Which Laptop you Recommend among these 2 HP Envy?

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630
Hi guys,

I want to buy a beast Core i7. I've 2 in consideration. Please tell me which 1 you recommend. In Option B, I see the only difference is 24GB SSD, which I don't feel is much space, but plese try to convince me if I should get Option B & why).

Option A).
HP Envy 15-J039TX Core i7 4700MQ-2.4GHZ
8GB RAM
1TB HDD
15.6" LED
Win 8
NVIDIA 2GB GRAPHIC-
CAM-FP-
6 CELL BATTERY

Option B).
HP Envy 15-J138TX Core i7 4700MQ-2.4GHZ
8GB RAM
1TB HDD & 24GB SSD DRIVE
15.6" LED
Win 8
2GB GRAPHIC-
CAM-FP-
6 CELL BATTERY

Thanks.
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610
Before a good recommendation can be given I need to know your primary and secondary uses for the proposed laptop. I don't really consider any computer "bad". They all have a given area in which they are useful, some more than others.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


My USAGE:
I'll buy for professional as well as for personal use. Office work, graphics designing (Photoshop), lots of browsing, lots of movies, lots of programs running at the same time (Skype, Word, Excel, Email Outlook, Firefox, Chrome, IE, Filezilla, Dropbox etc. etc. I need them running all at once), so I need performance to be EXCELLENT & Peaceful.

My perception with my current HP g6 Pavilion ci3 2.5Ghz 4GB ram is, when the processor gets more busy, it stars getting hot & fans starts running fast & a fast fan means I start to heat up as well lol, its just irritating when it gets noisy.

What you recommend? And do you have another recommendation apart from the above 2?

Thanks.
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610


This is probably a stupid question, but I have to ask it to feel better. Question: "Is it a necessity for it to be a laptop?" The reason that I ask is that a desktop simply offers superior performance in basically every category. With that said, I will go ahead with my pick of the two laptops, along with an explanation as to why I picked it.

Seeing as the computers seem to be identical except for the SSD, I would choose the one with the SSD 1,000 out of 1,000 times. If you have never used a computer with even a "ho-hum" SSD, then you will be ELATED with the performance that it offers! Albeit that it's a small SSD (I'm guessing that only the OS is on it), you will love it. As a matter of fact, I would strongly recommend that you at least look over and consider a computer with an SSD as the primary hard drive, while purchasing a good external drive for storing very large and/or rarely used files. A good candidate for this external drive would be this 1TB, 63 dollar solution from WD. As you can see by the reviews, it is a very good product. And no one can argue with the price! This hard drive is in the relatively still new field of "Portable Personal Cloud", another good addition to computer technology.

http://www.amazon.com/Passport-Ultra-Portable-External-Backup/dp/B00EAS8KSW/ref=sr_1_4?s=pc&ie=UTF8&qid=1396212960&sr=1-4&keywords=portable+cloud+storage

The SSD (in my humble opion), is the greatest thing to happen to computers since the invention of the internet. They deliver performance that a conventional HDD can only dream about.

If you have any more questions, please feel free to ask.
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610
One more addition to support my recommendation:

Your main uses are in the fields that really make an SSD effective. While not necessarily great for gaming, SSD's are literally 10 times as fast or faster at loading the OS, programs, and large files. You in particular will benefit greatly from this due to your uses of the computer.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630
Thanks.

Both these laptops have a dedicated graphics cards. NVIDIA GeForce GT 740M (2 GB DDR3 dedicated)

Price difference is about $55.

You've a very Good Processor Vs Ram point. I'm also interested to improve my current laptop's performance, but I'm not sure what exactly will help. First thing I thought of is, Upgrading Ram to 8 RAM (i.e Max allowed on this machine). 2 modules of 4GB + 4GB as Dual channel, but then I'll have to sell my current rams. Do you think this Solution will help with the Processor giving too much processing & eventually getting heat up issue? ?

