Help me decide on these 2 laptops?

Solution

soccerjchen

Estimable
Jan 30, 2016
3
0
4,520
The Dell should have a superior processor, though it may not be as efficient with regards to battery life as it is a higher thermal power dissipation rating (45W as opposed to 15W for the AMD). It looks like AMD has done better with its newest mobile CPU/GPU chips, which in the past were outclassed in most respects by Intel's offerings (aside from niche cases where a user wanted the APU for moderate gaming at low cost compared to Intel's integrated graphics chips).

The nVidia GTX 960 on the Dell is probably going to be similar with regards to graphics performance to the R9 M380 on the Lenovo, but the GTX 960 on the Dell should still outclass it if even only by a little.

The biggest factor for difference is likely going to be the solid state drive (SSD) on the Dell vs the standard traditional spinning hard-drive for the Lenovo. Yes, the Lenovo has nearly 4x the amount of storage space, but it will be noticeably slower when booting up, loading programs, and loading games. This difference is going to be more noticeable than anything with regards to the CPU or GPU between these two computers. A good SSD will be able to cut boot-up and load-up times by 2x-4x the time of a regular HDD, so the Dell is a clear winner here. If you absolutely need the space on your laptop, the 1TB is useful (i.e. significant amounts of media, music, etc). However, your best bet is the SSD if you can live with the 256GB and use an external HDD or cloud storage for your back-up and media files. Since the Dell is cheaper to begin with, it is probably your best bet.

Either way, you will probably be able to upgrade the storage on either device by buying a larger SSD if you need (for example, getting a 500-512GB SSD drive to replace the 256 if you need the space. Just make sure you find out what connector the HDD/SSD uses (SATA, mSATA, m.2, etc).

You should also look at weight, size, ports, and battery life to take those into account with regards to your preferences.
 

Mudig88

Estimable
Mar 3, 2014
4
0
4,510


For me, I've had a terrible experience with Dell laptops and built quality. A few years ago I got an Alienware Laptop and had to deal with Dell's atrocious customer service and the laptop was supposed to be top of the line, well built and reliable but it was neither of those things. I've also read that on paper the M380 is supposed to be quite a bit faster than the GTX 960m but I can't find any reliable benchmark tests since the M380 isn't in many laptops. The SSD in the Dell is pretty attractive because I don't require to have that much space in a laptop anyway...256gb seems quite enough. This is a tough one. The CPU for the Lenovo is the only thing that I'm afraid of. I'm not sure what the exact CPU it is and it's not giving out much info. Do you know which one it is?
 

soccerjchen

Estimable
Jan 30, 2016
3
0
4,520




Here is a link to the PassMark CPU comparisons between the two. The Dell has the Intel i5-6300HQ quad core processor. The Lenovo has the AMD-FX8800P (it's listed on the best buy site if you scroll down). The Intel CPU wins out as expected (you'll need to copy/paste because I think the link doesn't work properly):

=2632&cmp[]=2567]http://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare.php?cmp[]=2632&cmp[]=2567

These are synthetic benchmarks, so take them with a grain of salt. However, Intel has been producing better chips than AMD in general since 2006 and it looks like that hasn't changed significantly.

I couldn't find much info on the R9 380 in terms of benchmarks. I've only seen very little information. The 960m has been used in many laptops and there's plenty of info on it. Notebookcheck classifies the 960m as an upper mid-range graphics card for notebooks. It classifies the R9 380 as an upper mid-range graphics card for notebooks. Again, grain of salt with regards to what that means. I've only been able to guess based on the specs of the card. But maybe the R9 380 is significantly faster... I can't say. But with the 960m, at least you can find out exactly what you're expecting for that card and its performance (see links below).

960m: http://www.notebookcheck.net/NVIDIA-GeForce-GTX-960M.138006.0.html
R9 380: http://www.notebookcheck.net/AMD-Radeon-R9-M380.147253.0.html

I've seen build quality go both ways. Few companies have truly stellar low-cost and mid-range laptops. Usually, you'll see better parts and build quality on more expensive laptops ($1000+). You can probably look at some reviews to see what others have complained about and take that into consideration. I personally have never owned a Dell or Lenovo laptop so I can't comment. I've had friends with good and bad comments for both, so they seem to come out pretty even to me.

Take a look here also: http://www.laptopmag.com/articles/laptop-brand-ratings

It doesn't make your experience with Dell any better, but it's just some more information. This is also from 2014, so, more grains of salt to be taken! :)

To be honest, the Dell stands out as the better laptop in my opinion, on paper, if all else is equal (build quality, weight, service, battery life, noise, keyboard, trackpad, screen quality, heat, etc). Of course, not all else is equal, so you have to weigh the specs with the differences in those factors and make the best decision for you. The SSD and CPU are the stand out features for me. If you plan on upgrading the HDD in the Lenovo for a SSD, then that won't matter as much, but you'd also need to spend another ~$100 to get the SSD.
 
Solution