Tom's Guide Forums »
Homebuilt Systems
»
New System Build »
Please help out with a Long Overdue gaming PC upgrade: Pentium 3 to C2
| Bottom | |
|---|---|
| Author |
Thread : Please help out with a Long Overdue gaming PC upgrade: Pentium 3 to C2
|
|
More Information
|
Update Oct. 13: I've updated my current choices a bit based on the feedback I've received in the last 2 days - thanks a lot guys! Also, about OCing: I do want to have at least 3.0 GHz, even on the Q6600, but I doubt I'll go crazy with like 3.8+ GHz overclocks.
Message edited by shurcooL on 10-15-2007 at 05:52:02 AM |
|
Related Pr oduct
|
Register or
log in to remove.
|
|
More Information
|
Hide
I forgot to mention, I'll probably be buying all the parts at a local PC shop in my city - I really don't wanna deal with eBay or ordering stuff only from the US and such... I'll just pay a bit more but won't have to deal with the shipping wait and all the hassles.
|
|
More Information
|
About the case, make sure the 8800GTX will fit in it cause its longer than normal ATX size motherboard, but any case that can fit an EATX mobo will be big enough
|
|
More Information
|
Hide
I'll keep that in mind about the case. I've heard the 8800GTX is unbelievably long.
|
|
More Information
|
The dell 27" is just stretched more, as in the same # of pixels, but one is larger and the other is not. if you opt for the larger display just for the size, then I would recomend a 32" HDTV 1080P if you get a good one they have a DVI port/HDMI port and the resolution is 1920x1080.
|
|
More Information
|
A good case choice in your price range: Cooler Master RC 690 $81CAD plus rebate Cooler Master RC 690 review One good HSF in your price range is the Cooler Master GeminII $38 plus rebate CM GeminII review 19x12 vs 16x10 monitors are both good choices for wide screen gaming but 16x10 is budget friendly.
|
|
More Information
|
Good job, shurcool! You have researched well, and presented it nicely. I can agree with all of your choices. As to some of the issues you raised:
--------------- E8400-stock, GA-P35-DS3R(rev2.1), Corsair 4x2gb 6400C5, EVGA 8800GTS-512-G92, Vista home premium-64-bit, WD velociraptor-300gb, PC P&C silencer-610, Antec SOLO, 2 x Samsung 275T, Samsung-203b-dvd |
|
More Information
|
Hide
Thanks so much, you guys have been very helpful!
Message edited by shurcooL on 10-13-2007 at 11:16:08 PM |
|
More Information
|
C2Q/C2D @ 3.0Ghz performance should be close enough that you won't notice any differences in single threaded games. A few games are starting to show that 4 cores can make a difference like Supreme Commander and Lost Planet.
|
|
More Information
|
There are a few things wrong with this system....Here are my thoughts...Cosidering you have a 2-3k dollar budget you have a lot of wiggle room to get quality parts...
Are you planning to overclock?...If so it makes no sense to get a dual core. I only recommend dual cores to people who don't plan to overclock as they would benefit form the higher clock speed then more cores. Considering how old your current rig is...I bet this system is to last just as long. If that's the case grab a quad core as it is the future which can't be denied. Crysis which is also a FPS which you like is multithreaded, so it will benefit from quad cores. The choice is yours though. If you aren't planning to or are afraid of overclocking...Just grab a dual core. If you plan to OC at all get a quad...Also keep in mind the affordable quad core penryn solutions come out in january 2008. You might want to just nab something decent until that time...Or just go ahead and nab something now to last you for a few years. I can't stress this enough though. If you plan to Oc at all don't get a dual...seems like you want this rig to last you for years..Which makes it a unworthy purchase.
This is the tough segment. I'm planning to build myself a new rig as well. I just can't justify spending 500 on a year old card. Choice is yours if you want to do this. But it's good to see you picked out a EVGA card..Although I doubt the step up would last until the 9800 is released...Unless nvidia plans to have a surprise release in november. Overall though a great card. You might want to look into getting a XFX model instead. IMO the EVGA program is overrated. Yea you have 3 months to step up...yea you have a limited life time warranty. But it doesn't cover over clocking or anything. With XFX's warranty you get a double lifetime warranty. You can even sell the card with the lifetime warranty to a new buyer. They just have to register the product...XFX also has a no hassle overclock warranty as well. No matter what you do to it you're still covered. It makes it a better buy in my eyes. Let's say the 9800 GTX comes out sometime q1/q2...You can just take the XFX model and pop it up on ebay for 50-150 below the current retail cost...Place a couple hundred or so ontop of it and purchase the new high end. IMO it's a much better buy. Choice is yours though. You might also want to wait until november to see what nvidia rolls out as well as ATI....
