---|---|
| Author |
Thread : Build AMD/ATI OR Intel/nVIDIA thats the question
|
|
More Information
|
I had tested many hardwares during all this years from K6 till phenom and MMx 233 till Q6600.From S3 savage8 till 3870 X2.Let me talk about my experience: Old days: 1. K8 was faster than any P4 per it's price all the time.(maybe clock is not a good factor because it was a big clock gap between K8 and P4) 2.Ati 9xxx were faster than Fx5xxx(and most of 6xxx) from nVidia (not per price sometimes) 3.Am2 was a big failure from AMD because: DDR performance was twice faster than DDR2 .(specialy in dual mode) today : 4.HD 3870 seems to perform slower than 8800gt BUT: a.Picture quality (3d maps) are in better quality if you take picture from games?! 5.All the time M/Bs detected AMDs new CPUs at least in the name of "Unknown AMD " But today phenom does not boot with 98% of AM2 boards.... this is a new big mistake from AMD pushing AM2 users to Intel core2.
8.X2 6400+ is a CPU you can buy it at 180$ (boxed with heat-pipe fan)... It is a power hungry choice but it's price make it a good choice.Which is faster than 6750 with the same price.this CPU has a good performance in Memory.(around 10000MB p/s) ,But it's technology is old.Why Amd cannot build a low power cpu at this performance?This could be another mistake! 9.Clock is not a problem.I think power waste is the problem.Phenom is not a good per watt CPU ,if it was.... there is no problem with it's lower clock/performance ratio and While I am waiting for a better low-power and higher clocked phenom. So AMD or Intel? Nvidia or ATI? thats the question...
Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by massih on 05-06-2008 at 12:41:10 AM |
|
Related Pr oduct
|
Register or
log in to remove.
|
|
Sniper
More Information
|
|
|
Sniper
More Information
|
--------------- E2180 @3.2Ghz + P35DS3L +8400GS (700/475 OC) ![]() |
|
Sniper
More Information
|
I have a bad feeling this is going to go in to flames.
--------------- E2180 @3.2Ghz + P35DS3L +8400GS (700/475 OC) ![]() |
|
More Information
|
What is the purpose of this Thread?
Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by Rwayne on 03-12-2008 at 02:11:00 AM |
|
More Information
|
OP, Why Don't you Post under your REAL ID?
--------------- If its good in theory but not in practice, its not good theory. |
|
More Information
|
--------------- macgirlfriend: "Hey I don't get you people, the people on insanely mac were so much nicer" |
|
Sniper
More Information
|
^Agreed. And remember:
--------------- E2180 @3.2Ghz + P35DS3L +8400GS (700/475 OC) ![]() |
|
More Information
|
Sounds to me you like the high end ATI GPU's but hate the AMD mobo's and phenom. You also dont want the quads from Intel as you are afraid of new CPU's coming crushing any high priced CPU now. I would suggest you buy a cheap dual core maybe the E2160, E2180, or X2 5000BE with an HD 3850 or HD 3870.
|
|
Gosh, i love ATI
More Information
|
what is the point of that long and disturbing wall of text? |
|
More Information
|
X48 Board intel and ati. |
|
More Information
|
If you're going to do show a lame picture about a troll, at least make it look like a lame troll picture and take it from WoW |
|
More Information
|
2 cents...
Message edited by choirbass on 03-12-2008 at 04:52:39 AM --------------- Folding@Home |
|
More Information
|
--------------- Give a man a fish, and you'll have fed him for a day. Give a fish a man, and he'll eat for weeks. |
|
More Information
|
--------------- If its good in theory but not in practice, its not good theory. |
|
Only the paranoid survive.
More Information
|
@massih Do you have any supporting article or anything for your statement & judgement? |
|
More Information
|
antas ,Tomshardware guide has details most of my experiences in more detail.I tested many systems but not as much as toms.if you wana try go to charts http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/foru [...] ge-quality and I am 100% sure about 3870 x2 quality is much better.because I have a about low performance of ddr2/ddr3 systems sisoft sandra is a good reference.but be carefull sisoft sandra is not a good reference for CPU! that is not real world.
Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by massih on 03-12-2008 at 10:43:07 PM |
|
More Information
|
somebody find a job for : Shadow7037 93 you have full time here I think!
Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by massih on 03-12-2008 at 12:46:07 PM |
|
More Information
|