Thanks.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


OK SSD sounds good then. I also think this 24GB SSD is for OS, but my next question is, isn't it too small? I mean normally we install most of the softwares to the same Drive as our OS, which is C: traditionally. And all these programs need more & more space, like my current C drive is over 35GB, so how will this SSD carry all these programs & future new installations? DOES IT EVEN WORK LIKE THIS? Or in this new SSD scenario its all different & only OS uses SSD while all other programs are installed on C drive? Or may be I should ask, is there even the concept of Drive C, in the presence of SSD? Will this 24GB SSD only & always keep just the SSD on it & nothing else?

Thanks for recommending to buy a portable HD, but I already have a WD Passport size 1TB hard drive.
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610


As a rule of thumb, I simply do not upgrade laptops. My reasoning is that you are EXTREMELY limited in what you can update anyway. Besides a new hard drive and better RAM, you're stuck with what you bought. This is ESPECIALLY true when it comes to GPUs. Laptops have the GPU soldered in and are a permanent fixture in the machine. It is best when buying a laptop to overkill and go for a bit more than you need, as this will give you better usable life from your machine. If you get only what you need now, in 2 years you could be stuck with a computer that doesn't get the job done anymore. With a desktop, you can simply upgrade. But unfortunately this just isn't an option with a laptop.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


Ok, I'll give a Ram Upgrade a try as well. I just checked the Asus laptop, its way to expensive than my budget in my country. Thanks.
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610
If you already have a portable 1TB external drive, then the only thing that I would settle for is a laptop with an SSD as the primary drive. I do not mind helping you to locate a suitable model that incorporates this. It seems that you are wanting an HP Envy, which is a good computer, so I will try to find an Envy model that is identical to the ones that you have picked out so far, only with an SSD as the primary hard drive. If your primary use of the laptop would be for gaming, then I wouldn't really worry so much. But your uses will enable you to get the absolute most out of the abilities and strengths of an SSD. Give me a few minutes and I'll be back with the results of my search. :)
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


Yes dustinhunt78, I agree with you. That is one reason I first asked for a better laptop recommendations instead of asking for a Ram Upgrade. Bcoz if I go for Ram upgrade, I only have 2 slots which are already occupied with a 2GB each Ram module, so in order to replace those, I've to buy 2 new 4GB modules, & TRY to sell the old ones. New Rams will cost me around $90 in my country and even after that, 1). I'm not sure if its going to give smooth performance, 2). After couple of years, I'll again have speed issues.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


Thanks. Well I may play some games on it since there will be a dedicated graphics card, so why not use it, but gaming will not be one of my primary uses, bcoz I also have an Xbox360. But still I may play some games which are only on PC, like Sims 3, Sims 4 (Upcoming) etc
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610
No worries about this computer being able to game. My primary purpose of encouraging the inclusion of a SSD is because of your main intended uses is because you will see a huge gain in performance. While this computer will certainly be able to game, the SSD will not affect gaming that much. But for your main uses, you will see a HUGE jump in performance.

And what was the price of the 2 laptops that you picked out? I want to make sure that I stay at least close. My design will be slightly higher because of the primary drive being an SSD, but it won't be outrageous. But I need the price so that I have a standard to go by.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


The prices are I got are not in USD, they're in my local currency, which roughly makes about $850 to $950. I doubt you can find a model in US which is available in Asia.

Also, my next question is, isn't 24GB too small? I mean normally we install most of the softwares to the same Drive as our OS, which is C: traditionally. And all these programs need more & more space, like my current C drive is over 35GB, so how will this SSD carry all these programs & future new installations? DOES IT EVEN WORK LIKE THIS? Or in this new SSD scenario its all different & only OS uses SSD while all other programs are installed on C drive? Or may be I should ask, is there even the concept of Drive C, in the presence of SSD? Will this 24GB SSD only & always keep just the SSD on it & nothing else?
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610


Windows 8.1 requires 20GB in the 64 bit version, so that 24GB is pretty much only for the OS. As with any hard drive, the whole 24GB is more than likely non-usable.

