Which of these two low budget laptops is better?

odin6786

Honorable
Dec 14, 2013
2
0
10,510
http://www.staples.com/Asus-X551MA-156-Laptop/product_573082

http://h10025.www1.hp.com/ewfrf/wc/document?docname=c02625184&cc=us&dlc=en&lc=en

My mom has the HP, I think the fan on the processor is dying though as it gets really loud and shakes now. By loud, i mean loud like it hitting or grinding on something. I am either going to give her my Macbook Pro, which i honestly don't want to part with, or buy her the one from Staples. But, i don't want this to be a downgrade for her. I can't spend more than $250, i have too many other things on my plate right now. But for her, i am willing to part with my MBP.

Opening up her old HP now, but if i can't fix it i want to know if the Asus is at the very least a sidestep from the HP. Or is it a downgrade?

EDIT: Forgot to mention she will be mainly playing facebook games on it. Farmwars 3 or whatever the hell people do on facebook.
 
Solution
Try the replacement fan. The hairball clogging may have killed it.

The name Celeron got bad press early on. Now, it is just another product line.

odin6786

Honorable
Dec 14, 2013
2
0
10,510
So i just cleaned a hairball from the fan, and took a can of air to it. But it still does it. I think the bearing is going or something. But i actually found a replacement fan for $20. So, i may go that route.

So are the processors on those laptops about equal you think? I have hated celerons forever now. What about the graphics? I want her to have the option of playing some other stuff if she wants, she might download a few things on Steam, mainly point and click adventures.
I know 250 really limits me, that's why i'm willing to part with my laptop if it comes to it, i have a PC and she doesn't. Plus she loves the Macbook...but so do i :p