Archived from groups: alt.tv.tech.hdtv (
More info?)
Interestingly enough, I had a chance to see the HLP5063 next to the
"Captain Kirk" 50" yesterday and honestly... I could not see much
difference if any. I was at CC and they had the Olympic feed on, and
neither set showed any pixelization/artifacting during any fast action
or splashes.
I spoke with two of the guys that worked there, and one was a
bona-fide techno geek, explained the dimpled mirrors and stuff to me
(which I had already read about). But the bottom line was that if I
was buying a 50" I think I'd be pretty happy with the HLP5063 for two
reasons; one being the price, the other being that the Captain Kirk's
design just does not appeal to me in any way, shape, or form. The
huge triangular plexi base will be a dust collector extraordinaire,
and the fact that it would require a separate stand for any sort of
components is a bummer. It's also the first Samy to use outboard
"wing" speakers so the unit is about a foot wider than it needs to be.
And I'm saying this as a professional industrial designer, not just a
consumer.
What seems to be up in the air is when the HLP5674W 56" HD2+ "regular"
Tantus tabletop model will be released. That is a set that interests
me because it's supposedly only 49.6" wide but goes edge to edge with
a 1/4" molding and not 2" black strips.
But back to the original matter... most retailers are heavily
discounting the "older" HLN models, and I think it _IS_ worth the
extra $500 or so to get the HLP5063W with the HD3 chip (poor man's
version of the HD2+) over last year's model.
On Wed, 18 Aug 2004 12:08:49 -0400, David Pear
<davidp@atlargemarketing.com> wrote:
>I read many good reviews online about this TV. There is a third generation
>model that just recently came out (HLP5063W) which costs about $500 more
>than the second generation (HLN5065W). I'm wondering if it's worth spending
>the money on the newer model. If anyone has experience with this product or
>similar DLP rear projection TVs please reply.
>
>Thanks!
>