Roundup: Three External Burners : Samsung SE-S084B

By Digital Versus, published on August 6, 2009
Powered by Digital Versus

4. Samsung SE-S084B

Burning

For the burning tests, we always use the same free software - CDBurnerXP Pro.

Samsung beat out the competition in all other departments, but when burning a 3 GB ISO file the Buffalo Technology drive was faster. The Samsung took 11 minutes to complete the task compared to only 9 minutes for the Buffalo.

Samsung says that their new SE-S084B slim external DVD burner, available in six colors (black, white, gray, blue, rose, and red) can go with you everywhere. And, like its competitors, this DVD burner requires no special configuration and no AC adaptor thanks to its Plug & Play technology and the fact that it gets its power through its USB cable.

Samsung ahead on data rates

Buffalo Tech.
DVSM-PN58U2

LG GSA-E50L


Samsung SE-S084B


Time taken to create an ISO image of our test DVD (s)

Our data-rate tests showed a slight advantage for the Samsung, but the difference was negligible. On the ISO image ripping test, the Samsung SE-084B was neck-and-neck with the LG GSA-E50. The task took 14 minutes on our Hercules netbook.


The lowest power consumption

Buffalo Tech.
DVSM-PN58U2

LG GSA-E50L


Samsung SE-S084B


Energy consumption (Wh)

The Samsung is the most energy-efficient external DVD burner we've tested so far. Multiplying its power consumption under operation by the average time taken to create an ISO image of our test DVD and to burn the image works out to 2.7 Wh. That puts it ahead of the LG and the Buffalo by 0.2 Wh.

Fastest, but also quietest

Buffalo Tech.
DVSM-PN58U2

LG GSA-E50L


Samsung SE-S084B


Noise level during operation (dB)

Not only is the Samsung the fastest burner, it's also the quietest, at 45.5 dB while operating compared to 47.7 and 49 dB, respectively, for the Buffalo and LG units. But while that's the best result we've logged to date, it's still a stretch to call the burner "quiet".


Samsung SE-S084B
ProsCons
  • Lowest energy consumption
  • Least noisy: 45.5 dB
  • Rates: ISO image rip

The Samsung SE-S084B is the best-performing external DVD burner we've tested to date. And it's also the quietest. And to put the icing on the cake, it comes in a rainbow of colors.

Comments | Print | Send to a friend

Sponsored links

Comments

socrates047 08/06/2009 8:54 PM
Hide
-0+

quick question..
these plug and play types can be used to install an OS, right?

erichlund 08/06/2009 10:31 PM
Hide
--1+

Confused? The article says the Buffalo was the fastest, but it also says the Samsung was fastest, so gave the nod to the Samsung because it was also quiet and power efficient. The evidence seems to indicate the Buffalo was actually the fastest, so I guess it depends on what the individual user is looking for, speed or quiet.

Seems like either too much or too little caffeine here.

quantumrand 08/07/2009 3:15 AM
Hide
--1+

Socrates047 :
quick question..these plug and play types can be used to install an OS, right?



That depends on your system. If your BIOS support "booting from USB," then yes, you can install your OS from these drives. Dont worry. Just about any computer newer than 2005 will have this ability.

Anonymous 08/08/2009 4:38 PM
Hide
-0+

I have the Samsung SE-S084B. It boots my Asus 1000He Eee-PC no problem at all. It works good with 1 usb cable.

Anonymous 08/10/2009 1:05 AM
Hide
-0+

"In other words, these roundups are a work in progress."

=

In other words, Digital Verses likes to kiss TG rear, so TG publish their stuff even if it's half-baked.

Sponsored links