This is the segment that requires the most research. There is no perfect LCD monitor. They all have strengths and weaknesses..It's all about choosing a monitor that has the strengths you desire. PVA/MVA are likely to have the most ghosting...Which the dells 24" & 27" happen to use. If you want some really detailed consumer based reviews check out http://www.hardforum.com/forumdisplay.php?f=78 Browse through the first 5 or so pages and you can get a LOT of detail on every panel. Some threads dedicated to certain models that range up to 100 + pages. A very active community that helps you really get down to the problems of each monitor...as they are reviewed and owned by people that have them. There are also a few users on their who know quite a large amount of information regarding TFT Technology....You would really benefit from looking into this. Also make sure you check out the top sticky thread which states "TFT Technology Breakdown" to understand the differences of the panel types. IMO LCD technology has way too many faults...I'm personally going to nab a high end Sony FW900 24" widescreen CRT till FED rolls out in 2009/2010.
You can get away with a reasonable budget for the mobo. For a great price/performance ratio look into the Gigabyte p35-DS3R. Or if you want you can grab the Asus p5k also...They are both in the same category in terms of price performance. But the gigabyte is a great overclocker for it's price. If you want..Even though they are pricey..You can look around for a X38 board. They are just about being released and are in their infant stages. But as newer bios releases come out they should push past the p35 in terms of performance...ATM they are pretty much quite similar...Although the x38 supports PCI-E 2.0....This will give you more upgrading headroom in the future without having to nab a new motherboard to support newer cards down the road. Although most people would just end up getting a new board...It's good to know when PCI-E 2.0 cards really start taking over the market that you can just swap your card for a replacement.
Are you planning to overclock?..If so stay away from corsair. A LARGE portion of their chips are switching over to promo ic's....A lot of corsair customers are extremely unhappy with the new change. If you don't plan to OC they'll do you fine. If you plan to OC make sure you get D9 micron modules. They are wonderful overclockers that have lots of headroom..As well as being able to handle higher voltages more efficiently. Unlike the promo chips...You'll be able to overclock farther...and longer without degrading the life of your chips quickly. Micron chips are the most desired since they are wonderful overclockers... Here are some 800 mhz rated crucial modules that run Micron D9GMH chips.... http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820146565 Here's a 1066 version if you really want to overclock as far as possible based on your cpu... http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820148069 There is one better candidate then the D9GMH from micron...It's the Micron D9GKX....They tend to overclock farther and are better with tighter timings...Although the company that put these ram modules together isn't very well known...Here's one from newegg....But I've heard great things from the D9GKX series.. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820150054
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820146691 Choice is yours on which ram you want. Stay away from corsair atm...They have quite a few of their customers angry considering their cheaper quality IC's now...If you want an even more extensive list on Micron chips. Just go to google and type in Micron D9GMH List of Micron D9GKX list...Browse through the results and see which modules have them. To double check the accuracy..Take the model number of the modules they spoke of and give it a google search with the D9 chips they stated were in use. I would help you out with this but going through ram modules is the most time consuming part imo...when it comes to grabbing the IC's you prefer and all the choices you have...
your choices are fine. for high budget builds I always recommend a raptor for heavy gaming and video/photo/3d work...WD drives are grand too. Personally I prefer seagate...I've used MANY drives from all sorts of manufacturers...IBM, WD, Maxtor, Seagate....and the list goes on. but overall WD and Seagate have given me the best results. Half of my WD drives have died so far though..While all of my seagate drives are still alive and kicking. Also make sure you look at the warranties as well...The Raptor has a 5 years warranty..But most of the Caviar drives have a 3 years warranty except for a few models...All the seagates I've looked at have a 5 year warranty..
