Why AMD had to buy ATI - CPU & Components
  Tom's Guide Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » Why AMD had to buy ATI
 




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Why AMD had to buy ATI
 
More Information

http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=37548


Because INTEL is going balls out with its intergrated GPU/CPU core....

Nvidia better look to change its business model

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

More Information

While I agree that a Fusion-esque APU is the future, discrete graphics cards won't be disappearing for a long time, as long as there are gamers that will buy them and they perform better than whatever is integrated. I think the Inquirer is exaggerating things a bit here.

nVidia is far from dead.

More Information

Quote :

While I agree that a Fusion-esque APU is the future, discrete graphics cards won't be disappearing for a long time, as long as there are gamers that will buy them and they perform better than whatever is integrated. I think the Inquirer is exaggerating things a bit here.

nVidia is far from dead.



you are assuming that fusion-type performance will not be able to compete with discrete at some point

More Information

Quote :

http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=37548


Because INTEL is going balls out with its intergrated GPU/CPU core....

Nvidia better look to change its business model



Hopefully it's better then the ast GPU Intel released. I mean they're talking about 16x faster than G80.

I'd ike o see how they manage it considerng the power reqs for G80/R600.

They are saying it will be x86 "mini-CPUs" like Cell or XBox360 CPU. It will be interesing to see, but hopefully no one really thinks nVidia can be beat.
R700 is already set to be modular and nVidia will undoubtedly want to really out-distance Intel after this announcement. And considerng the time between G70 and G80, Intel will NEVER catch up.

if anything it'll be like ATi where ntel releases a chip that's faster than nVidia current and nVidia releases a new monster that lows the competitin away.

nVidia has the most experience in 3D GPUs and Intel - no matter the money they throw at it - will not be able to make up the 10+ year headstart.

More Information

Unless they steal/hire Nvidia's employees :wink:

More Information

sure it sounds like a monster, but how well will it really push the pixels? who knows. it sounds like it will be one helluva server add on type chip not a gpu.

More Information

Discrete graphics have a long life ahead of them. I don't see discrete graphics going away because there is a foreseeable demand for the sheer power they put out as long as games and video gets more realistic/advanced. When we reach the point where that isn't possible and all that is left it to shrink stuff then, yes maybe Nvidia will be "in trouble" but I doubt they are that stupid. If anything, I bet nvidia helps lead us into the next revoltuion with VR or something like that.

Let's not get all bent out of shape at something that is 7+ years off in the future. 8O

More Information

Quote :

Discrete graphics have a long life ahead of them. I don't see discrete graphics going away because there is a foreseeable demand for the sheer power they put out as long as games and video gets more realistic/advanced. When we reach the point where that isn't possible and all that is left it to shrink stuff then, yes maybe Nvidia will be "in trouble" but I doubt they are that stupid. If anything, I bet nvidia helps lead us into the next revoltuion with VR or something like that.

Let's not get all bent out of shape at something that is 7+ years off in the future. 8O



but hence the thread title... AMD did what it had to do early....to be viable in 7 years...

wr
More Information

Unless there is a paradigm shift in graphics processing that I'm completely missing, I don't see how from a raw performance perspective a GPU could compete while integrated into a CPU. You'd run into heat issues just like cramming two dual-cores onto one die and then trying to run at previous frequencies (almost twice the heat in the same socket space). I don't see this changing with a more advanced litho node as long as the discrete card doesn't seriously trail the CPU process.

However, I do see clearly some power efficiency, component-retasking, and manufacturing advantages from an integrated GPU that would make it suitable for budget and low-power systems.

More Information

Quote :

Unless they steal/hire Nvidia's employees :wink:



Employees by themselves won't do it and if they(employees) steal manuf or trade secrets, Intel can be prosecuted.

They will never REALLY catch nVidia or even ATi.

More Information
More Information

Quote :

interesting article from august

http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=33812



Upon reading this I have concluded that it is not outside the realm of possiblility for intel to become a powerhouse in graphics. With the expertise of 3D Labs engineers and intels very deep R&D pockets, it would be very foolhardy to become complacent about intel becoming a player in the GPU market. This event was probably what triggered the eventual merger of AMD/ATI.

I wonder how much it cost intel to obtain this level of graphics expertise? I don't know, but I bet it was alot less than 5 billion dollars.

More Information

Quote :

interesting article from august

http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=33812



Upon reading this I have concluded that it is not outside the realm of possiblility for intel to become a powerhouse in graphics. With the expertise of 3D Labs engineers and intels very deep R&D pockets, it would be very foolhardy to become complacent about intel becoming a player in the GPU market. This event was probably what triggered the eventual merger of AMD/ATI.

I wonder how much it cost intel to obtain this level of graphics expertise? I don't know, but I bet it was alot less than 5 billion dollars.


Perhaps, but they also don't get a suite of GPUs for every segment. Intel better look out because nVidia is WAAAAAAYYYYYY ahead. nVidia is already working on a GPGPU. Yes, Intel has deep pockets but 3D Labs is known for OpenGL pro cards. I doubt they will catch nVidia.

More Information

its still amazing to me AMD bought ATi

More Information

so it doesn't trouble you to reference inquirer stories anymore, interesting change of heart you've had.

More Information

don´t panic ...if you think that the inquirer is incorrect


http://www.xbitlabs.com/news/video [...] 30933.html

More Information