I am unable to find an HP Envy model with the option of having an SSD installed. I wouldn't be so determined to find you a laptop with an SSD if I knew that it wouldn't really make the difference between having what you consider a good machine and having a great machine. If having an SSD included in your computer isn't an option, I would even go so far as to contact HP through live chat and request to order a computer WITHOUT a hard drive and just purchase one on your own. I really do feel that strongly about it. If you had even a 250/256GB SSD in your computer, it would be sufficient. That would leave you plenty of room for OS, frequently used programs and frequently used files. And you can get one of the very best SSD's on the market in the Samsung 840 Evo for around 140 US dollars. If you can get them to ship you a computer without a hard drive (and without the cost of a hard drive included), you can get out paying little more for a computer WITH an SSD. Buying the right computer, one that fits your specified, personal needs is a big deal. You are making a substantial investment and I would hate to see you get something that isn't perfectly tailored to your needs. ESPECIALLY since the price difference isn't really all that much.

Here is a link to the SSD that I would recommend for you. I am also going to find a comparison between this drive and a conventional HDD just to show you how much more performance and speed that you will gain. Give me just a few minutes on the comparison.

http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Electronics-EVO-Series-2-5-Inch-MZ-7TE250BW/dp/B00E3W1726/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1396217234&sr=8-1&keywords=250gb+samsung+840+evo
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610


Well, he IS going to be using/loading/saving larger files from what I gather. I mentioned somewhere that an SSD isn't that big of a deal with someone who only games, but his application of the computer will certainly gain a great deal of performance with the use of an SSD. I've said this before and I'll say it again......people who have not fallen in love with the performance of an SSD are people who simply have not used them to any extent. Read/Write speeds are at LEAST 10 times as fast, they fun absolutely silent because they have no moving parts, and their lifetime is longer than that of an HDD now. Earlier models had a problem with lifespan, but they have GREATLY improved on this, now exceeding that of conventional hard drives. Some models even boast over 1 million hours of life.

SSD "naysayers" are almost always people whose main use of a computer is gaming (because that isn't where their true strength is), or people who are just unfamiliar with them and haven't used them to any length of time.
 

bruce20

Honorable
Feb 23, 2013
105
0
10,630


Ok, I'm happy to buy the laptop with SSD. This one seems fine.
http://www.myshop.com.pk/laptop-pakistan/hp-envy-touchsmart-15-j138tx-f9z55pa-pakistan.html

BUT I'm still confuse for the 24GB size, I see you recommended to get a model from hp without harddisk & buy a separate SSD, but in our country its not quite possible to deal directly with HP, bcoz importers import hp products & distribute to local vendors, who sell the whole laptop, without opening the laptop/removing hardware from it.

So I'm still stuck with the "24GB SIZE" Question. I agree, 24GB will be enough for OS ALONE, but what about the other lots of programs that are installed in Program Files or in same drive as the OS (Like we've been doing for last 20 years)? Is 24GB (Small Size) going to cause a problem for it? Bcoz if THIS is going to be a problem that I can't install anything more than OS in the SSD, the other option I've is, I can install them in C or another Drive, but then the question is, Is it NECESSARY (A MUST) to install all other programs on a drive, other than SSD? If not then what is the point of creating such small 24GB SSD, that can only store OS?

Thanks.
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610


That's just it! He CAN afford to go with an SSD. He has the computer picked out that he desires, make and model We were just trying to figure out how to get an SSD in it instead of an HDD. We've been working on this for about an hour. I'm going to get back to trying to figure out a solution for him now. Thanks for your input! :)
 

dustinhunt78

Estimable
Feb 22, 2014
64
0
4,610


I am very aware of this and have been from the very beginning. Read the posts. What I am TRYING to do is to get it shipped from the factory with a true SSD in it. Having it shipped without a hard drive at all is another thing that was discussed (if you read the posts). The 24GB partition is just big enough for the OS. 250GB SSD as the primary drive is the goal. And no offense, but again I find myself having to repeat. Please, no hard feelings, but repeating myself isn't getting anything done! :) I really do appreciate you offering help though.