One thing you don't want to go cheap on is a PSU...If it goes out it can take your entire rig with it. Not a great investment...Overall though your choice wasn't bad at all..The GameXStream, EvoStream, and ProXStream are all tier 2 PSU's....Great choices..even though the StealthXStream isn't on the list at all...Should be a tier 2 as all of them seem to be from the same product line. You might want to get a better unit though...Look into this one... http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] ne%2bDA650 It's a tier 1 powersupply for a fantastic price. Most people nab the Corsair HX620 which is a great powersupply. Costs the same on newegg as the Silverstone 650DA...They have the same amperage levels. But the Silverstone is tier 1 which offers better reliability...It also comes with a 8 pin PCI-E connector for newer graphics cards. While the HX620 doesn't. You can get the 8 pin connector from corsair but you have to call them and ask for it...As well as pay for shipping for the modular cable. Both these psu's are modular. I would recommend trying to spend the extra 60 to get a tier 1 if possible...Although a tier 2 will be fine as well..Here's a list of tiered psu's...Considering your budget...Try to get a tier 2 or tier 1..Stay away from anything else... http://forums.overclockersclub.com [...] opic=69770
This is personal preference really...But make sure you try to nab something with good airflow...Although you can get some cheap cases for 100 or less...I'd recommend going with what others have suggested...A Antec P180/182 or 900 model is great for the money. Also look into the Thermaltake Armor series...Here are 3 variations of the armor series.. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811133032 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811133021 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811133154 ...Any of these or the others mentioned should do fine. If you plan to OC you want a good case with airflow. Heck..Even if you don't OC...considering your budget...get a good case that can keep everything nice and cool.
choose whatever you wish.all pretty much the same...I'd recommend getting SATA versions compared to IDE...As it will be better for airflow..
Choice is yours..I always make sure to nab quality cooling. If you aren't planning to OC the stock cooler will be fine. If you do plan to oc look around for an alternative. Use the image in the previous posts to make your choice. If you are planning to OC HEAVILY...I'd recommend either a tuniq tower...Or Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme, Or even the Thermalright Ultima 90 (Not the ultra 90)....The tuniq tower has a 120 mm fan inserted in the middle of the heatsink. While the ultra and ultima don't come with a fan. But they come with 120 mm brackets to add your own. This is where it's a great cooler. Just slap on a high cfm fan and your good to go. Personally I like a mixture of low noise and high cfm..So the Scythe S-flex Sff21f fits my tastes... http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6835185006 Don't worry about the price on newegg..you can get it much cheaper from other places...around 10-14 dollars. Choice is yours on what you want for cooling. The thermalright ultra 120 cost with the fan is a bit high..almost 80-90....you also have to slap on some Arctic Silver 5 for the best cooling possible. The tuniq tower has a more affordable solution but still pricey. Or you can just nab some of the other coolors. Once again..I only recommend these if you're oc'ing...if not then don't worry about it..Just use the stock heatsink or a arctic freezer 7 pro which is a great VALUE heatsink..around 20 bucks and does a better job then the stock. Well..that's pretty much it..If you have any questions just post..I'll respond when I can...Regarding store purchases. It's almost impossible to grab most the parts mentioned at retail stores. I've helped a few people who live in canada as well as europe/london...Almost every time they head over to a local store..They end up with a cheaper quality parts which really isn't up to snuff...meanwhile online solutions can get you every quality part you desire...This is one reason why I ALWAYS purchase computer hardware online..In almost all cases they are cheaper..so it equals out with shipping..Plus they head directly to me so I don't have to hunt them down. Returning defective products are the only downside...RMA'ing as well..But I've only had this happen once..Overall I think online purchasing is the best way to make sure you get the best quality parts for your money... BTW...Almost forgot..If you do plan to go quadcore and plan to OC...Try to nab a G0 Stepping model...I was going to recommend buying it from clubit.com ....but considering you're from canada I don't know if that would help. although the b3 stepping is still fine..the G0 is just cooler and has a higher temperature threshold...So they are great overclockers. Message edited by Kamrooz on 10-14-2007 at 02:28:18 AM |
|
More Information
|
Maybe the better question would be:
|
|
More Information
|
Hide
First of all, Kamrooz and WR2 - ty so much for such detailed help! =D
|
|
More Information
|


shurcool@hotmail.com 
