Apple's Legal Goliath Struck Down by Spanish Tablet Maker
A tiny Spanish tablet developer has accomplished what Samsung could not.
Perhaps it's opposite day in the international court system, but it turns out that Apple isn't invulnerable in courts of law after all. After a nearly unbroken string of humiliating legal victories over Samsung, it seems Apple has finally met its courthouse match: a tiny Spanish tablet maker called Nuevas Tecnologias. A Spanish Judge in the city of Quart de Poblet has now overturned a previous decision granting an injunction against Nuevas Tecnologias have have dismissed commercial and criminal charges brought against them by apple.
At issue is Nuevas Tecnologias' NK-T slate, accused by Apple of (of course) infringing on the iPad design. Apple first filed their claim in 2010, and were quickly granted a preliminary injunction that restricted sales of NK-T to only 200 units. At the time Apple received their preliminary ruling, Spanish customs agents seized China-bound shipments of Nuevas Tecnologias tablets. This led to N.T. being briefly listed on an EU list of known technology pirates, at which point Apple outrageously filed additional criminal charges. Now that the case has been thrown out, Nuevas Tecnologias is suing to recoup court costs and better still, pursuing anti-trust charges for what they allege - quite rightly from appearances - is a pattern of anticompetitive behavior by Apple.
Nuevas Tecnologias have posted a statement (in Castilian Spanish) posted to the company blog saying in part that "We are a small company like many others. In these times of crisis we [are] trying to get ahead, and it seems grossly unfair that a company the caliber of Apple has to use its dominant influence."
- Amazon Prime Now Offers Book-lending for Kindle
- GameStop's Android Tablets Arrive in Stores
- Study: Chinese Cyber-Threat is 'Rudimentary'
- Kickstarter Project Hopes to Build a New Civilization
- Online Communities Lead to Risky Financial Decisions
- VIDEO: The First Grand Theft Auto V Trailer
- Verizon to Launch Galaxy Nexus Black Friday Weekend?
- Google Rolls Out New Gmail to All Users
- YouTube, Lenovo Will Put Student Experiments in Space
- A $200 Tablet You Could Actually Consider Buying
- Motorola Confirms Two New Xoom Tablets
- HTC's Dr. Dre-Branded Rezound Will Cost You $299
- Ford Sets Focus Electric Car Price Below Cost
- Study: Playing Video Games Promotes Creativity
- US Says China is World's Biggest Cyber-Theft Perpetrator
- Sprint Lawsuit Against AT&T/T-Mobile Merger Moves Forward
- Unbelievable: 3.5 Million People Still Pay For AOL Dial-up
- Apple's Siri Suffers Extended Service Outage
- Climate Scientists Find Huge Increase in CO2 Emissions
This makes me happy. Love the moneybags pic too.
Apple beaten? And by a little guy at that! Never thought I'd see the day.
So awesome, more judges out there need to rule like that spanish judge!
This just made my day!
I remember Apple's famous "Big Brother" commercial from way back when. They wanted to make a statement against IBM being the big, bully corporation trying to restrict peoples choices (and thoughts). How ironic that Apple has become they very thing that Steve Jobs claimed he so despised.
its a great day when apple gets its shit flung back to them
If you think unemployment in the US is bad, Spain is 10 times worse.... And I would think that Apple would be "cool" and layoff the patent infringements for just "breathing" in these countries.....
Judge: Manzana me da diarrea.
Oh, so it should be allowed to steal, because it is a small company...like that makes it any better.
Theft is theft, period.
This just made my day!
Must have a pretty depressing life.
It will be a very cold day in Hell when there is any kind of Apple product in my company !
Oh, so it should be allowed to steal, because it is a small company...like that makes it any better.Theft is theft, period.
Yep, so where did Apple get the idea of the 'Mouse' from ?
Let's face it, Apple and Microsoft are two of the largest technology thieves out there. They just get away with shit due to their crushing size.
i love you!!
getreal
Following the conclusion of Apple they can't make air book pros either. After all its quite clearly a physical design almost identical to *insert whatever company that produces laptops here*. Apparently Apple believes it has a patent on a fucking rectangle and you are stupid enough to buy it.
does that car have four wheels? where did they get that idea? time for Apple to make it's money with quality products instead of suing people
does that car have four wheels? where did they get that idea? time for Apple to make it's money with quality products instead of suing people
Pretty sure it is on a 4 week backorder for the iphone 4s. Meanwhile, vendors have to GIVE Samsung phones away, because nobody wants them!
Oh, so it should be allowed to steal, because it is a small company...like that makes it any better.Theft is theft, period.
It doesn't look like the iPad, that is what the judge said, so this company is not stealing a thing, Apple is just being a bully like always.
So they have had that ruling overturned, but the "war" is still not over. I hope they are successful in suing Apple.
Wonder how they won that argument.
I just have no more words for Apple anymore.
I would go on a rant about how they are trying to shove everyone out of the technological world with their over-priced/under-powered products and flat out lying to people (brainwashing) why you need the latest device from them, but I will not.
One thing I will say, THEY ARE TRYING TO PATENT A FREAKN' RECTANGLE!!!
It's a great day for the small guy though. Karma is a bitch and I hope that Apple gets what is rightly coming to them with all the s**t they have pulled lately.
apparently spanish judges are the only ones that can't be bribed.
i love spanish courts.
they are the best ones with not siding with big businesses, look up the ds and supercard. it has legitimate uses, but has been banned most places, but spain sold nintendo to screw off a while back.
nintendo was almost as bad back in the day as apple is now, by getting it to be a crime in japan to rent games in any form to people, even if they are perks you get when renting a hotel room.
Pretty sure it is on a 4 week backorder for the iphone 4s. Meanwhile, vendors have to GIVE Samsung phones away, because nobody wants them!
Yes i'm sure the 27 million smartphones (plus who knows how many stupid phones) that Samsung distributed in the last 3 months were all given away for free. They are the #1 phone maker in the world because they don't know how to do anything except copy Apple.
The real reason Apple wants injunctions against Samsung is because Samsung has a superior product that cost's less. It was only a matter of time before they fell, and I don't think strapping an Apple TV to a regular TV, and calling it iTV will do much to save them.
Unless, of course, Nuevas bought a judge, or the judge was being a nationalist.
Karma is a bitch and I hope that Apple gets what is rightly coming to them with all the s**t they have pulled lately.
The former CEO surely got a taste of karma, having the workers who produced the company's wealth die due to the working conditions in the factories while stockpiling billion after billion in the bank while claiming a few dollars raise per product was out of the question!
" an injunction against Nuevas Tecnologias have have dismissed commercial and criminal charges brought against them by apple"
Looks like the OP was discombobulated by the news... Sorry, buddy, but Apple took it on the chin this time...
bribed? the truth is much darker. Apple has remotely turned on the camera on their devices, catch several judges in their indiscrete moment, upload them to HQ, and use them as leverage to sway the judges' opinions.
Ouch. Good for N.T.
The real reason Apple wants injunctions against Samsung is because Samsung has a superior product that cost's less.
I appreciate your rebuttal and valid discussion (non-flame), but let's stay on topic here and be realistic. Apple is not suing because it is afraid of competition; Samsung shamelessly made a replica of the iPhone from the packaging to the icons and UI and called it its own. Regardless, Apple is still having no problems selling out of its phones, so the lawsuits are merely to discourage more blatant copying.
I don't like tablets.... but I would even buy one this Spanish tablets...
just to stick it to Apple.
Serves you right R(otten)-apple!!! At the end of the day you're nothing more than a thief and a bully. But when you get the spank in the ass you act like the victim.